AtmanIsBrahman

Is IQ is a Valid/Meaningful Measure of Intelligence?

51 posts in this topic

I've been researching IQ a lot recently. 

Intelligence feels like a very important part of this work, so it feels like our duty to evaluate our own intelligence if a tool exists to do so.
(As a quick note, I'm talking about plain regular intelligence here, not mystical intelligence. That seems like a different domain and would complicate the picture significantly.)

I initially thought it's silly to quantify intelligence and there's no way IQ can be a good measure of it anyway considering it involves math and language -- cultural constructs. 

But I realized there is actually good science backing it up. General intelligence -- the mysterious thing that makes people who do well on one cognitive task do well on others -- is very well observed. IQ is just a way of quantifying general intelligence, which is done through a variety of tests that are given a correlation with G from 0.0-1. The interesting thing is that progressive matrix problems and mental rotation problems tend to correlate well with G and also correlate with crystallized intelligence tests like vocabulary. This means that what IQ measures might not be culturally constructed, but a real innate faculty of someone's mind. 

Regardless, it seems obvious if we're honest that some people are more intelligent than others. Not just in some things but across the board. And we should want to know where we stand in the pecking order if we're committed to truth, as much as it could hurt our feelings. 

I wonder whether IQ would correlate with someone's progress in spirituality or their epistemic ability.
I don't know exactly where I stand on this. The IQ topic is super complicated, and people are ideological on both sides.

What do you think? 
Is IQ valid, and would you take an IQ test?

 

 

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@AtmanIsBrahman the only real intelligence is consciousness, how conscious you are, guess what, no one is, not even all these spiritual people singing "om namah shivaya" barely anyone is conscious and lives life in accordance. The most intelligent person I know is the most conscious, brave person that I know, not the most intelligent, because he knows 1 + 1 = 2 therefor he is intelligent. Look at autistic people, they are intelligent only in a certain area, their mind is sharp, but they can't pick up if someone is feeling good/bad/frustrated etc. They can't read energy properly, that is not intelligence, that is being stuck in your head. I know a guy that just like me, can read peoples energies from a distance, he is the most intelligent person I know. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm also not sure. 

On one hand, it seems wrong to say that spirituality is limited to 5-10% of the population with a high IQ. 

At the same time, it obviously takes some brain power to understand advanced spiritual concepts.

Edited by enchanted

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Olaf said:

@AtmanIsBrahman the only real intelligence is consciousness, how conscious you are, guess what, no one is, not even all these spiritual people singing "om namah shivaya" barely anyone is conscious and lives life in accordance. The most intelligent person I know is the most conscious, brave person that I know, not the most intelligent, because he knows 1 + 1 = 2 therefor he is intelligent. Look at autistic people, they are intelligent only in a certain area, their mind is sharp, but they can't pick up if someone is feeling good/bad/frustrated etc. They can't read energy properly, that is not intelligence, that is being stuck in your head. I know a guy that just like me, can read peoples energies from a distance, he is the most intelligent person I know. 

I totally get what you're saying, but I think this is conflating mystical intelligence with normal intelligence. 

I do believe that mystical intelligence is a thing that is transcendent and even more valuable than normal intelligence. But I also think it would be wrong to act as though normal intelligence isn't a real thing.


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Leo Gura What do you think the key limitations are?

Is it that the G which IQ tests measure is too narrow a form of intelligence?

How would you explain the differences in career outcomes, lifespan, and so many other things that are correlated with it?

I’m pretty sure you would agree that some people are more intelligent than others. It seems reasonable that this intelligence could be approximated somehow.

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel generally icky about any scoring system at all for people. You collapse something multi-dimensional and context sensitive into a single finite biased number. It's both inhuman and meaningless. The only reason for doing it at all seems to be for comparison and rejection and both of those things seem questionable. However, I'm not strongly against it as a way of having fun, I just wouldn't hang anything at all off of the results.


Truth as process not object

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, LastThursday said:

I feel generally icky about any scoring system at all for people. You collapse something multi-dimensional and context sensitive into a single finite biased number. It's both inhuman and meaningless.

I think you guys are taking the easy way out. 

Let’s say Leo takes an IQ test tomorrow and posts the results.

Would you feel the same way about his teachings whether he scored 100 or 150?

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bare minimum is a Epistemology Test. EsQ.


How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think IQ captures intelligence. IT captures a specific kind of pattern recognizing aspect of mind. 

To me intelligence just is like a processor in a computer, the better the processor the faster the task will get completed. That's about it.

To be a genius however, depends on how long the person has been contemplating a problem. If a dumb guy took 20 years and an intelligent guy takes 10 or 5 years to figure it out, that's about the difference I can think off. But to stay with one problem and be curious about it for years, that's something beyond intelligence.
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Vido said:


To me intelligence just is like a processor in a computer, the better the processor the faster the task will get completed. That's about it.

To be a genius however, depends on how long the person has been contemplating a problem. If a dumb guy took 20 years and an intelligent guy takes 10 or 5 years to figure it out, that's about the difference I can think off.

I’m not sure about this. Somebody with low enough intelligence can never solve the problems that a genius can solve even given infinite time.
 

Can a normal person make discoveries like Nikola Tesla? I really doubt it 

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I’m not sure about this. Somebody with low enough intelligence can never solve the problems that a genius can solve even given infinite time.
 

Can a normal person make discoveries like Nikola Tesla? I really doubt it 

High IQ does not measure creativity.

A test that just asks you to invent stuff would be better then the iq test.

Question: you have a spoon and a stick, what are all the things you can do with it?


How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I’m not sure about this. Somebody with low enough intelligence can never solve the problems that a genius can solve even given infinite time.
 

Can a normal person make discoveries like Nikola Tesla? I really doubt it 

yea. I feel insights are independent of intelligence. Now I'm assuming normal intelligence, like middle of bell curve. However, I feel interest, curiosity, contemplation are important ingredients for getting insights.

I don't think Tesla would have great insights on making music, if you consider him to be a genius. If I forced him to learn music, I don't think he'll be as successful as a person passionate about music and thinks about it all the time. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@AtmanIsBrahman Were you fooled by religion as a kid? Or was it pretty easy for you to see its issues?

Peterson has an IQ of 150 and still cant manage to make sense of it. 

“It isn’t that the Bible is true. It’s that the Bible is the precondition for the manifestation of truth, which makes it way more true than just true. It’s a whole different kind of true.” -peterson

I can see the 150 iq... its impressive.

Still... wrong...

He used all his inteligence to make his paradigm coherent. 

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I found a great marker for intelligence to be how people go about dealing with a chronic illness. Since so many different kinds of intelligence are needed to figure this stuff out. 

Edited by Vynce

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know. I have very low IQ and yet there are people that are way smarter than me that believe the most low IQ things ever.

For example I can't even go to university cause of my IQ but I understood determinism on my own at 13 while some very smart people go 80 and never considered determinism could be true (whether it's true or not doesn't matter, they haven't consider it even  a little).

Or the fact that I found Leo's videos, yes you don't have to be super intelligent to watch Leo's videos, but it takes some kind of intelligence to be interested in this stuff. And yet I have zero humour, and humour takes intelligence.

I don't know, I think there are different types of intelligence (that's what AI have told me). I am bad at every type of intelligence but when it comes to logic I think I am above average. For example many times I think about what the situation is and then reach conclusions while I see most people believing what the majority of people believe. I am not always right of course.

My informatics teacher thought I was a good student cause I was great at problem solving but she was shocked when she saw that I am completely low IQ to other subjects.

 

Honestly I think there are different types of IQ and creativity is the best superpower of intelligence. I completely bad at creativity too, but I was great at analyzation and problem solving

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IQ is like the speed and size of your shovel. Shoveling through the snow of life, it helps you a lot. That doesn't mean you can't slide or find hills that bypasses the shoveling process. But a lot of problems involve shoveling.

Metaphor aside, IQ is quantitative in that it deals with how much, how quick, how big, are the things you are putting inside your mind. It doesn't necessarily deal with how complex things are (that's cognitive complexity). An academic with 160 IQ can make a great normal scientist and teacher, but it does not necessarily make a Newton, an Einstein, a Ken Wilber, people who create the theories that people teach. That requires a certain complexity of mind (meta-systematic, paradigmatic, and upwards).

Similarly, having a high IQ does not necessarily mean you will be spiritually inclined. But it can help you with processing things related to spirituality, in so far they involve processing capacity, speed, etc. In my opinion, spiritual giftedness correlates more with being refined, precise, and a bit of an obsessive person (perhaps "conscientiousness" in the more qualitative or feminine aspects).

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now