Seed

Anyone been following Russell brand’s rape trial?

841 posts in this topic

 


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, LordFall said:

Not only does that show poor judgement but to then double down on helping them commit the defrauding shows a lack of empathy and an incredible amount of selfishness. She's clearly an awful person with low morals.

haha, who is stage green now? jk 

I don't see how we have enough information about this particular woman to justify a confident moral judgement of her character. And in the absence of that info, your starting point should be some reasonable estimate of how ordinary people would behave in the same situation.

And that would ordinarily be a woman who doesn't even know she's doing anything wrong. She's far more likely to be ignorant and self-deceived (because her life depends on it), than intentionally complicit in some malicious act. 

I don't know her well enough to say. I don't even know Brand well enough to call him all the things he's been called. Although it is looking more and more like he's just a total POS, and I definitely lean that way on him. 


What if this is just fascination + identity + seriousness being inflated into universal importance?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Jodistrict said:

The authorities figured out how to disrupt Brand's source of power.

"Russell Brand is reportedly furious after his hair-loss pills were confiscated by prison officials.

The disgraced comedian, 51, is serving 10-and-a-half years behind bars after being convicted of rape and sexual assault and he was secretly transferred from HMP Wandsworth in south London to the Category C facility HMP Littlehey in Cambridgeshire last week. Now a new report suggests he’s worried about losing his trademark long hair after prison officials denied his request to be able to use special shampoo and take a prescription drug called Propecia, which is used to treat male pattern baldness.

A source told the Sun newspaper: “He was kicking off because he’s worried he’s going to lose his hair.

“He takes Propecia pills for his hair, but he had them confiscated inside. He isn’t allowed to take them because they’re not essential. They’re considered cosmetic.

“He asked to have his special Alpecin caffeine shampoo and his Propecia pills.”

https://www.nzherald.co.nz/entertainment/russell-brand-furious-over-confiscated-hair-loss-pills-in-prison/QCN6N2GACNEU7KI6FLD4O2KQ44/

Spoilt brat. To think he is a celebrated individual in our society. 

Much of his antics when he rose to fame were very "lad" bro culture. It was a different time back then - even I was across some of his debauchery and didn't blink. I just recall thinking "men". His antics were... accepted. Men's poor behaviour was not inspected and explained away as "boys will be boys". I suspect more cases will arise and a new trial.

Doesn't fly now. There has been a big shift in cultural tolerance of misconduct.

Contrast to 2026, after the cultural impact of 2017 #MeToo and onwards there has been greater public scrutiny of sexual harassment and workplace power dynamics. Increased criticism of objectification and sexual double standards. Greater awareness of how entertainment can normalise particular attitudes towards women. Changing expectations around consent, boundaries and sexual conduct.

We have progressed past a lot of unconscious acceptance of poor conduct. Not all of these attitudes have been eliminated however- some remain entrenched. Lots of commentators on this case have leaky rhetoric, betraying what appears to be confusion around responsibility.

Edited by Natasha Tori Maru

It is far easier to fool someone, than to convince them they have been fooled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Natasha Tori Maru said:

Much of his antics when he rose to fame were very "lad" bro culture.

Yeah the "lads, lads, lads" culture is rampant in the UK. It's eroding with each generation though. Younger guys I meet when I'm out are a lot less entrenched in all that stuff nowdays, since pop-culture and the influential figures in it are so different. Look at the films Brand was in as well, totally different time. It's not cool to be like Brand anymore, but back then, it was.

Edited by Cubbage

I expected you. 
We have business, You and I...

https://youtube.com/@vivec?si=6no4qYSFDuPQpP6Z

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Cubbage said:

Look at the films Brand was in as well, totally different time. 

Totally. If anyone wants to see a glimpse of what was accepted culturally at the time - just watch his films from 2010-ish 🤢🤮 - or don't, also don't buy his books, fuck giving this dude more money!

I actually cannot comprehend how I just wrote it all off in my head as acceptable. That "lad" culture was just... norm. It is eye opening to how much cultural / societal conditioning effects us. Skews the worldview and morals.


It is far easier to fool someone, than to convince them they have been fooled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Natasha Tori Maru See! Morality and free will RRRRRrrrrr-de-matey a thing! 

To label either as merely a social construct is to dismiss the biological structure behind both.

Second, to take anything from culture as anything other than an outcome to biological function, is to get caught up in the noise that takes away from registering genuine epistemic truths.

Cultural mishmashes are mismatches for establishing generalizable truths, as its like polling the population of a country on what diet I should be on. Some countries will be better than others, "better" here is closer to the actual underlying reality, one's biological makeup, truth, rather than an outcome of "the cultural norms of the time". 

For very large portion of human history the disrepair of biological functions due to lower health standards was normalised into lower empathy and lower awareness. Making morality and free will deterministic constructs, or reserved to those who could "merely afford it" at the time, a classism that benefitted from viewing those with less financial means as somehow less moral and less aware. This was the entire mindset that justified the segregation of both gender, African American populations and other races where splits occurred in the respective culture. With Australia, racism was still very strong as little as 20 years ago. This is in-built to the narratives that are crafted from biological opulence, rather than being anything close to "the outcome of the many or the few reflects the underlying truth". 

Leo's video above, I won't be able to catch all of it, but she begins talking about raising the age of consent. This is not a subject that is merely determined through facts and figures, brain and nervous system regions must be engaged that rule the empathy required to reconstruct the perspectives that generate the morality that corresponds. Increasing education, health, access to information, social networks, incrementalism of human rights, these are not merely changing social norms, these are affordability dynamics that allow the full use of our biological functions to establish agreed upon revised standards. Remove those accommodations, now the cultural conversation suddenly becomes medieval. The culture didn't just change, the biological baseline for what culture can emerge did. The trend will be no different for the future.

Free will exists and it simply means a narrative that originated from the awareness to express it.
Morality exists and it simply means a narrative that originated from the empathy to express it.

Narrative distortion conflates free will vs determinism and biological morality vs purely a cultural construct.  
Narrative signal is something that is always revising and aligning the relationships.

You're very passionate about this subject Natasha, we all see that, its good, we just hope as well that you're looking after yourself and that you are okay. Rock out eh!
 

Edited by oOo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@oOo I am not so perturbed to be overly distracted 😊

Russell Brand is suffering inside. He has been for a very, very long time. I understand the plight of addiction and impulse control. He did damage to others though his suffering. The women hurt too. 

Hurt people, hurt people. 

I probably look like I am on a crusade. But I react more to my own internal changes & realisations, than anything else. Betrayed by my own unconscious conditioning. My self is Judas! If I make sense 🫶🏻

Edited by Natasha Tori Maru

It is far easier to fool someone, than to convince them they have been fooled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, Joshe said:

haha, who is stage green now? jk 

I don't see how we have enough information about this particular woman to justify a confident moral judgement of her character. And in the absence of that info, your starting point should be some reasonable estimate of how ordinary people would behave in the same situation.

And that would ordinarily be a woman who doesn't even know she's doing anything wrong. She's far more likely to be ignorant and self-deceived (because her life depends on it), than intentionally complicit in some malicious act. 

I don't know her well enough to say. I don't even know Brand well enough to call him all the things he's been called. Although it is looking more and more like he's just a total POS, and I definitely lean that way on him. 

I think you're being a bit shallow in terms of analyzing the underlying psychology here. Do you not find it interesting to deconstruct? People have reasons for being attracted to different humans, attraction is not random and is deeply rooted in our own identity. 

There are many of negative character traits we can extrapolate in someone that specifically chooses to entangle her life with a playboy celebrity accused of many sexual assaults. A lot of women would not be attracted to an individual like this. Some other women are more opportunistic, cutthroat, vapid, insecure, cruel, etc. 

There is not much wisdom is refraining to make judgements on people. If we are to have a conversation to understand how problematic behaviour shapes our society and how psychology shapes that behaviour then we have to investigate these things. 

I call out Stage Green people on the forum for defaulting to a victim and passive mindset when encountering problematic situations in the world. Ironically that's what you're doing here by refusing to analyze the psychology deeper. I guess you're using having standards of behaviours and moralizing people as also a Stage Green trait? It can be to a point when it's unproductive or becomes performative outrage but I think that taking 20 mins to reflect on famous criminals and what that teaches us about human nature is a good use of time. 

Edited by LordFall

The dream is not easy but each day we're getting closer

Follow my journey on Instagram @Kylegfall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Which is this trial such a big deal?

Brand is some random celebrity he is not Di Capro or Ronaldo

Not first time celebreties do bad stuff

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, LordFall said:

I think you're being a bit shallow in terms of analyzing the underlying psychology here. Do you not find it interesting to deconstruct?

What is the purpose of the deconstruction? 

What can be known with what degrees of certainty? 

What is the level of effort required to know? 

These questions arise for me at the outset.

Purpose: I'm interested in deconstructing things I haven't already. Brand fits a very similar template that I've already grasped. The whole extroverted morally bankrupt sexual charmer archetype is nothing new for me, so I'm not interested in exploring every single variation that comes up. 

What can be known?: I believe there is enough data to warrant a confident moral judgement against Brand, but not his wife. 

Level of effort: I would need a trove of evidence to analyze for hours before I could even form a hypothesis about the wife's character. 20 minutes is nowhere near enough. And I doubt there's even enough evidence for me to analyze that could justify a confident read. 

As far as I can tell, when it comes to his wife, there's not enough data for you to know much of anything about her. Yet you're here judging her as some monster from a chain of reasoning that doesn't look anything like a well-formed chain. 

4 hours ago, LordFall said:

There is not much wisdom is refraining to make judgements on people. If we are to have a conversation to understand how problematic behaviour shapes our society and how psychology shapes that behaviour then we have to investigate these things. 

I love making judgements, if they're sound.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it appears you arrived at your judgement mostly from focusing on selection effect: only a low-character or morally low woman would be attracted to Brand. Do you have anything more than this + a few YT vids you watched in 20 minutes? 

I have known many good-hearted women who were attracted to the bottom-of-the-barrel lowest scum. And guess what. It's because they couldn't actually see that they were scum. This is far more common than these women being sociopaths or scum themselves. 

Is a man who sleeps with prostitues of low moral character? Maybe. But maybe not. It's a cheap heuristic. You can't actually know just because he sleeps with prostitutes. 

If a woman is sexually attracted to a man who has terrible moral character, what exactly does that establish about her own moral character? Obviously, without more data, fucking zilch! 

You simply cannot infer much about a woman's moral character just because she's attracted to Brand and is standing by him through this after she has built a life and family with him. It's reckless, unless you have actually found and properly assessed good data, which would take hours to do. I for one am not going to spend hours figuring out the wife's moral character. 

5 hours ago, LordFall said:

I call out Stage Green people on the forum for defaulting to a victim and passive mindset when encountering problematic situations in the world. Ironically that's what you're doing here by refusing to analyze the psychology deeper. I guess you're using having standards of behaviours and moralizing people as also a Stage Green trait? It can be to a point when it's unproductive or becomes performative outrage but I think that taking 20 mins to reflect on famous criminals and what that teaches us about human nature is a good use of time. 

I was just fuckin with you about the stage green stuff. I don't place anyone on the spiral.


What if this is just fascination + identity + seriousness being inflated into universal importance?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@LordFall It would be like saying because Trump has a terrible moral character, the majority of his supporters must as well. But actually, the majority of Trump supporters are morally decent people with far higher moral character than Trump. They just fail to see how bad Trump really is. They truly think he's a good person, lol. Same dynamic likely in play here with Brand's wife. 

People can become very attached to someone whose behavior they would condemn in anyone else, precisely because they don't perceive that person the way outsiders do.

Edited by Joshe

What if this is just fascination + identity + seriousness being inflated into universal importance?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

 

Definitely shot himself in the foot doing that.


“The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.” ~ Meister Eckhart

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, LordFall said:

Of course you can blame someone for committing their life to someone accused of violent crimes lol, wtf are you smoking 

Not only does that show poor judgement but to then double down on helping them commit the defrauding shows a lack of empathy and an incredible amount of selfishness. She's clearly an awful person with low morals.

Can you explain why you believe her to be above moral judgement? 

A person doesn't have to earn a large sum of money to be compensated for moral injury especially when that injury occurred some two decades ago. Russell's money eventually goes to his wife and children.

Even the simple act of filing a complaint actually after 20 years; there is something suspicious about this process.

In my view the justice system (much like politics...) should enable a rational and mature society; not listening to emotions (when they aren't in fact consciously or not just a cover; a way to get attention, money...). Once you start giving in, it’s the beginning of the end for a society.

Edited by Schizophonia

Take some Monster

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


 

What are you thoughts on this? @Leo Gura

 

Edited by Seed

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
54 minutes ago, Karmadhi said:

Which is this trial such a big deal?

Brand is some random celebrity he is not Di Capro or Ronaldo

Not first time celebreties do bad stuff

Because Russell is a celebrity that recently converted to christianity and grew a very large following commentating on political and cultural events, positioning himself as an evolved and awake being after a long career of being a degenerate fuck boy. It's an interesting case study given these incidents occurred nearly 2 decades ago and finally caught up with him in the midst of his new identity solidifying into the public zeitgeist.

Edited by pursuitofspirit

“The eye through which I see God is the same eye through which God sees me; my eye and God’s eye are one eye, one seeing, one knowing, one love.” ~ Meister Eckhart

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

His YouTube will channel be banned. 

You absolutely CANNOT make any public statements or interviews while incarcerated. I'm pretty sure it is not allowed.

Nice try Brand. Twisted circumvention.

I see he is denying everything. Nice repentance. If there is another trial this won't be good for him.

Edited by Natasha Tori Maru

It is far easier to fool someone, than to convince them they have been fooled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is an interesting essay written by a priest of the Anglican Church.  He sums it up perfectly.

I was always too busy at church to watch Sunday Service with The Brands on YouTube, where Russell and Laura prayed, chatted and discussed theology. All while wearing dressing gowns and with Brand showing rather a lot of his naked chest. I tend to prefer a clerical shirt and collar but perhaps I’m old-fashioned.

Brand’s many followers were surprised last Sunday to see the show airing again as his wife took the reins. She introduced the episode by quoting from St Paul’s epistle to the Philippians, written from prison and in which he says he’s “in chains for Christ” and his plight will “advance the gospel”.

Lest anyone failed to notice a parallel, Laura read a note from her husband. “As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for,” he wrote. “I don’t know which other men here are not guilty, and the ones that are, they are people that Christ died to save, like you and me, let us all love, pray for, and forgive one another as God forgave us.”

It’s an outrageous juxtaposition. Paul was a selfless devotee of the Gospel and was attacked, incarcerated and finally beheaded for the faith. Brand is in prison for the crimes of sexual assault and rape, after a legitimate trial in which he enjoyed a highly financed defence and was fairly judged.

Paul wasn’t as fortunate but he was a writer of genius and perception. He warned, for example, of alleged Christians who are “not serving our Lord Christ, but their own appetites. By smooth talk and flattery, they deceive the minds of naive people.” He also wrote: “Evil people and charlatans will go from bad to worse, deceiving others and being deceived themselves”. He said: “Such people are false apostles, deceitful workers, masquerading as apostles of Christ”.

Judgment is a tricky issue for Christians because, while we’re told not to do so, we’re also commanded to be wise. Since his baptism less than three years ago in a highly publicised ceremony, Brand’s faith has been ostentatious, even performative, and his embrace of various right-wing Christian conspiracy theories acutely disturbing. At the centre of this ideology is the conviction that the boldly honest will be silenced by the state. Which is exactly what his people believe about Brand and are proclaiming at every opportunity.

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/outrageous-russell-brand-plays-the-victim-unlike-st-paul-hv9rbtgbr

Edited by Jodistrict

Vincit omnia Veritas.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now