Israel / Palestine News Thread

[Breakingthewall]

51 minutes ago, zazen said:

Asking you to examine why October 7th happened, its root cause and the conditions that would lead to it - isn’t justifying it.

Implies that the cause is in the people who was murdered more than in the murderers, it's similar than justifying 

51 minutes ago, zazen said:

The 70% support could be for breaking the siege and the act of resistance itself - not the horrific crimes that were done on the day. For Gazans that was a crack made in a prison wall - that doesn’t mean they supported the brutality of what happened when Hamas went across the wall.

Have you seen the videos? In one, they transport a 20-year-old German girl with her leg bones completely broken, bent 180 degrees, who later died. In her wake, there's a hysterical crowd screaming, raising their hands to the sky, weeping in ecstasy, and many furiously hitting her with sticks. Think about it seriously. What's the reason for such joy? Are they going to achieve something with this action, and that's why they're happy? No, it's pure hatred. It's a satanic ecstasy of pure, absolutely irrational hatred that they've cultivated for generations.

51 minutes ago, zazen said:

Before October 7th - a 2023 Pew survey found nearly half of Jewish Israelis believed Arabs should be expelled or transferred from Israel. Does that justify their punishment? Obviously not.

Well, Knowing that for their Palestinian neighbors, the highest level of humanity is to be a martyr by killing Jews, more than being a doctor, engineer, father, or mother. And that killing a Jew is a direct ticket to eternal paradise, the fact that only 50% of them think about it speaks volumes for the Jews.

51 minutes ago, zazen said:

Whether they’re making Gaza un-livable through starvation or destroying buildings is beside the main point - which is that they are making it un-livable to begin with. You call it destroying Hamas but it’s collective punishment in practice

Well, it's different attacking the bodies than the objects, and the point was knowing if Israel used starving as a weapon. I think they didn't, but maybe they did in some extent, some days, like an warning: What's certain is that photos of skeletal men like those in Auschwitz, when thousands of videos show everyone looking normal, are demagoguery.

51 minutes ago, zazen said:

you rob me then I target you with a nuke - aren’t I in effect collectively punishing everyone around you because of the method and tool I use to “target” you? It’s like trying to blow out a candle with a flamethrower and burning the whole house down - “but I targeted the candle bro my bad”.

Hamas It's an army with a vast network of tunnels. How are you going to fight them? By sending your soldiers to be slaughtered?

Edited 11 hours ago by Breakingthewall

[Raze]

9 hours ago, Breakingthewall said:

I didn't insult you by sending those links. I said that 5 photos of hungry people against 1000 hours of videos of healthy people aren't valid as proof to me.

 

I’m not talking about that, you insulted me and used sarcastic remarks and even AI walls long before I did anything, and kept doing it after I told you to stop. Now you play the victim.

9 hours ago, Breakingthewall said:

I

And regarding the reports from organizations that talk about arm circumference, etc., I said that in a situation like Gaza, food distribution isn't the same as in peacetime. It's also carried out by Hamas. Therefore, it's to be expected that there will be people who aren't perfectly fed. But that's absolutely different from using starvation as a weapon of war. All the food that comes in goes to Israel, the genocidal enemy. And seeing the people after two years, I see that there's no use of hunger as a weapon.

This statement provokes insults from you and very long insulting AI messages that, for you, validate your perspective (strange). So, since I don't like being insulted, I would like to know what to say so as not to provoke your righteous anger thirsty of justice that makes you insult so much. 

No, the food distribution isn’t carried out by Hamas, as per usual you do not know basic things about what you’re talking about.

Youve been discussing this for months now, are you incapable of using basic logic? Do you actually think israel is giving large sacks of food to Hamas and they shake hands and Hamas goes around distributing it? 

It was distributed by the UN, later israel banned them and brought in an American company GHF to do it.

It you are not aware of these basic facts on the ground but still share your opinion over and over arrogantly as though you’re right it’s not my fault the AI calls you a dense idiot.

No, the food doesn’t come from israel, they let the aid organizations in.

Israel purposefully limited food and blocked all aid for 3 months. The finance minister literals stated the purpose was to use it as a war strategy, the former general whose plan they used to limit food said it was a war tactic. 

As you were told multiple times, some people looking healthy is irrelevant, no one said everyone; was dying of starvation. I pointed out how even during worse historical famines most people actually didn’t die of starvation either. 

The AI told you this at least six times, but because you still didn’t get it, the AI started calling you stupid. Because you are, there’s no other word to describe someone so proud of their ignorance who cannot process as a basic concept repeated to them over and over.

I didn’t ask AI to insult you, I asked it to review your claims with forceful language, it correctly called you out for complete ignorance and defensiveness, the terms used are insulting because they are negative, but they’re accurate in this case. 

Edited 11 hours ago by Raze

[Breakingthewall]

24 minutes ago, Raze said:

.

No, the food distribution isn’t carried out by Hamas, as per usual you do not know basic things about what you’re talking about.

No, the food doesn’t come from israel, they let the aid organizations in.

Approximate distribution (2024–2025)

Source of food entering Gaza    Approx. share

Israel (production + distribution)    ≈ 60–75 %
Egypt (via Rafah)    ≈ 20–30 %
Other donors (Turkey, Qatar, Jordan via Egypt)    ≈ 5–10 %
 

About the distribution, who has the power In gaza? Food enter in trucks, who decides where those supplies goes, who stores them? Who controls the streets? 

24 minutes ago, Raze said:

The AI told you this at least six times, but because you still didn’t get it, the AI started calling you stupid

Why are you insulting again? I thought that was enough insulting. Do you feel like threatening or anything? Do you need a hug? Don't insult people.

24 minutes ago, Raze said:

it correctly called you out for complete ignorance

Shit, another insult. I'm so ignorant. Then why you need to insulting again and again? Do you insult all the ignorants? Before you said that im an ignorant because the food is not Israeli. But who could supplies the food for 2 million people during 2 years? Some organizations? It's a serious amount, not some aid. Maybe you should try to think by logic , not by emotions. 

About the starvation, then no people looks starved except those 5 pictures of men and kids almost skeletons that you sent as a proof, but people in general looks normal, and this is compatible with general starvation. Well, sounds bit forced, but if you feel better believing it, that's ok. 

Edited 11 hours ago by Breakingthewall

[Raze]

18 minutes ago, Breakingthewall said:

Approximate distribution (2024–2025)

Source of food entering Gaza    Approx. share

Israel (production + distribution)    ≈ 60–75 %
Egypt (via Rafah)    ≈ 20–30 %
Other donors (Turkey, Qatar, Jordan via Egypt)    ≈ 5–10 %
 

About the distribution, who has the power In gaza? Food enter in trucks, who decides where those supplies goes, who stores them? 

Serious question: do you have dyslexia? Or some other issue that makes it difficult for you to read? This is I believe the third time I’ve seen you quote something to prove your point that actually disproves it.

The very thing you yourself quoted says Israel does the distribution. I’m assuming it’s counting the GHF as israel since it was distributing during that period which is what I said. And thats because israel at that time was blocking the humanitarian organizations. They were spending tens of millions in aid.

 Yet you ignored that and doubled down on Hamas distributing it.

Actually it looks like that’s origin of entrance, not the source of actual aid. That’s why it says Egypt via Rafah. The UN and Europe have spent the most on aid. 

 

Edited 11 hours ago by Raze

[zazen]

@Breakingthewall Your username is literally Breakingthewall. Maybe you’d have a euphoric outburst from breakingthewall on October 7th too - from breaking the siege of your oppressors. Obviously if the euphoria is from the suffering you cause those on the other side of the wall your a sick sadist though. It’s so obvious it’s dumb for me to even have to mention that nuance but you seem to conflate and misread things entirely.

Your now saying that maybe they did use starvation as a weapon but only sometimes.

Your saying its different and okay that their attacking objects (buildings) instead of bodies (civilian) - but attacking the buildings still makes the place un-livable in which those bodies (civilians) live. You just evade and sometimes concede begrudgingly lol

If Hamas are in the tunnels underground then what’s the point of destroying everything above ground including the civilians ability to live there. It only ensures more recruits for Hamas, and more hatred and condemnation from the world.

Edited 10 hours ago by zazen

[Breakingthewall]

14 minutes ago, Raze said:

The very thing you yourself quoted says Israel does the distribution. I’m assuming it’s counting the GHF as israel since it was distributing during that period which is what I said.

 Yet you ignored that and doubled down on Hamas distributing it.

I know it's a complicated idea, I will try to speak easy. Look, in gaza there is a war, then, when it's said that Israel does the distribution means that they deliver the food to the door of Gaza , but they can't do the distribution inside the city. Why? Because if Jews get in, Hamas would kill them! Then, who distributes the food inside the city to the 2 millions of persons one by one? Some volunteers? And what are going to do those volunteers? Who decides inside gaza about everything? Hamas! Bingo!!! If you are inside gaza and Hamas tells you to put the food there, you do. Again, logic is the key.

Edited 10 hours ago by Breakingthewall

[Breakingthewall]

3 minutes ago, zazen said:

Hamas are in the tunnels underground then what’s the point of destroying everything above ground including the civilians ability to live there. It only ensures more recruits for Hamas, and more hatred and condemnation from the world.

I guess that the only way to prevent Hamas from hiding is to eliminate the hiding places. They can't always be in the tunnels.

4 minutes ago, zazen said:

username is literally Breakingthewall. Maybe you’d have a euphoric outburst from breakingthewall on October 7th too - from breaking the siege of your oppressors.

Well, it's different braking walls than breaking lifes and being euphoric knowing that the consequences that are coming are death for your people. Why you can't admit that this is absolutely insane, like a mental illness? You could be happy if you kill your bully and now you are free, but being happy by killing some innocents knowing that the revenge is going to fall in your family is simple being insane 

[Raze]

17 minutes ago, Breakingthewall said:

I know it's a complicated idea, I will try to speak easy. Look, in gaza there is a war, then, when it's said that Israel does the distribution means that they deliver the food to the door of Gaza , but they can't do the distribution inside the city. Why? Because if Jews get in, Hamas would kill them! Then, who distributes the food inside the city to the 2 millions of persons one by one? Some volunteers? And what are going to do those volunteers? Who decides inside gaza about everything? Hamas! Bingo!!! If you are inside gaza and Hamas tells you to put the food there, you do. Again, logic is the key.

So like I said, as per usual you don’t understand basic things about what you’re talking about.

Thats not what distribution means, distribution is what is done inside Gaza, not just letting it into the access point.

You’re very strange, when most people get shown they have basic facts wrong they become either ashamed or humble and maybe look into the issue deeper before talking. Even if they get defensive or won’t admit it they will at least shift the topic or privately begin looking more into what they’re saying to avoid it in the future. You don’t, you just double down and somehow become more confident, you actually become more ignorant the more you discuss the topic and even more confident in your beliefs the more you are proven wrong. as thought you think acting like a stubborn child who denies reality right in front of them over and over will change it, then when people get frustrated with you that’s proof you’re somehow “winning”. It’s an extremely bizarre psychology. 

And no, Israeli officials themselves admitted there was no evidence of Hamas systematically stealing aid.

It’s distributed by handing it out to civilians at aid sites.

you can see examples in this: 

 

Hamas has no capability to steal aid en masse, they numbered 20-40K and were being hunted, they can’t somehow stop aid from getting to 2 million people.

The starvation only began after israel began limiting aid and then blocked all aid from entering for 3 months. Guess what happened when they stopped, the starvation reduced. That had nothing to do with Hamas.

Edited 10 hours ago by Raze

[zazen]

14 minutes ago, zazen said:

Obviously if the euphoria is from the suffering you cause those on the other side of the wall your a sick sadist though. It’s so obvious it’s dumb for me to even have to mention that nuance but you seem to conflate and misread things entirely.

@Breakingthewall I literally said if the euphoria is coming from the killing itself then it is insane and sick.

Anyway - is this how AIPAC Zionists approached you:

If you’re getting a yatch I want an invite next year for 2026 season. Let’s go Ibiza and Formentera papi.

[Breakingthewall]

9 hours ago, Raze said:

You’re very strange, when most people get shown they have basic facts wrong they become either ashamed or humble and maybe look into the issue deeper before talking

You insulted me before because I said that Israel provides the food, then I gave the information that Israel provides 75% of the food, and you insulted me again.

 

9 hours ago, Raze said:

So like I said, as per usual you don’t understand basic things about what you’re talking about.

Thats not what distribution means, distribution is what is done inside Gaza

Then you said before, just after insulting, that in the IA text that I posted says that the 75% of supply and distribution of food comes from Israel, then I explained you that inside of Gaza Israel doesn't go, because I side gaza is Hamas who controls , so the food goes where Hamas says. It's quite simple, read again, you will see that you can get it

9 hours ago, Raze said:

Even if they get defensive or won’t admit it they will at least shift the topic or privately begin looking more into what they’re saying to avoid it in the future. You don’t, you just double down and somehow become more confident, you actually become more ignorant the more you discuss the topic and even more confident in your beliefs the more you are proven wrong

Maybe you are talking about yourself. Here we are talking about where the aid comes from and who distributes. You insulted me because I said that Israel supply, then I show you than I was right, and now you really believe that it's you who said it. Anyone who reads this can see it.

9 hours ago, Raze said:

you think acting like a stubborn child

You think that by insulting you will become more right, but it doesn't work like that, believe me. Over all when you insulted before for an statement I said, and then showed you it was true

9 hours ago, Raze said:

And no, Israeli officials themselves admitted there was no evidence of Hamas systematically stealing aid.

I didn't say Hamas stole the aid, as many Palestinians have confirmed, but it decides where it's stored, who it's given to, and when. There also seems to be a black market where everything is sold for very high prices. Where does that money go?

9 hours ago, Raze said:

Hamas has no capability to steal aid en masse, they numbered 20-40K and were being hunted, they can’t somehow stop aid from getting to 2 million people.

Some aid is taken directly by people but there are 2 millions of people in gaza, food must delivered inside by the Gazans and Gazans are ruled by Hamas. There are plenty of testimonies from Gazans saying that Hamas keeps food, distributes it as it wishes and sells it. Hamas maybe are just 35k but they have the power and weapons. it's like saying that in a city there are just 30k of cops then they can't decide what the people does, they do in great extent. 2 millions ÷35.000 is like 50, not so much people to handle

Try to discuss without insulting and distorting what is said . It is tiring

Edited 1 hour ago by Breakingthewall