Insightful27

I emailed this to my philosophy professor and asked if this was evidence against materialism, here is his reply (he is a materialist) I was tempted a few years ago to write something about this very question, but I never did, though I was satisfied that the reports of people with NDE’s could be explained consistently with materialism. For there to be a problem for materialism, there needs to be conscious experience at the same time as there is no brain activity of a kind sufficient (given materialism) for conscious experience. So it’s not enough to show that at some time the patient’s brain exhibited no activity, and at some time the patient had a conscious experience; the two times must be the same. But it’s very hard to pinpoint the times of the two things. It is not true that brain activity simply ceases entirely when the heart stops, but as far as I can tell it’s very hard to determine how far relevant brain activity has entirely stopped after someone’s heart has stopped, in part because we don’t really know which brain activity is relevant to sustaining conscious experience, and in part because we can’t easily tell what, if anything, is going on deep in the brain of someone in the ER. Apparently, though, some brain activity continues for a surprisingly long time—several minutes—after the heart stops. And it’s hard to say when the conscious experience reported by a patient actually took place. There seem to be two ways in which we might tell. First, we might take the patient’s word for it. But if someone is revived and reports having had certain experiences five minutes ago (or whatever), we can’t just assume that their sense of when they had the experiences is correct. After all, when you remember your dreams, you typically can’t say when you did the dreaming, and even if you had a sense that it was some time ago, rather than just now, that might sense well be inaccurate. Second, we might find a match between the content of the conscious experience reported (for example, what the patient seemed to hear) and sounds (e.g., of human speech) actually made while the patient was unresponsive. If the match is surprising enough that we take the experience to have been veridical (e.g., the nurse spoke of her dog, Felix), then we have a time for when the experience occurred. However, we’ve all seen TV shows of people in the ER “dying” and being revived, so we can easily imagine what might be said in such circumstances; that’s why the match has to be surprising. I’m skeptical that the match is ever that surprising. There is a skeptical literature on NDE’s and their significance for materialism. An activist scholar named Keith Augustine has written on the topic, but I’m sure there are others. For some psychologists, NDE’s are just an interesting psychological phenomenon to investigate; they’re not gunning for materialism. For all I know, there’s experimental work too. Let me add one more thing. If conscious experience occurs in the absence of any brain activity at all, then not only is materialism false, but so too are those forms of dualism that take certain kinds of brain activity to be (merely) causally necessary (and sufficient) for conscious experience. The snag is that these are the most plausible forms of dualism, since they accommodate the fact that ordinarily, as far as we can tell, we enjoy conscious experience of different kinds only when our brains are undergoing certain kinds of activity. Dualists would need to explain why, ordinarily, my auditory cortex has to be active for be to have auditory experiences , but not in the case of NDE’s. There is already a problem for dualists to explain what the brain does for the mind if the mind is immaterial; but the problem is aggravated if NDE’s are experiences in the absence of all brain activity.

This reading was assigned to me in class, I can't believe that this got published in NIH. It is a near death experience of a neuroscientist of 20 years. Must read. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6170087/ "Communication there goes light years beyond our simplistic linear thinking, beyond the bottleneck of linguistically constrained awareness we experience in these physical bodies in the earthly realm." "I came to see that unconditional love has the potential to bring infinite healing."

I found this post from JP taking about Jung's concept of circumambulation of the self and immediately made the connection to the way Deida talked about purpose in Way of The Superior Man. Basically the concept is that you have a series of mini-purpose's that you need to work through, like the layers on an onion. As you work through them you get closer to your true self and what you really desire. Any thoughts about this or about how this ties in with Leo's idea about life purpose?

@OBEler You make good points. I think I will take an extended break from Actualized. However, I do still see spirituality as a core part of my life and Life Purpose.

@OBEler Right, but "spiritual teacher" is actually pretty vague. There are a lot of ways to be a "spiritual teacher", for example I want to earn my PhD is Psychology and become a psychedelic therapist.

@Space Right, I am still learning how to use AI to get more specific answers

I am in the process of trying to find a meditation cushion that doesn't put my feet to sleep. I think that the cosmic meditation cushion might work and I wanted to ask here and see if anyone had any feedback if they have tried the cushion. https://www.sagemeditation.com/cosmic-cushion-and-zabuton-meditation-cushion-set/?revpage=2 #product-reviews

@Space Hard to put in all the results as they are get long, here is an example.

@Thought Art I don't have a problem with Aikido, what I am skeptical about is the training partner moving across room when he barely touches him, it's ridiculous. It makes me sad because I have a lot of respect for him and he has a lot of good things to say in his book on body awareness, things like this tend to discredit him in my mind. Perhaps I am being dense and something is going over my head, but I don't know how you get around being skeptical after seeing something like this (there are many more videos online).

I am re-reading Ralston's book on body awareness. He talks about how he got into martial arts work in order to get better at his consciousness studies, not the other way around. I thought that was super interesting and that is why I am doing it. I love the idea of showing up to the Dojo day after day to understand consciousness and self better.

@MuadDib I just had the time to go through your entire post and I loved it. Keep up the long detailed posts! I wonder where you could buy a club like that... https://a.co/d/eET9uOy Not too bad

I recently bought the Claude Opus 3 after seeing it on Leo's blog and found something really creative that you can do find your life purpose and ideas for task/projects to get you there. I generated a PDF from OneNote with all my notes from the Life Purpose course, uploaded it to Claude, and asked it questions to help get me on track. Some of the best questions I asked were: -Given what you know about me, what are some different ways I could formulate my Life Purpose statement to make it sound more authentic? -Give me a vision of what my life could look like if I was living my Life Purpose, be specific -Give me a list of tasks and projects that I can do in order to get on track with my Life Purpose -Brainstorm a list of people who have a life purpose similar to mine and a brief summary of how they did it It's not a substitute for doing the real inner work but I think that it is a great tool to use especially if you took the Life Purpose course and want help brainstorming an working on your Life Purpose

I need someone who understands AI better than me to explain which AI's are better than others. All I can think of is how big of a LLM they are using, what else goes into making a good AI and what is the best AI on the market right now?

Training Notes 4/3/24 -When you take someone's back make sure to roll to the side and not straight back because this will make is easier for them to get away -When you get to a mounted triangle you can pull up on the head just like in a normal triangle to finish it -If someone is in turtle and you can't get your hooks in you can grab their ankle and take them to technical mount -From side control, if someone is framing really well against you, you can fall forward so that they can not bench you off them and isolate their far side arm and go for an Americana or if they straighten their arm you can pull up and sit on their head squeezing your knees to hold them still. Now, you can either hit a kimora or fall back into an arm bar. -When you fall back into an arm bar, keep them as close to you as possible so that your body is touching them the whole time. If you give them space they can pull their arm back in and get their elbow to the mat and escape.

I want to study at a Buddhist Monastery for this summer (3 months) and I have no idea how to go about finding a place to stay. I currently live in the U.S.A but I'm willing to travel almost anywhere. If anyone could help direct me in this process I would greatly appreciate it as I don't know where to start.