AtmanIsBrahman

Is IQ is a Valid/Meaningful Measure of Intelligence?

68 posts in this topic

1 hour ago, Carl-Richard said:

Thing is if your IQ is low enough, you can't keep a single coherent sentence in mind at one time. Scale that up and you'll see that maybe a high IQ is not such a bad idea.

There are a few people you'll meet that are noticeably "slow" in the way they think and talk and you get a sense of unclarity, and they might even come off like they have dementia (which is effectively equivalent with a low IQ or generally low cognitive functioning).

1 hour ago, Carl-Richard said:

Thing is if your IQ is low enough, you can't keep a single coherent sentence in mind at one time. Scale that up and you'll see that maybe a high IQ is not such a bad idea

Sure maybe for stuff that requires you to think, it might be a bad deal. But you are assuming that the best things in life are mental in nature which is not true. Also there is a bias towards success and IQ which is also not true. I'm not sure where but i read that people with super high IQ are not social, and that fucks up their life even though they are super intelligent.

 

If you are super intelligent and not social, then you'll be fucked and not successful regardless. He lived rest of his life in a farm. I think that was Langan and i read it in outliers book.

Ultimately you need to have average intelligence and some other things to be materially successful. But to be world class in something, that's a whole new game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Vido said:

If you are super intelligent and not social, then you'll be fucked and not successful regardless. He lived rest of his life in a farm. I think that was Langan and i read it in outliers book.

Ultimately you need to have average intelligence and some other things to be materially successful. But to be world class in something, that's a whole new game.

I think you're conflating intelligence with success. It doesn't matter if someone was successful or not; the fact remains that they are intelligent.

I wonder if this sort of line of reasoning is an ego defense mechanism. Not saying you're doing it, but in general.

"I don't want to be seen as unintelligent" becomes "intelligence doesn't matter for life anyway." Classic sour grapes


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

"I don't want to be seen as unintelligent" becomes "intelligence doesn't matter for life anyway." Classic sour grapes

Hmm......when I was in Uni, I always was fascinated by what the TOP TOP level genius look like. I was in all the top classes but never the top student. I did have friends who are super super smart, and was super curious. 

Like these people are not like American type smart, they are like elite level genius. I think its because of the population density (my city is like 20M), that I met so many people. I feel the courses here are childish compared to India. 

These people are like intelligent combined with something super extra. Like one guy was fucking smart and great at sports, one guy was like super fucking smart and also just makes shit by himself, both my close friends are super fucking smart. One is like super good with logic and analytical, another is super smart and plays the social game like crazy. He is like Harvey Specter from suits. Not only smart, social but also rich. 

The thing is, the harvey specter guy literally said fuck you to the university and just gave blank papers. Super low GPA, then decided to move to America, got like 755 in GMAT, and did a semester in Harvard. What's funny is all the people I know are smart, are working in some company. Like the biggest company. 

You would think that a person who's smart would see through the illusion, start their own thing, create something epic, or just give back, but those qualities are not like related to intelligent. You could be super intelligent and cheat, betray, believe in Jesus, etc.

For me, genius is when you see through the illusion and create something crazy that is a mindfuck. When you propose that sun in the center even though saying that would burn you, When Einstein though "shit this thing is relative". I want to feel that experience. Intelligence doesn't help much but is a factor. Maybe like 20%. 

Issac Newton who I think is the GOAT, god knows how smart he is, smartest scientist of ALL TIME, was a Christian. Imagine creating a whole field of mathematics that is still used today heavily just to solve a problem. That is like....1 in 7 billion type talent. Of course he is smart, but Newton, Einstein was something more. Much more than IQ. If IQ is the only factor that made a genius like them, then we would have many.

What is the point of being intelligent when the best thing about it is, doing stuff that's hard for others more easily? 

Edited by Vido

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you were just asking this question in the general sense, I would ask you why are you not first considering the following traits before you even start to consider raw intelligence:

  1. a wholehearted, authentic drive toward curiosity and drive for truth
  2. an absolute passion and devotion toward one's end goal (or a willingness to cultivate such, ideally unquestioningly, so that you are at least not questioning yourself about that drive every step of the way). (Alternatively, the unwillingness to leave an "out" for oneself along their path regardless of how one feels about anything, and the unwillingness to make excuses and hide from yourself, like a "truth at nearly any cost" sort of mindset)
On 2026-11-15 at 1:53 AM, AtmanIsBrahman said:

This means that what IQ measures might not be culturally constructed, but a real innate faculty of someone's mind. 

Regardless, it seems obvious if we're honest that some people are more intelligent than others. Not just in some things but across the board. And we should want to know where we stand in the pecking order if we're committed to truth, as much as it could hurt our feelings. 

I wonder whether IQ would correlate with someone's progress in spirituality or their epistemic ability.
I don't know exactly where I stand on this. The IQ topic is super complicated, and people are ideological on both sides.

Well yes, some people have more raw intelligence than others by whatever metric you wish to measure. Why do you think any of this matters though on a spiritual path, the intelligence? Specifically -- what's that intelligence FOR; what purpose does it serve? What does it actually do, and what is it capable of doing?   

For jnana yoga, by definition, you probably do need some degree of raw base intelligence (Here I just mean the spirit of jnana, not necessarily in direct association with Hinduism and yogic practices rooted in India or any other specific time or place. I moreso mean the search for pure, absolute Understanding and/or knowledge). But you use whatever you have available to do whatever you can, regardless of where you are at currently, where you want to go, what you want to do, and what you want to become.This is true for everyone. If you lack a certain degree of intelligence to start with, perhaps you also lack curiosity in general and therefore never step on the spiritual path in the first place, but this is not necessarily the case. Maybe you feel a hole in your heart or something essential that is somehow missing, and that is (at least theoretically) more than enough stimulus for anyone to feel compelled, especially if they are desperate enough (such tends to be the human way, regardless of intelligence).

"How much" only really matters when you're in a community of people, talking with and comparing against each other, or constructively if there is a shared aim. I don't think """God""" cares about pace --- you do. You and everyone else who is doing the measuring!

For bhakti-style, you wouldn't particularly need extra raw intelligence. Why would you? If anything, your big old dumb brain and all your opinions and ideas, your identity, your reasons for doing what you do and being the way that you are -- this doesn't matter. Why would it? If anything, the more elaborately, tightly, and cleverly constructed your identity, the more trouble you very well might have not tripping over yourself due to stubborn attachment to pride, simply because "intelligence" is something you value and identify with so tightly, and it's not like you're super intelligent and then you're automatically better at dealing with things like of a more emotional and primal nature. At best, you just understand and execute strategies for dealing with issues better (as in, faster and with greater accuracy and finesse) -- but I have to say, it's often a double edged sword. That same mind/intellect that is great at identifying and solving problems rapidly also easily enough turns against you in equal measure if left to its own devices as a sovereign force. Take a look at the emotional and psychological problems of the classically highly intelligent.

For karma (action and service orientated) and raja yoga (meditation, asanas, kriya, etc.), YMMV?  (The question then becomes, are you capable of focusing? Impulse control? There's some correlation between intelligence and self-regulation, but look around at people -- clearly it's not a strict one.)

 

 

If you're asking, are some people more capable of articulating their Understanding, are some people capable of coming to certain conclusions faster on their path, and should they maybe be the ones leading and teaching others? --- I consider this to be a distinct question to be considered separately. 

Edited by eos_nyxia

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:
9 hours ago, LastThursday said:

I feel generally icky about any scoring system at all for people. You collapse something multi-dimensional and context sensitive into a single finite biased number. It's both inhuman and meaningless.

I think you guys are taking the easy way out. 

Let’s say Leo takes an IQ test tomorrow and posts the results.

Would you feel the same way about his teachings whether he scored 100 or 150?

I honestly don't see what Leo's IQ has to do with Leo's teachings. This is actually my point. I take the entire context of "Leo" into my frame for understanding him. I can certainly see an intelligence or more accurate intelligences in the way Leo presents himself. I have a tacit feel for him as whole over hundreds of hours, which is in no way commensurate with some IQ number. In fact getting a "feel" for someone over time is the harder way and more human.


Truth as process not object

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My IQ is 45, but I do my best.


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

My IQ is 45, but I do my best.

Unsubbed.


Truth as process not object

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now