integral

Epistemic Puzzle #2

16 posts in this topic

Puzzle, is this sound reasoning? How do we know this is true? 

 

  • Boys' brains develop, on average, later than girls'.
  • Schools reward certain developmental capacities.
  • Therefore, boys should start school one year later. 

 

Live example of someone thinking this way

At the end of this thread AI will calculate your Epistemic Rating.

 

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, enchanted said:

Or go back to boys schools and girls schools

This is potentially a good exercise for you, i remember in the other topic you were concerned about Not knowing how something could be true without double blind studies and peer review.

Maybe this is an opportunity to practice.

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, Human Mint said:

What is this? What is the assigment here?

Puzzle, is this sound reasoning? How do we know this is true? 


How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, integral said:

Puzzle, is this sound reasoning? How do we know this is true? 

If people laugh at you then you know is true.


I am the impossible made reality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Btw I am really passionate about education


I am the impossible made reality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

4 hours ago, Human Mint said:

If people laugh at you then you know is true.

The category in Epistemology this falls under is: Social proof, that the level of humor is sufficient evidence for truth.

And that is true for specific questions, Like, how do you know if someone's funny? well, everyone's laughing.

Read the argument and try to figure out:

  • Is this actually true?
  • How do they know?
  • Are they making any mistakes in their thinking?
  • What are they overlooking?
  • How would you think about this differently?

Don't just tell me whether you agree or disagree with it. Investigate the reasoning.

The goal is to find the epistemic problems

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Education is an art, it should be based on principles rather than yes or no answers. The problem is not when you enter school but how they treat you there. In fact the sooner you enter a school the better — assuming it is a healthy school.

This reasoning doesn't have in consideration the corruption that can happen in a school.

Should you treat different cognitive capabilities diferently? The answer is yes. How you go about that is the heart of the problem. That's where you need the practical experience to decide what the best practice for each level is.


I am the impossible made reality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Notice what the best schools have in common. They prioritize critical thinking, learning by experience, creativity, no room for dogma, community, emotional regulation from a young age, connection with nature. You only need one thing: mature teachers.


I am the impossible made reality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, integral said:

Therefore, boys should start school one year later. 

Only way to truly know that is to run split tests on various cohorts of boys and girls.

I expect the results to be inconclusive because this is such a vague issue, with so much variability. There will be no clean, simple answer.

In practice, wasting a year not in school is probably just a waste of development opportunity.

You have to consider the alternative: boys playing video games all day or surfing toxic rabbit-holes on the web.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are different methods within neuroscience to evaluate structural differences between male and female brains and you can observe different behavioral tendencies between the sexes and how they tend to change over time.

You haven't explicitly stated why boys should start school later than girls so the reasoning isn't necessarily valid. If you assume that males and females should be given equal chance to thrive and be rewarded in schools, then you can maybe argue that there should be different experiences and rules for each gender.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, integral said:

This is potentially a good exercise for you, i remember in the other topic you were concerned about Not knowing how something could be true without double blind studies and peer review.

Maybe this is an opportunity to practice.

Ya interesting post 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Implicit in the conclusion is the idea that performing better in school leads to better life results. That may not be the case.

In practice, wasting a year not in school is probably just a waste of development opportunity.

💯 In fact, being more challenged earlier in life may turn out to be a good thing.

What is it we'd like to optimize?

PS: Great post.

Edited by PsychedelicEagle

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Brains are always in development. This is why we give toddlers toys that facilitate development. Should female toddlers receive learning toys at age 2 and male toddlers at age 3? Of course not. Every stage of development should be facilitated. If you started boys 1 year later, you’re putting males at an even more educational disadvantage, which has consequences. If anything, you’d start boys one year earlier to make up for the deficit. 

It’s true that grouping kids with wide ranges of capacity into the same learning environment has its issues, but we’d need to define the acceptable ranges for any particular grouping, and I think most 5 year old boys are within acceptable range to be grouped with 5 year old girls - just my hunch. 

Plus, there are other costs like an extra year of daycare parents would have to pay for. It seems it would complicate many logistics.

It would take many hours to game this out, but these are my initial thoughts in 5-10 minutes. 

Edited by Joshe

-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There a many variables in this issue. One is family genetics, the family economic class, how dissfunctional are the first years of the kid. A child who grow in a household with violence,stress, abandonement, abuse etc.. may have different capacity to development in certain aspects or better in others. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now