AtmanIsBrahman

Is IQ is a Valid/Meaningful Measure of Intelligence?

51 posts in this topic

The problem with IQ is that even people with high IQ are stupid. IQ does not capture the truly important aspects of intelligence.

IQ is too crude. It is akin to measuring intelligence by head size. There is certainly a correlation between head size and intelligence, but its too crude to be a reliable metric.

IQ makes people with a high score feel smarter than they actually are, and it makes people with low scores feel dumber than they can be.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

The problem with IQ is that even people with high IQ are stupid. IQ does not capture the truly important aspects of intelligence.

IQ is too crude. It is akin to measuring intelligence by head size. There is certainly a correlation between head size and intelligence, but its too crude to be a reliable metric.

Um Hum.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

The problem with IQ is that even people with high IQ are stupid. IQ does not capture the truly important aspects of intelligence.

IQ is too crude. It is akin to measuring intelligence by head size.

High iq people can be self deceived for sure, but they do have a higher cognitive capacity or whatever this strange thing called intelligence is, right?

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

High iq people can be self deceived for sure, but they do have a higher cognitive capacity

They have higher capacity at the specific things being measured.

It is not just about self-deception, high IQ people can be missing higher aspects of intelligence.

IQ is like measuring all weapons by their DPS. But weapons have many other qualities besides DPS.

IQ is too reductionistic.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

They have higher capacity at the specific things being measured.

The standard response to this from psychometrics people would be that G tracks your performance across a wide variety of tasks. An IQ test is only good because it correlates highly with G, say 0.9. And G in turn is important because it predicts how someone will perform academically, their career success, even lifespan. 

I don't see an easy way to refute this. If you try to say that G is only narrow test-taking ability, that doesn't hold up because it tracks a number of other life outcomes. 

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@AtmanIsBrahman Yes, I know that argument.

My counter-argument is:

Yes, IQ tracks "g", and "g" predicts all sorts of success at general tasks involving intelligence, however, this still misses many subtle and higher aspects of intelligence. Those general tasks are themselves poor measure of intelligence.

"it predicts how someone will perform academically, their career success, even lifespan." << That is a very poor measure of the richness of intelligence.

IQ and "g" misses all that richness.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

Yes, IQ tracks "g", and "g" predicts all sorts of success at general tasks involving intelligence, however, this still misses many subtle and higher aspects of intelligence. Those general tasks are themselves poor measure of intelligence.

"it predicts how someone will perform academically, their career success, even lifespan." << That is a very poor measure of the richness of intelligence.

IQ and "g" misses all that richness

I see, so are you saying that g is basically tracking survival, which can't get to the metaphysical depth of intelligence?

I had that thought myself, but I don't know if it's conflating the spiritual and everyday domains.

I'm not sure; this stuff is very complicated. Understanding intelligence is super difficult, not just in the cosmic Consciousness sense but in the ordinary sense too.

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I see, so are you saying that g is basically tracking survival, which can't get to the metaphysical depth of intelligence?

I had that thought myself, but I don't know if it's conflating the spiritual and everyday domains.

I'm not sure; this stuff is very complicated. Understanding intelligence is super difficult, not just in the cosmic Consciousness sense but in the ordinary sense too.

I think it tracks more than survival, but certainly scientists love to boil everything down to survival and pragmatism.

Yes, it is very complicated and we just don't have good scientific accounts of intelligence. The science on intelligence is very crude, reductionist, and philosophically shallow.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

I think it tracks more than survival, but certainly scientists love to boil everything down to survival and pragmatism.

Well, if it tracks more than survival, I think it captures a legitimate piece of intelligence. Sure, not all of it, but a portion. Is that 20%? 60%? 80%? I don't know. 

But regardless, I think people should probably get their IQ tested if they care about truth and personal development.

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I think it captures a legitimate piece of intelligence.

Yes. We aren't denying that.

Quote

But regardless, I think people should probably get their IQ tested if they care about truth and personal development.

I don't see how that follows.


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

finding out what is true about yourself

Is it really true though?

Why accept a reductive frame?


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

Is it really true though?

Why accept a reductive frame?

So that you know if you have high DPS or not?

Edited by integral

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Carl-Richard said:

So that you know if you have high DPS or not?

But would you know what DPS even means?

Would it move you closer to an accurate self assessment?

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Carl-Richard said:

So that you know if you have high DPS or not?

What is the DPS on a nuclear bomb? ^_^


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scientists are like people who invented a test for height, never considering the existence of giraffes. xD

An IQ test is a Procrustean Bed.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

But regardless, I think people should probably get their IQ tested if they care about truth and personal development.

I would even suggest that maximizing your IQ (which is a thing you can do) is another thing to have in mind. Let's not even call it IQ: let's just call it speed and capacity. Would you prefer to spend 50 seconds reading a few sentences or 5 seconds? 50 minutes working a task or 5 minutes with the same output? Be able to hold 8-9 numbers in your mind at once or 5? IQ closely maps on to such things. Basic load-bearing metrics.


Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't see myself as particularly intelligent per se.  I don't care about that.  I'm fine with what I have.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31 minutes ago, integral said:

But would you know what DPS even means?

Would it move you closer to an accurate self assessment?

If you know what an IQ test is and you have the "IQ" to know/estimate how it could generalize and how it would probably not generalize, then you're probably better off knowing about that than not.

The main thing I've gathered from people you could consider high IQ, is you get the sense that they are very "quick". There was a girl once in university who I wanted to tell once while working in a group project "something tells me you have a high IQ". Because she was just so very quick with what we were doing. And only later I found out she had been in the newspaper described as one of the best math heads in the country and competing in math competitions when younger.

Another group project in a different university; same story, different person, and she actually shared her IQ (Mensa member). It was a bit cringe that she shared it, but she was quick. One time we were doing a group presentation and one of the group members pussed out and she learned their part on the day maybe an hour or so before the presentation and she presented it so smoothly as if she had written it herself.

Another girl from uni who also is very quick I know has applied for a PhD position and is ranked in the leading positions for consideration to the position and is very fresh out of her graduate degree.

My graduate advisor (professor), very quick. My sort of stepdad is a professor in medicine, very quick. Mike Israetel (who boasts of 160 IQ), also very quick (he is probably a good example of the limits of IQ). My actual stepdad, very quick, top position in an oil company.

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

IQ is very devious because you hear about some person's high IQ and then you assume all sorts of things about what that means, which it does not mean.

If I told you that I have a 200 IQ, what would you start assuming about me? Whatever it is, it would likely be wrong. People inevitably try to use IQ as some source of authority. "IQ is high, therefore must be true"

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now