Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
trenton

Fatherhood versus rational self interest

9 posts in this topic

I'm discovering that part of me feels a desire to be a father. It seems to be this desire to experience love within a relationship that I was never given the opportunity to experience. I find myself imagining having a child and a defacto wife even though I don't like the institutional set up around marriage. The problem is that I hold this as against my rational self interest.

I no longer believe in the trauma narrative I was conditioned with. I feel this desire for love because of what wasn't there. I am not who I was told I was nor am I anything like my father.

The thing is.

First of all, I'm still with my family.

Secondly, my job doesn't match my desired career direction yet.

Thirdly, I have an associates degree at this time.

Fourthly, settling with a child would restrain the possibility of pursuing spirituality as far as I would like to.

Fifthly, there is a massive economic trap which will be harder to escape.

Sixth, stress and a lot of it.

Seventh, loss of autonomy.

Eighth, I need to find a decent woman, though this should be fixable.

Ninth, I still live in America at this time and parts of Europe are likely better for my purposes. I think a good parent would be open minded to the possibility of a school shooter murdering your child any day of the week and take the issue seriously in advance. Should you really trust a school to keep your child safe?

Tenth, some other tenth thing.

In any case, my feelings contradict what I believe is good for me at this time. It is like this desire to just exist as a normal human being without needing to prove my significance or compensate for the harm done to me through a major life purpose. Holding life purpose as a redemption fantasy which proves my worth just makes me hate life even more.

I am wanting to date. It's just a question of how I go about it and avoiding an accidental child as that would demonstrate my lack of responsibility already as a parent. Maybe if it weren't about me anymore, that would be part of the appeal.

What do you think about fatherhood and rational self interest? This is probably why more educated people have fewer kids if they are wise about the outcomes. Or maybe we were indoctrinated with career focused values over relational values.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How old are you? You can afford to wait a long time to setup your life before starting to have kids. You can freeze your sperm and have it be at in its peak state even into your 50s and 60s. That would be an extreme age but with anti aging and age reversal starting to look quite promising, there are all kinds of options that look to be possible in the next 10-20 years.

I'm 31 and am still building my life. My fatherhood instincts are kicking in though and I don't wanna delay it forever. Probably around my late 30s I will have built the life I want and experienced all that I want out of singlehood and will be ready to pivot towards settling down with one or a few partner and build a family with kids. I think being setup financially and having a career/business that provides a solid income while not requiring too much time makes such a difference in building a high quality life and not just struggling with a partner while trying to raise a child. 


The dream is not easy but each day we're getting closer

Follow my journey on Instagram @Kylegfall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Right now I'm 28. I definitely don't think it's a good idea to have kids right now. What I mean ultimately is why would I have kids at all knowing how much would be sacrificed in the process. The sacrifice appears to be part of the appeal, but it conflicts with the other visions I had for my life which involved more travel and spiritual or intellectual pursuits.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Humans are good at romanticizing suffering because that's what helped us coped with lack of options for a long time. Don't let people tell you that you need to sacrifice all your goals for the privilege of being a parent. A lot of people did do that and some are quite satisfied about it but you can be more strategic in how you build your life. 


The dream is not easy but each day we're getting closer

Follow my journey on Instagram @Kylegfall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Joseph Maynor said:

I'm 48.  20 years over 28.  I'll be 49 in a month.  

What's your relationship with fatherhood? Do you have kids and if not, how come? 


The dream is not easy but each day we're getting closer

Follow my journey on Instagram @Kylegfall

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 11/15/2026 at 9:47 AM, trenton said:

I'm discovering that part of me feels a desire to be a father. It seems to be this desire to experience love within a relationship that I was never given the opportunity to experience. I find myself imagining having a child and a defacto wife even though I don't like the institutional set up around marriage. The problem is that I hold this as against my rational self interest.

I no longer believe in the trauma narrative I was conditioned with. I feel this desire for love because of what wasn't there. I am not who I was told I was nor am I anything like my father.

The thing is.

First of all, I'm still with my family.

Secondly, my job doesn't match my desired career direction yet.

Thirdly, I have an associates degree at this time.

Fourthly, settling with a child would restrain the possibility of pursuing spirituality as far as I would like to.

Fifthly, there is a massive economic trap which will be harder to escape.

Sixth, stress and a lot of it.

Seventh, loss of autonomy.

Eighth, I need to find a decent woman, though this should be fixable.

Ninth, I still live in America at this time and parts of Europe are likely better for my purposes. I think a good parent would be open minded to the possibility of a school shooter murdering your child any day of the week and take the issue seriously in advance. Should you really trust a school to keep your child safe?

Tenth, some other tenth thing.

In any case, my feelings contradict what I believe is good for me at this time. It is like this desire to just exist as a normal human being without needing to prove my significance or compensate for the harm done to me through a major life purpose. Holding life purpose as a redemption fantasy which proves my worth just makes me hate life even more.

I am wanting to date. It's just a question of how I go about it and avoiding an accidental child as that would demonstrate my lack of responsibility already as a parent. Maybe if it weren't about me anymore, that would be part of the appeal.

What do you think about fatherhood and rational self interest? This is probably why more educated people have fewer kids if they are wise about the outcomes. Or maybe we were indoctrinated with career focused values over relational values.

Get firstly and secondly handled before you even consider this. As long as you live with family you can't think straight as much as you think your willpower is overriding their biases. Structurally, living under someone else's roof makes you feel like you can't develop, so find a way out.

Why did you put thirdly? Is that degree helping you in any way? Personally I'd turn that into a bachelor's as that gives you more freedom and power in the marketplace. But if that threatens your finances then consider other routes.

I would challenge fourthly. That's just an assumption. You don't actually know that. There are loads of ways to approach spirituality in the 21st century. Meditating in a cave in the forest is antiquated and unrealistic for most of us. Personally I'm with you in that I want to go far spiritually, and yet I see having a kid as not a barrier, but an accelerator to it. You just have to feel into your desire stronger and you'll imagine ways to do both. Which is more powerful than this "either-or" dynamic you have going.

I don't blame you for thinking fifthly, but again you don't actually know that. I'm currently undoing student loan debt to give myself the option to have a family if I so choose. In 3 years I'll be out of debt and in another 4 I'll easily have enough money. And it's not because I'm some special person. Hell no; I fucked up many times in my 20s. The key is I'm laser-focused now (I'm also 28 btw).

Sixth and seventh are more unchallenged assumptions. It's not about what it looks like on the outside but how you feel and the strength of your vision.

Eighth is actually valid, but I wouldn't frame it as "need." If you want this to actually happen, you will. You'll do what's needed to make it all happen.

Ninth... I have two points. Number one, why are you so focused on the worst outcomes possible (this goes for your whole post). Number two, either send your kid to a school in a safe district or homeschool. Yeah again, easier said than done; if you actually want this, you need long-term thinking and creativity. And flexibility.

Planning to have a family would make you really skilled as a person in general, I don't know why I can see that and you can't; you seem like a really smart dude. Just by reading your post I think you'd be a great fagter because of how much time you put into thinking about all of these different factors. But what i'd invite you to do now is what I said before.

Don't think about it in terms of:

Spirituality vs Family

Think about it as a unique project that you're taking on, should you do so.

Last thing I'll say is there is wisdom in having children that's lost on some. For several reasons. Yes, economics of it make it difficult for the lower-class, but that doesn't have to be you. I have friends who have told me having children was the best thing they ever did, and it was a massive healing experience that redefined their lives and get them super inspired again.

So don't just go with your brain and beliefs, go with your gut and your higher vision. Whatever that is.

Edited by WonderSeeker

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Having a kid to make something that happened in the universe right is just a bad approach. Having the kid isnt going to do anything about that.

Having a kid to feel love is what most parents do and its just a tape over something. When the kid grows and leave its still there.

It is a selfish reason to have a child.

And when you have it and then it dosent solve the problem of why you want to do that in the first place you can get angry or something else.

The child in you wants to be loved if it wasnt and you are trying to have another child to make the inner child feel better about not being loved. That dosent work you gotta love your inner child. You would probably get jealous of your own child.

When you are a kid you are giving a part of yourself away when your selfish inner child not healed.

Edited by Hojo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@WonderSeeker I know how it would make me skilled as a person. In order to manage the economic situation, I would need good planning. One example would be advertising twin restaurants that trash each other and say how much better they are than the others. You can come up with hilarious signs as they write "they suck. Easy here instead."

A good business would be one way to make the money manageable. It is an alternative life vision away from things like sociology and public policy, but an acceptable one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0