AtmanIsBrahman

Is IQ is a Valid/Meaningful Measure of Intelligence?

100 posts in this topic

4 hours ago, Basman said:

Eq will get you further in life than iq, because at the end of the day people will prefer to work with someone who they like. Bill Clinton is a good example. 

Absolutely. However, I'm guessing a formal EQ test would have the same traps as the IQ test has today? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, oOo said:

To the core question on a 'G' factor, that would be relational reasoning. Every other cognitive ability is a measurement of how much its enabling someone's core capacity for relational reasoning's expression rather than being a reflection of underlying 'G' itself other than a potential strong correlate 

I'm not sure what you mean by relational reasoning.


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here are some important limitations of IQ, just to ground the discussion. 

(And I think a lot of you are in denial about how much it does capture, but regardless...)
 

  • Misses creativity - this is a big part of intelligence which IQ overlooks because it's about zoning in on the "right" answer
  • Misses cognitive development - important because this plays a huge role in real-life sensemaking
  • Misses spiritual intelligence - this seems to be separate from IQ (although of course no data exists because most people don't even know spiritual intelligence exists).
  • Doesn't fully capture reasoning ability - whether someone can make sense of the world accurately depends on things like caring about truth, epistemic responsibility, education, resistance to conformity, and more.

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I'm not sure what you mean by relational reasoning.

If you want I can send through some research in the next few days; particular one's I'd site.

Relational reasoning in simple form = What is the relationship between A to B? B to A on its own? A to B on its own? What relationships make A 'A'? What relationships make B 'B'?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, integral said:

@Carl-Richard I know MBTI is illegal but, Te is not going to score as high on a IQ test as Ti.

mbti-type-iq-calculator-v0-rghc8anej1y91

Cant a ESFJ have high horse power but score lower on IQ tests? Im sure they can be blazing fast at wtv they are doing with there mind, its just not tested by IQ.

Im not going to pretend the right types dont have obvious inteligence issues. 

Statistically, no. I've by the way made the case why Ne and Ti could outperform Ni and Te (and feeling and sensing functions). And by the way, I tried to deduce it from first principles rather than trying to retrospectively explain the graphic you presented (even though I have seen the graphic before):

Of course, in reality every person uses every function. It's just they prefer some over others. Somebody who matches most closely ESFJ could still be relatively fast even if they don't prefer thinking and intuition functions. It's just statistically, you won't see the extremes as much in those types.


Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 16.11.2026 at 6:58 AM, AtmanIsBrahman said:

@Carl-Richard  so do you see IQ as basically just raw horse power? 

Yes. The speed and size of your cognitive conveyor belt, your working memory capacity (mental working space). Your cognition can be thought to have a basic engine that determines how fast you process units of information and how many units of information you can hold in your cognition at once. The way IQ tests are constructed (time pressure × amount of tasks completed) and the relatively simple nature of the tasks means it largely approximates this function.

 

On 16.11.2026 at 6:58 AM, AtmanIsBrahman said:

What finer aspects of intelligence specifically do you think it disregards?

 

On 16.11.2026 at 5:08 AM, Carl-Richard said:

Complexity, creativity, subtlety, intuition, logicality/coherence, connectivity/associative ability (latent inhibition); many things not as directly measured by IQ can impact what we would consider to be "intelligence".

 

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, oOo said:

Relational reasoning in simple form = What is the relationship between A to B? B to A on its own? A to B on its own? What relationships make A 'A'? What relationships make B 'B'?

I don't think this is the only thing captured by IQ tests. Digit span (how many numbers you can remember in a row) is not relational.

 

9 hours ago, Carl-Richard said:

Yes. The speed and size of your cognitive conveyor belt, your working memory capacity (mental working space). Your cognition can be thought to have a basic engine that determines how fast you process units of information and how many units of information you can hold in your cognition at once. The way IQ tests are constructed (time pressure × amount of tasks completed) and the relatively simple nature of the tasks means it largely approximates this function.

What about reasoning and pattern recognition? I'm not sure it can be reduced to working memory. How well someone does on a progressive matrix, for instance, seems to depend on how well they can reason and work through the patterns, not just how many patterns they can track at once.


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Intelligence is mostly a motivational disposition, Vast majority of inteligence is you wanting to be intelligent.

Inteligence is something that has to be practiced by challenging yourself everyday. Same way someone learns piano.

Its mostly a drive, motivation and personality trait.

Besides genetic handicaps, If you want to have a IQ of 130-140 you can. Just takes effort and health. After 140 you likely need genetics privileges or a sophisticated training program

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I don't think this is the only thing captured by IQ tests. Digit span (how many numbers you can remember in a row) is not relational.

It's good you understand that, nice work.

I expressed that in my original response.

 

1 hour ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

What about reasoning and pattern recognition? I'm not sure it can be reduced to working memory.

Precisely, and that's relational reasoning at work you're doing.

You're identifying the inconsistency between two forms in making a judgement by comparison; like is Lil Wayne better than Kanye West, or how about Josh Groban? There is a middle relaitonal point that can actually give an answer instead of just simply saying "well they've got different styles and people have different tastes, also Josh is in a completely different genre". 

A pattern is a pattern in and of itself, but noticing it requires relational reasoning and is encompassed by relational reasoning (so noticing patterns does not fully explain relational reasoning ability). 

1 hour ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

How well someone does on a progressive matrix, for instance, seems to depend on how well they can reason and work through the patterns, not just how many patterns they can track at once.

It's both. The former is where working memory and relational reasoning overlap, the latter is the interdependency that is raw relational reasoning overlapping and not fully explained by simply noticing patterns. 
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

AI by the way, even Astra 2.0, only has a relational reasoning IQ of about 120. 

And that's precisely why it cannot do high level work, and that's increasingly the case for original work. 

Terra 6.1, about a 100 relational reasoning IQ.

Edited by oOo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

What about reasoning and pattern recognition? I'm not sure it can be reduced to working memory. How well someone does on a progressive matrix, for instance, seems to depend on how well they can reason and work through the patterns, not just how many patterns they can track at once.

Sure those are obvious. Reasoning towards an answer, finding patterns, definitely a part of general problem-solving/intelligence and what IQ tries to capture.

But consider how much pattern recognition and reasoning depends on identifying and weighing options, testing comparisons, etc. If you do that faster and at a larger quantity, that will significantly impact your reasoning and pattern recognition skills (certainly in a timed scenario like an IQ test). If you have a lousy CPU that only does two comparisons a minute, you can be the best reasonmaker and pattern finder and you won't make it out the first base before the game is over.

And as far as operationalizing pattern recognition and reasoning skills, you would do it through something like an IQ test which you would likely time or else it would be hard to standardize the results, and then you would of course end up at working memory capacity being a central piece again.

You can also question whether there are any significant rate-independent factors for these things. If for example 100 IQ gives you 15 comparisons a minute but 160 IQ gives you 150, that's going to produce astronomically different results. I believe it was Jordan Peterson who said that high IQ individuals are so much more productive than normal IQ people that it's mind-boggling. If the main difference is the rate of basic cognitive operations, that wouldn't be too mysterious.

But I think there are rate-independent factors (certain minds just tend to work in certain particular ways), but again, they're probably hard to measure/operationalize in a way that separates them from the rate-dependent ones.

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
28 minutes ago, Carl-Richard said:

Sure those are obvious. Reasoning towards an answer, finding patterns, definitely a part of general problem-solving/intelligence and what IQ tries to capture.

But consider how much pattern recognition and reasoning depends on identifying and weighing options, testing comparisons, etc.

The point I’m trying to drive at is that even IQ is a nebulous concept.

It can’t be defined as just how many options you’re weighing, like “person A weighs 150 options, person B weighs 80.” It depends on so many different things. 
 

 


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
47 minutes ago, Carl-Richard said:

If for example 100 IQ gives you 15 comparisons a minute but 160 IQ gives you 150, that's going to produce astronomically different results.

High G cognition acts more like a chess grandmaster than a calculator, it uses abstraction to immediately ignore 95% of the irrelevant noise and only test the 2 or 3 high-probability options.

Thats better intuition for what matters at the task at hand. Basically there thinking smarter not necessarily faster. But it ends up being way faster then the normie at finishing the task.

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

The point I’m trying to drive at is that even IQ is a nebulous concept.

It can’t be defined as just how many options you’re weighing, like “person A weighs 150 options, person B weighs 80.” It depends on so many different things. 
 

 

You need to be more humble.

You don't understand it well enough yet.

You will if you take the time to but. Or not. It's yours.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
58 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

To be clear, I'm not denying IQ is real. I'm just saying that the "g-factor" itself is nebulous.

If you're stating that as opinion, that's fine.

Stating it as fact, requires a stronger argument. 

Explore across alternate species as well. Next, construct imaginary environments and imagine how intelligence can manifest there.

For both, you'll have to express more patience than what you've shown at weeding out assumptions. 

Best.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it makes sense to observe people taking IQ tests.

The ones that are bad at it have disastrous intuition for what they should be doing or focusing on, while the inteligent ones have great strategy and sense for it.

IQ is being good at coming up with strategies that will get you solve the problem. 


How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are assessment-centers here in Germany. I have been to one of those when I applied for a dual-studies course. That is a university course paired with a apprenticeship at a company. They only take the best of the best. I didn't make their cut 13 years ago. I wonder if I would make their cut now. I am not the smartest by any mean, but I am one of the smartest at working around my own limitations and getting help when I need it. And I feel like that is also an extremely important distinguising factor. Knowing when you have reached a dead-end and being able to turn around or call for help so that someone picks you up before you collapse and die in an alley somewhere no body can find you.

Edited by Psychonaut

I AM a Website EMPIRE, and a persona

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
18 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

The point I’m trying to drive at is that even IQ is a nebulous concept.

It can’t be defined as just how many options you’re weighing, like “person A weighs 150 options, person B weighs 80.” It depends on so many different things. 

The point is not to reduce it down to one thing and nothing else. It's to ask what is the thing that most explains it. Creativity could impact IQ test performance (it does), but it's not as central.

The thing about working memory is that it underlies all mental operations. Every test you ever do involves working memory. So tests for reasoning and pattern recognition do actually test working memory, and it's not possible to really control for it. You can make so-called tests for approximating pure working memory (e.g. digit span tests, N-back), but you can never really control for the working memory component of each "non-working memory" test (you could do it half-assedly by giving multiple different tests, but then you're disproportionately controlling for some things over others and thus things other than working memory unless you manage to give enough tests to capture the entire human psyche).

So how much of each test is due to working memory or how much is due to the particular test is actually not that easy to determine. You can really only go by logical inference and what is most likely the case.

What we do know is that things like N-back training (which is again thought to approximate pure working memory) increase IQ, things like physical activity (particularly high-intensity cardiovascular and power/speed training) and optimal diet and pharmaceuticals (e.g. amphetamines). So basic things that increase the baseline functioning, metabolic capacity, bloodflow, do increase IQ, and do so in a rate-dependent way (more bloodflow or energy to the brain does not necessarily make you a completely different person, just sharper, quicker, clearer).

And when you do try to make tests for approximating pure working memory (again like N-back), we see that this operationalization of working memory tends to correlate with IQ around 0.50-0.80, which is a moderate to strong correlation (0.90-0.95 is more or less the maximum you could expect before you start to suspect statistical problems). And even if some other tests could score higher, again, how much of that is working memory and how much of that is something else? 

So working memory is the basis of all mental operations, you can't really control for its effects properly using tests, and when you try to make tests for working memory, they correlate strongly with IQ, and IQ tests have built-in incentives for speed (time pressure) and for completing a large number of tasks (usually around 100), and we see that physiological rate-dependent factors do increase IQ.

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now