Seed

Member
  • Content count

    756
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Seed

  1. Amazing self awareness. Really interesting and thanks for sharing
  2. I’m wondering whether you might be negatively biased towards ‘men like him’ e.g: narcissistic, exploitative , womanizing. All of which he admits he is. Also is there a part of you that is holding onto the ‘I see through the bullshit’ lense which is preventing you from seeing the case for what it is. it’s easily done. is there also a fear that if he isn’t a ‘wild animal’ then a loving father and morally questionable but lawful man is being locked up for a decade, based on stories and judgement ? The current narrative of him being a beast is far more comfortable and palatable than the alternative: and I believe this becomes a bias towards the ‘victims’ .
  3. Fair. And have you got any negative bias? Aside from the horrible stories?
  4. Of course. Out of interest - are you aware of what own biases might be towards Russell? Is anyone on this thread aware of them?
  5. @Wilhelm44 very possible.. along with the rest of the world. how can one think of this objectively? And bringing his comedy forward as evidence to prosecute shows just how much they were scraping the barrel.
  6. And that’s an opinion you have rather than facts. The issue here is whether he was fairly trialled and I don’t believe he was.
  7. Perhaps a text along the lines of ‘you forced me, I told you to stop and you didn’t…’ might hold more weight. And / or a text that had been recovered rather than ‘remembered’
  8. So because he doesn’t perceive what the other person perceives. Is this proof beyond reasonable doubt that he’s lying? She didnt accuse him of rape at this point either. She accused him of ‘treating her like an animal’.
  9. He didn’t intervene during the interrogations. He should have. He allowed them to be retraumatised. This could have prejudiced the jury. Try to look at all the angles here. It doesn’t mean the jury are wrong and Russell is innocent. BUt tho is behaviour shouldn’t have been allowed in the court room as it can cause harm to the victims and Russell’s defence. I believe it wasn’t dealt with appropriately. At the time. explain after the fact is too late. The damage is done,
  10. This could also be grounds for appeeal As he was clearly incompetent so it could be argued that his unprofessional and insensitive attacks prejudiced the jury. And if he was that incompetent, how could he have represented his client responsibly.. A capabable judge ‘doing his job’ should have intervened. But, he allowed it to happen. Which is another grounds for appeal.
  11. Not necessarily- it would depend on what grounds the appeal is approved. Eg. If the trial was brought to court based on a weak case and the possibility of the documentary prejudicing the judge / jury - this would not be the fault of the judge, but the CPS.
  12. Because he’s innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. still waiting on the proof.
  13. This incorrect. he sent her a sorry text 6 months later when he got back in touch with her to hook up again and she said ‘you treated me like an animal and he said ‘I’m sorry’ these texts were part of her story and not recovered by police. when confronted , he said he probably did say he was sorry as she clearly was not happy about the encounter. Please remember that sex can be degrading , humiliating and painful whilst still being ‘consensual’ in the eyes of law. people can also apologise without having committed a crime. She was upset with her, he said ‘sorry’. I am also wondering why he would get in touch 6 months later to hook up again if he had violently raped her? That could have easily triggered her to phone the police.
  14. Dude. He was sober from 2002. All the allegations bar one (which he was cleared of) were a during his sobriety .
  15. @Leo Gura it isn’t the judges job to decide whether charges are brought to trial. That’s the CPS. Might be different in USA.
  16. @Leo Gura he’s also human and subject to bias, external pressure etc. In fact: the amount of pressure he was under was obscene. I’m wondering if he wasn’t Russell Brand, would there even have been a trial? What about the many, MANY women and girls who are raped a few days prior who gather up the courage to go the police and are told they won’t be believed. That there is ‘NOT ENOUGH EVIDENCE’. Is it possible that this judge couldn’t judge fairly because the trial was brought to court unfairly?
  17. I’m only throwing it out there. I’m not defending him. I’m trying to offer a wider perspective.
  18. It seems insane to go on a ‘well it seems more likely than than not’ determination. Particularly given the fact he is a celebrity so extremely vulnerable to unconscious projection and bias.
  19. And not just his life you’re betting on, but the life of his wife and three children.
  20. @Leo Gura well if I was on a jury I would only find someone guilty if I was so sure that I’d bet my own life on it. That seems fair.
  21. Yeah and my other argument is that if we wouldn’t bet 10.5 years on our own lives that’s he’s guilty than how can we do it to his?
  22. I totally agree and I can see my bias! I absolutely don’t know if he’s innocent. He could well have done these crimes, but he could well have not. I don’t claim to ‘know’ him in the same way everyone else does. And this is what alarms me. It’s so easy to project on to a celebrity, has basically a cartoon character and that goes for my own bias as well. I feel like I’m questioning a lot as I am trying to convince myself that he is guilty of that makes sense? But nothing seems solid enough. At all. Apart from a hell of a lot of judgment, stereotyping and projection. Check out this guy’s take. He rips Russell every episode. So funny.