AtmanIsBrahman

Is IQ is a Valid/Meaningful Measure of Intelligence?

105 posts in this topic

8 hours ago, Carl-Richard said:

The thing about working memory is that it underlies all mental operations. Every test you ever do involves working memory. So tests for reasoning and pattern recognition do actually test working memory, and it's not possible to really control for it. You can make so-called tests for approximating pure working memory (e.g. digit span tests, N-back), but you can never really control for the working memory component of each "non-working memory" test

I see what you mean. But again, pattern recognition, fluid intelligence, and whatever else you want to call these mental faculties are probably more important than just working memory for other portions of the test. How well you do on a matrix problem is more so determined by your pattern-spotting ability than brute force working memory.

 

8 hours ago, Carl-Richard said:

What we do know is that things like N-back training (which is again thought to approximate pure working memory) increase IQ, things like physical activity (particularly high-intensity cardiovascular and power/speed training) and optimal diet and pharmaceuticals (e.g. amphetamines). So basic things that increase the baseline functioning, metabolic capacity, bloodflow, etc., do increase IQ, and do so in a rate-dependent way (more bloodflow or energy to the brain does not necessarily make you a completely different person, just sharper, quicker, clearer).

This isn't true based on what I know. Training N-back will make you do better at that task, but not what the test is trying to measure. I actually researched this -- people can use memory techniques to hugely improve at these things, but that doesn't mean they got smarter. 

I also highly doubt that physical activity or pharmaceuticals will do much beyond maybe a couple IQ points.

Edited by AtmanIsBrahman

What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After thinking about this topic a lot, I basically think Leo was right:

IQ does measure something real, but it's too reductionistic. 

High IQ people can still be stupid, and mostly are. 

The core problem is that no one understands intelligence, and even worse they don't understand that they don't understand it. 

Who would have thought Leo would be right? ¬¬


What is this? That's the only question.

My Youtube Channel - Philosophy | Spirituality | Consciousness Work

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 minutes ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

Who would have thought Leo would be right?

suspicious-v0-rthjqjyenrq81.png


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I see what you mean. But again, pattern recognition, fluid intelligence, and whatever else you want to call these mental faculties are probably more important than just working memory for other portions of the test. How well you do on a matrix problem is more so determined by your pattern-spotting ability than brute force working memory.

We don't know that, and if true, to what degree. What is known is that comparing a pattern against a template requires holding things in working memory, updating, manipulating, discarding, etc.

What we also know is that a comprehensive IQ test tries to test many different domains and kinds of mental operations, and that in aggregate, the contribution of each specific domain lessens and the more general mechanisms become more salient. And of course, the general workspace of the mind, the working memory, approximates such a mechanism.

41583_2003_Article_BFnrn1201_Fig5_HTML.jpg

https://www.nature.com/articles/nrn1201

"Fluid intelligence" is what IQ is trying to test (along with crystallized intelligence).

 

9 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

This isn't true based on what I know. Training N-back will make you do better at that task, but not what the test is trying to measure. I actually researched this -- people can use memory techniques to hugely improve at these things, but that doesn't mean they got smarter.

It has been shown to make you perform better on IQ tests. Whether IQ can be said to capture "intelligence" is of course a different question. Also, the particular literature on N-back training seems to be underdetermined mainly due to the problem of assigning participants to your study (they tend to be not very motivated to perform well, not knowledgeable about what they're doing or seeking out knowledge or mentorship/advice, not seriously aiming to improve, less likely to actually be consistent or engage with high focus or intensity). You should expect greater effects if you're motivated, educated, engaged (and people do anecdotally report great changes in their day to day life and also on IQ tests, e.g. 13 IQ points after a year of training).

 

9 hours ago, AtmanIsBrahman said:

I also highly doubt that physical activity or pharmaceuticals will do much beyond maybe a couple IQ points.

I believe most people underestimate especially how sprint training in particular affects cognition. Lactate is something the brain responds to in a very interesting way (besides the act of pushing the ceiling of intensity of your physiology, seems to have a direct mirror in your psychology, in that you're able to do more intense cognitive operations, which would at least affect working memory particularly well).

As for "a couple of points", a couple of IQ points is a lot considering an increase from 115 (most college graduates) to 120 pushes you from top 16% to top 9% of people. Comparable to going from a B to an A. If you're even higher than that, e.g. 136, and increase it to 149 (13 points), like one anecdote, you go from already gifted to genius level. The kinds of things you can do at that level and the compounding effects over time are definitely not to be discarded.

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now