integral

Epistemic Puzzle #1

11 posts in this topic

Lets see how high your epistemic rating is with puzzles:

Puzzle #1 Here is some scientific information vets use to justify neutering animals. What do you think of this epistemically? 

 

image.png

image.png

image.png

 

Populare Vet Opinion: Neutering makes animals live longer, it reduces some disease, and calms them down. 

 

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would probably ask my vet sister about this. I think the choice of color for increased and decreased can be confusing if it makes it look like a good or bad thing. The way it is presented gives minimal information and various scientific terms you would need to understand.

I think the way all of this is presented is confusing, but solvable.

Also is there an ethical way to test this on humans then? Would neutering humans make us live longer?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34 minutes ago, trenton said:

I think the way all of this is presented is confusing, but solvable.

It is a puzzle with a right answer, but it takes interpretation of data in a new way then what its presented.

Neutered animals live 2 years longer on average according to the data.

Does that then mean we should neuter all animals? 

Edited by integral

How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would not sterilize my animals. Why?

I would not sterilize a male animal, because the lack of testosterone makes male dogs lazy and fat. This leads to a reduced life expectancy.

I would also not sterilize any female animals, even though I would have the hassle of having to deal with a bleeding vulva every 6 months.


I AM a Website EMPIRE, and a persona

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Psychonaut said:

I would not sterilize a male animal, because the lack of testosterone makes male dogs lazy and fat. This leads to a reduced life expectancy.

Good but the data shows it increase life expectancy.

The first half of what you said is correct, hormonal issues, the second half is missing something.


How is this post just me acting out my ego in the usual ways? Is this post just me venting and justifying my selfishness? Are the things you are posting in alignment with principles of higher consciousness and higher stages of ego development? Are you acting in a mature or immature way? Are you being selfish or selfless in your communication? Are you acting like a monkey or like a God-like being?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Being overweight leads to a reduced health expectancy. If you reduce the food intake then the weight stays the same.

Being about 20% underweight increases life expetancy about 20% from what I recall. This is independent of the neutering and is entirely dependant on the owner and the owners discipline when it comes to feeding the animal.


I AM a Website EMPIRE, and a persona

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Long Story Short. This claim is bullshit. It is a logical phallacy. It is applying reverse logic and isolating a single claim to a single outcome. That is what is called classical bullshit science. You need to look at all factors apply Bayes Theorem, find all variables and then you can make a claim. If you can't do that. You first have to prove statistical relevance. Blablablablabla. I failed statistics, or I never actually did a statistics course.

BTW. I really love this format @integral GREAT JOB!!!

Edited by Psychonaut

I AM a Website EMPIRE, and a persona

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, integral said:

It is a puzzle with a right answer, but it takes interpretation of data in a new way then what its presented.

Neutered animals live 2 years longer on average according to the data.

Does that then mean we should neuter all animals? 

Firstly, is the question we are trying to answer is "should we neuter all animals?"

If so, then firstly why are we attaching significance to individual lifespan as though it were a moral good? Secondly, the logical endpoint would be that animals could not reproduce at all if all animals were neutered, therefore collectively they would go extinct quickly. Otherwise, we raise the problem of a select few being bred to our liking.

So is this a problem of individual health versus collective health? Why survive individuals at the cost of the entire species? This is a values question rather than an epistemic question.

Alternatively, what if we cured the diseases, had other means of preventing them, and allowed an environment for energy to be properly used? Would animals live longer on average given a different environment or is it specific to human environments and our limitations which would make them live shorter when it would otherwise be longer?

There are many ignored factors in this data in that the average does not account for different environments tailored to what a non sterile animal would need.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought the biggest reason to neuter (e.g The price is right) was to reduce the harm to the unwanted litters of puppies and kittens.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, integral said:

Does that then mean we should neuter all animals? 

Yes including humans. I never consented to be born!

Birth control is a type of neutering in a way. Also an insalubrious lifestyle is too. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also did not consent to be born! OR did it? That is a good question...

I think this was the first incarnation in which I am fully aware that I choose my parents.


I AM a Website EMPIRE, and a persona

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now