Carl-Richard

"Simple but not easy" might often be an underdetermination of the complexity

2 posts in this topic

First, a definition of terms:

Simple = not complex. Complexity is many interacting things, simplicity is few interacting things.
Easy = not hard. Hardness is the difficulty with which something is performed, easiness is the lightness 
with which something is performed.

 

We might tend to say something is simple but not easy if we can imagine and describe the general task in simple terms but the execution is not easy. This might be more true for some problems, for example lifting a heavy object. The task of lifting it up is thought to be simple and it's the weight of the object that makes it hard.

But for other problems, this might be less true. For example, I'm currently filling door cracks with rubber for isolating the doors. I wanted to describe it to myself as "simple but not easy", but I realized that the actions for filling them is actually not simple.

Sometimes it's really hard to make the rubber fit inside the crack, and the reason for this might be complex: the exact size and width of the crack might vary along the length of the door frame, the exact properties of the rubber might vary due to production processes and inhomogeneity of the material.

It's just that when we usually describe the task, we tend to ignore that level of detail and simply describe it as "fitting the rubber inside the crack". It's a bit like describing football (soccer) as "getting the ball inside the net". It's of course a bit more complex than that.

So the complexity is underdetermined in our description of the problem and we outsource its hidden complexity to its hardness, "it's simple but hard". There might also be hidden complexity in the lifting heavy object example, but here the complexity might even be more hidden as it's perhaps harder to describe in principle (and we just pack that complexity as a simple description, "biology").

Edited by Carl-Richard

Intrinsic joy = being x meaning ²

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting thought and I think it checks out. This is perhaps the main problem with abstraction. For example whenever we talk about reality in terms that give us a sense of understanding or clarity the question is are we really understanding anything or are we just hiding the complexity behind a fancy abstraction? As in when Leo says “I am God” that seems like a simple, profound statement but the question is doesn”t the statement itself sacrifice the very complexity, or infinity that the word God implies.


Basically what I’m trying to say is that I think what you’re pointing towards reveals a big deception in everything from science to spirituality where in reality things are way more complex than any single statement can contain.

Edit: It’s like lossy compression in audio or images. If you compress a high resolution photo a little bit, it’s still recognizable. If you compress it by 99.9%, you’re just looking at a single beige square, basically the image has totally changed and bears no resemblence anymore to the real image. That’s the risk with abstraction.

 

Edited by Asayake

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now