Someone here

My understanding of God

167 posts in this topic

1 hour ago, Xonas Pitfall said:

Again, just to clarify, I'm not trying to be "clever" or anything. I'm genuinely just asking questions because I'm confused, haha 😅

Not to sound too haughty (which it most probably will), but it seems to me that Leo is bad at explaining these things due to egoic and dogmatic biases that heavily distort his reasoning.

The answer to your "omniscience" vs. "knowledge" question is actually rather simple and straightforward (even though it probably still won't satisfy you, lol):

God/Reality/The Absolute is all that there is, therefore it has no opposite, therefore it is (and must be) everything and nothing.

Conceptual knowledge (as well as experience) is always about knowing "something", i.e. specific parts of reality that have opposites.

Therefore, you cannot ever fully know/experience/be conscious of all of reality. You can however get closer and closer and closer to "knowing it" (which is what the evolution of consciousness is all about); and the closer you get to "knowing everything", the more it will feel like "knowing nothing"... because, again, everything and nothing are two sides of the same coin.

Hope this helps.


The World Is Illusion.

Only Brahman Is Real.

The World Is Brahman.                                                 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, Hyperion said:

Not to sound too haughty (which it most probably will), but it seems to me that Leo is bad at explaining these things due to egoic and dogmatic biases that heavily distort his reasoning.

The answer to your "omniscience" vs. "knowledge" question is actually rather simple and straightforward (even though it probably still won't satisfy you, lol):

God/Reality/The Absolute is all that there is, therefore it has no opposite, therefore it is (and must be) everything and nothing.

Conceptual knowledge (as well as experience) is always about knowing "something", i.e. specific parts of reality that have opposites.

Therefore, you cannot ever fully know/experience/be conscious of all of reality. You can however get closer and closer and closer to "knowing it" (which is what the evolution of consciousness is all about); and the closer you get to "knowing everything", the more it will feel like "knowing nothing"... because, again, everything and nothing are two sides of the same coin.

Hope this helps.

I see! But my question then is: why stop at "nothing"?

Or, I guess, to give a better example:
I keep drawing the comparison between love and evil/hate because I feel like it illustrates my "confusion" well.

"You can, however, get closer and closer to loving everything (which is what the evolution of consciousness is all about); and the closer you get to loving everything, the more it will feel like loving nothing... because, again, everything and nothing are two sides of the same coin."

So, following that reasoning, I could conclude that the foundation of reality is Evil (loving nothing), because eventually you go from loving everything to loving nothing.

Therefore, both Love and Evil would have to be equally fundamental properties of God.

But that doesn't seem like what most of us would agree with here. So why should we privilege "not-knowing (knowing nothing)" over "omniscience (knowing everything)" when describing the Absolute? In the same way, why don't we privilege "loving nothing" (Absolute Neutrality) over "loving everything" (Absolute Love) when describing God's fundamental nature?

If you say that something knows "everything, or is quote and quote approaching ever more," you wouldn't normally consider that closer to the definition of "not-knowing" than omniscience.

I mean, if something is getting closer and closer to knowing absolutely everything (along a relative timeline, since there isn't really "time" for God), wouldn't you naturally describe it as approaching omniscience rather than not-knowing?

At the very least, you'd call it the closest thing to omniscience there is.

That's how I understand it.

Using the example you gave, you could imagine God as something like an integral that keeps approaching infinity in terms of knowledge, until, at its highest point, it achieves complete omniscience or total, absolute consciousness.

Similarly, you could say that God progressively approaches complete understanding or Absolute Love as it unites with everything, until there are no remaining fragments, distinctions, biases, or separations. It is all Unified, all One, all Love; hence, we don't say God is Absolute "Evil".


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
58 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

How many hairs does God have on his ass? You are God, so why don't you know? Where is your Omniscience?

I guess, to contemplate this xD

I don't see a reason why God wouldn't know.

Again, I completely agree that, as humans, we can't. We're relative beings, and when you start talking about God and ass hairs, you're talking about an infinite timeline, all possible iterations, and potentially infinite variations of existence.

Even if a human somehow tried to "download" all that knowledge, their brain would probably explode.

But again, we're talking about GOD here.

God IS that hairy ass, every hair on it, every bit of skin, and every possible iteration of hairy asses you could ever conceive of.

So why would God necessarily have any limitations in observing or knowing its own ass hairs?

God is simultaneously the observer, the observed, and every possible finite perspective through which those observations occur.

If God really couldn't know something about itself, my question would be: What exactly is imposing that limitation?

What is preventing God from knowing or observing some aspect of its own existence?

If anyone could know every hair on its own ass, wouldn't it be an Infinite Self-Referencing Intelligence that literally IS every self, every observer, and everything observed, with nothing outside itself?

And if God itself imposes that limitation, is it really a limitation definitionally?

But again, as I've said before, if we define "knowledge" as something inherently finite and conceptual, then sure, I can understand that.

What I still don't understand is why "not-knowing" would be a better description.

Doesn't not-knowing ordinarily imply some kind of lack, absence, or negation?

I've never really encountered a technical definition of "not-knowing" that would make it a more appropriate description of Absolute Infinity.

Usually, when we choose words to describe God, we favor terms like:

  • Love rather than Hate: Because love implies inclusion, acceptance, and unity, whereas hate implies rejection, exclusion, or separation.
  • Infinite rather than Finite: Because finitude implies boundaries and limitations, whereas infinity transcends them.
  • Intelligent rather than Unintelligent: Because intelligence implies the capacity to understand, connect, create, and integrate, whereas unintelligence suggests a lack of understanding or capacity.
  • Conscious rather than Unconscious: Because consciousness implies awareness, whereas unconsciousness suggests an absence.
  • Powerful rather than Weak: Because power implies capacity and ability, whereas weakness implies limitations or an inability to act.
  • Omnipotent rather than Impotent: Because omnipotence implies unlimited power, whereas impotence implies an inability to exercise power.

The reason we favor these terms, at least as I understand it, is that they seem to point toward something more integrative, unlimited, and free of separation or "otherness."

  1. For example, we don't fundamentally describe God as finite because finitude implies some boundary beyond which something else exists, an "Other" that is somehow limiting God.
  2. We don't describe God as unintelligent because that suggests there is something God cannot understand, integrate, or comprehend, an "Other" that is somehow outside of God's reach.
  3. We don't describe God as unconscious because that suggests some aspect of reality exists outside its awareness, an "Other" that is somehow outside of God's reach.
  4. And we don't describe God as weak or impotent because those terms suggest limitations on its ability or power, an "Other" that is somehow limiting God.

Yet when it comes to knowledge, we suddenly seem to reverse this pattern and describe God as fundamentally not-knowing rather than all-knowing.

So that's my question: Why does "not-knowing" fit better here? What exactly is limiting God?

Again, I apologize if there's some deeper technical or mystical definition I'm missing.

If "knowledge" is being defined as inherently finite, while "not-knowing" somehow refers to a more unlimited, nondual state of Consciousness, then I can understand the distinction.

But I've never encountered these terms being used that way.

Usually, when I hear "not-knowing," I understand it as implying a lack of awareness or understanding, something unknown, inaccessible, or beyond one's ability to grasp.

In other words, something "other" that escapes one's consciousness.

And that seems difficult to reconcile with the very definition of God as Absolute Infinity, Infinite Intelligence, and pure Consciousness, where nothing exists outside the totality of what God is.

So I'm trying to understand why not-knowing would be considered a more fundamental or accurate description of God's nature than Absolute Knowing.


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Leo Gura said:

You guys should understand that I do not fully understand the highest levels of God. I know the gist of it, but not all the details. As far as details go, I could get parts wrong.

And no worries at all! Again, I don't think people (or at least I hope not) expect you to know everything.

I think the issue is more when someone makes very confident, absolutist statements like "This is the truth. How do you not understand? This is just how it is," etc.

Then, at least for me, I start thinking, "Oh fuck, if this is really THAT obvious and they're THAT confident about it, what am I missing here?" And that can actually leave me even more confused, haha.

Whereas if there were some acknowledgment from the start, like "Hey, this is a tricky topic, and I'm not entirely sure myself," then it could turn into a much more fun and open discussion where we're all trying to figure things out together and bounce ideas off each other xD


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Leo Gura said:

The Unknowable is known through Being it.

Maybe this?

I think it's also possible that this is the distinction: God doesn't really "know" reality; it IS.

Which is completely fine; I agree.

However, if "knowing" is a relative, finite activity, and God possesses a higher-order version of knowing, namely pure BEING itself, then surely relative knowing would be a piece of cake for God?

It's similar to how we distinguish between relative love and Absolute Love.

If hatred, separation, and conditional love are all finite expressions of Absolute Love, while God possesses the highest, most inclusive form of Love, then of course God can manifest all those "lower" relative forms of Absolute Love.


+------------------------------------------------+
|                 INFINITY (GOD)                 |
|                                                |
|       ABSOLUTE BEING / CONSCIOUSNESS / LOVE     |
|                                                |
|       +--------------------------------+       |
|       |       RELATIVE REALITY         |       |
|       |                                |       |
|       |  Knowing / Concepts            |       |
|       |  Distinctions / Perspectives   |       |
|       |  Conditional Love / Hate       |       |
|       |  Finite Experiences            |       |
|       |                                |       |
|       +--------------------------------+       |
|                                                |
|   God IS the whole, including every part.      |
+------------------------------------------------+

You could imagine it as two nested sets:

The larger set is INFINITY, where God possesses absolute BEING, LOVE, and CONSCIOUSNESS.

Within that larger set are all the finite, relative expressions of those properties.

For example, relative knowledge could be understood as a limited form of Being. Because a finite human cannot literally BE everything, they instead try to understand reality by mentally conceptualizing, separating, and categorizing it.

But God doesn't have that limitation. God literally IS everything that the human is trying to know.

So if God already possesses the higher-order reality of BEING, why would the lower-order activity of "knowing" be problematic for God?

I completely understand why this would be impossible for finite beings. A finite human cannot attain or embody the totality of Infinite Love, Being, or Consciousness.

But God certainly can, because God IS that totality.

It's like saying that I possess an infinite reservoir of water, but somehow I'm incapable of filling a single bottle.


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Leo Gura said:

The Unknowable is known through Being it.

The known knows nothing. 



 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Xonas Pitfall

Again, God/Reality is all that there is, therefore it has no opposite. So you are free to call it whatever you want: "God", "Devil", "Reality", "Unreality", "Everything", "Nothing", "Spirit", "Matter", "Love", "Hate", "Good", "Evil", "Oneness", "Multiplicity", "A Slice Of Apple Pie", "Not A Slice Of Apple Pie"... it makes no difference whatsoever.

See, you are trying to conceptually understand and label All That There Is, which is a fool's errand. Like I said, conceptual understanding is always understanding of something; and by trying to come up with an "accurate label" for Everything/Nothing, you are essentially trying to fit Infinity into a neat little mental box, which will and can never work.

In short: Anything you call it isn't it... and also it is, but so is the opposite of what you call it.


The World Is Illusion.

Only Brahman Is Real.

The World Is Brahman.                                                 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now