Someone here

My understanding of God

165 posts in this topic

8 hours ago, Leo Gura said:

In philosophy, knowledge usually means "true justified belief". Knowledge is usually propositional: The Earth is round, or the moon is not made out of cheese.

When you say that God should know everything, that would mean that God should know how many ants are in Australia right now at 2:23 pm, Nov 15th 2026.

You should not expect God to have that kind of knowledge.

You can, of course, define terms however you like, but you have to be careful because you can define terms in counter-productive ways.

Do you know how many ants there are in Australia right now? Neither does God.

A question please :

God is said to be Omniscient in exactly that sense in all religious traditions.  That he ( it) does indeed know how many grains of dust exists on the planet Mars right this moment of time( if we freeze time) . And even if we allow time to unfold , then he knows the number each moment . Even before the number changes from one second to another. He already knows the past , the present , the future . All at once . That’s the typical understanding of what an omniscient God is supposed to mean .  Isn’t that correct? 
If there is a fixed information of “the number of grains of sand on planet Mars right this moment is (X) “ , then saying that God doesn’t know that number would mean God is not omniscient or possesses infinite knowledge. God would be ignorant .

Edited by Someone here

“God is the Alpha Omega .. the beginning-less  beginning and the endless end . 
He is the first without start . He is the last without end . He is the manifest actuality ..nothing covers him . He is the most hidden essence  ..nothing can grasp him .. nothing below him or more subtle than him .The ego is the belief I’m separate from god . Because being god is too good to be true .No matter how dark it gets or difficult it gets ..no matter how long it is going to take .. my destiny is the infinite happiness and infinite joy and love as the best thing ever ..God .  “

-that’s a me .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  1. Claim: God cannot possess complete relative knowledge of everything it manifests.
  2. Therefore, God's property isn't "knowledge"; it's "not-knowing."

My question is: if God is both finite and infinite, all there is, everything and nothing, then we'd have:

  1. Absolute consciousness, which is prior to all distinctions.
  2. Relative consciousness, which generates distinctions and knowledge of the "relative".
  3. One total reality that encompasses both without contradiction.

If God's consciousness is absolutely unlimited, and there is no division between the knower and the known at the absolute level, what could make any aspect of God's own being inaccessible to God's consciousness? What is this "other" made of, if not God's own substrate, that would even allow for such a blockage?

-

Quote

For God to know stuff, it is being a "regular" human right now, right? You as an ego know stuff. Now imagine that your "human mind" would somehow merge with another human. Two human minds thinking at the same time, two bodies to control. How would you even begin to manage that? How would you choose which mind to think with? It's hard enough to make one human mind think properly or shut up and focus.

Again, this is a completely valid argument for a human and why a human might not be capable of knowing everything. But we're talking about GOD, THE ABSOLUTE, INFINITY.

From a human perspective, of course I cannot be conscious of everything. My brain is only partially aware of things like my heartbeat, blood circulation, nervous system, motor functions, and countless subconscious processes.

But we're talking about God, which you define as absolutely EVERYTHING. God is everything, creates everything, and there is no separation. It's the total unity of all that exists, encompassing both every relative perspective and the Absolute itself.

So why couldn't that totality be omniscient? God is simultaneously my heartbeat, me experiencing that heartbeat, my family observing me, and every other perspective and interaction involved. God IS all of it simultaneously.

-

To explain it further, let's say a scientist wants to perfectly KNOW something, like a mosquito.

What would that scientist ideally want to do?

They'd want to observe the mosquito in the wild, in a laboratory, zoomed in, zoomed out, throughout its entire lifespan, and across all of time. They'd want to understand every aspect of its biology, behavior, and interactions with its environment.

Would the scientists want to become the mosquito? To experience reality from its perspective? And then become the mosquito it mates with, the predator that hunts it, the human it bites, the blood it consumes, the environment it inhabits, and every single organism and process that interacts with it?

And not just from one perspective, but from ALL perspectives, throughout all of time, including every possible interaction, relationship, and experience.

Now, of course, a scientist cannot do this because they're finite and limited to a particular perspective.

But God has ZERO limitations. God isn't merely observing the mosquito from outside. God IS the mosquito, its environment, every observer, every interaction, and the entire reality in which all of this takes place.

In that sense, God would be the perfect scientist, perfect knower, and the perfect experiencer, because there is literally nothing outside of God that could remain inaccessible to it.

Am I making sense? Wouldn't you call this the closest possible thing to omniscience?

-

If you say that knowing is finite and limiting, but not-knowing is unlimited and fundamental, we need to define exactly what not-knowing means.

If it means the absence of conceptual distinctions, then I understand. But I'd question whether this is the correct "technical" term.

If anything, I could argue that you can call it complete knowing, not "not-knowing". When we say God is UNITY, LOVE, "COMPLETE UNDERSTANDING," integration, these all point toward "integrative knowing" definitions, not not-knowing. Similarly, you wouldn't call God the ultimate destroyer, the ultimate hater, or the ultimate not-knower, because that implies a "lack," something missing, something that escapes the "unity." What is God not able to be aware of? What escapes this "unity" for God to not know?

But if it means the inability to be conscious of some aspect of reality, why would that be an essential characteristic of an absolutely unlimited God?

I think when most of us say "not-knowing," we'd define it more closely as this: the inability to be conscious of some aspect of reality, or the inability to grasp a concept of reality.


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I guess, to point out the contradictions I've noticed:

Contradiction 1:

You say "knowledge is a very technical term." I could say the same about the term "not-knowing."

This is what I find when I look it up:

  1. Ignorance: A lack of knowledge, information, or understanding (neutral in its literal sense, though often used as a harsh label).
  2. Unaware / Oblivious: Lacking consciousness or attention toward a specific fact or event.
  3. Unknowing / Unwitting: Acting or existing without knowledge or intent.
  4. Nescient: A formal or literary term meaning lacking knowledge or ignorant.
  5. Incognizant: Lacking awareness or failing to notice something.

All of these imply a lower level of consciousness, something that "escapes" God's awareness.

None of these definitions describe "having no distinctions or concepts."

What you're pointing toward seems closer to:

Not-knowing in the mystical sense: A form of openness in which reality is experienced without being reduced to conceptual knowledge.

You're pointing toward a nondual understanding of consciousness.

That was my original issue. For example, we have no problem using the term "infinity" to describe God, and we don't dismiss it as merely a "human mathematical concept." But when it comes to knowledge, we're choosing a term that ordinarily implies ignorance and attributing it to the Absolute, to God. Hence my confusion.

Contradiction 2:

Just as people argued that you wouldn't call God "all-hateful," even though relative hatred exists among finite beings, I could make the same argument about not-knowing.

You wouldn't call God fundamentally "not-knowing" if that term implies a finite limitation, namely, God's inability to access or be aware of something.

That wouldn't accurately describe God's fundamental nature, because God is awareness itself, pure consciousness. So using "not-knowing" in that sense would be flawed.

But again, if "not-knowing" is being used to imply the absence of dualities and conceptual distinctions, rather than a lack of awareness of finite things, then sure, I can understand that.

I'd just say that this definition of "not-knowing" is not one I'm familiar with, and it seems quite different from how the term is ordinarily understood.


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys, this issue is very subtle and advanced.

You are trying to understand Omniscience, yet you expect to understand it through simplistic human ideas. That cannot work.

Omniscience is real, but it's way more advanced than you imagine. Omniscience is not human knowledge.

Yes, there are contradictions, because a human cannot understand Omniscience.

If you expect me to explain Omniscience to you in a forum post, you are kidding yourself.

Omniscience is more advanced than the most advanced math and science in the world's top universities.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorry! Just to clarify, when I type these things out, it's mostly me trying to deconstruct these ideas for myself. I'm not expecting you to explain everything to me or anyone else. It's more like I'm having a debate with myself and others to deepen my own understanding, haha. All love to Leo! ❤️


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Xonas Pitfall No worries, you ask good questions.


You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Leo Gura No problem. It just strikes me as very strange and odd to say god is omniscient but “ omniscient “ doesn’t mean he knows all facutal information now , or in the entire timeline of existence. That there are things which exist and are real and can be quantified, yet god doesn’t know them and is ignoarnt about them. With keeping in mind that god is already being everything that exists .

this makes no sense .


“God is the Alpha Omega .. the beginning-less  beginning and the endless end . 
He is the first without start . He is the last without end . He is the manifest actuality ..nothing covers him . He is the most hidden essence  ..nothing can grasp him .. nothing below him or more subtle than him .The ego is the belief I’m separate from god . Because being god is too good to be true .No matter how dark it gets or difficult it gets ..no matter how long it is going to take .. my destiny is the infinite happiness and infinite joy and love as the best thing ever ..God .  “

-that’s a me .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, Someone here said:

this makes no sense .

It would make a lot more sense if you stopped treating God as something other to yourself.

You are God and you don't even know what you are yet.

God's Omniscience depends on what state of Consciousness it is in.

God in a low state of Consciousness thinks the Earth is flat.

You think those contradictions are bad? How do you explain that God is Omniscient and God is a Flat Earther?

If God is Omniscient, why does Flat Earth and MAGA exist?

I shouldn't be explaining to you, you should be explaining to me how this is possible.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Quote

When you say that God should know everything, that would mean that God should know how many ants are in Australia right now at 2:23 pm, Nov 15th 2026.

You should not expect God to have that kind of knowledge.

You can, of course, define terms however you like, but you have to be careful because you can define terms in counter-productive ways.

Do you know how many ants there are in Australia right now? Neither does God.

I feel like this same argument could be used when we talk about God being all-loving rather than all-hating.

For example, when I say God is all-loving, that doesn't mean God can suddenly cure the sadism of a serial killer, or eliminate the hunger and survival instincts of a tiger chasing a gazelle to hunt, cannibalize, and eat.

You should not expect God to have that kind of ability in the relative sense.

You can, of course, define terms however you like, but you have to be careful because you can define terms in counterproductive ways.

Do you know how to make a sadist suddenly fall in love with charity? Neither does God.

So, following the same reasoning, I could argue: See? God isn't all-loving after all. God cannot make every finite being loving, eliminate all hatred, or cure every instance of suffering.

But of course, that would be an incorrect understanding of what Absolute Love means.

If we wouldn't reject God's Absolute Love simply because hatred and suffering exist within relative reality, why should we reject God's Absolute Knowing simply because particular forms of relative knowledge aren't available from a finite perspective?

1 minute ago, Someone here said:

@Leo Gura No problem. It just strikes me as very strange and odd to say god is omniscient but “ omniscient “ doesn’t mean he knows all facutal information now , or in the entire timeline of existence. That there are things which exist and are real and can be quantified, yet god doesn’t know them and is ignoarnt about them. With keeping in mind that god is already being everything that exists .

this makes no sense .

I think the way I understand it is that, definition-wise, "not-knowing" here probably means something like "the absence of bias, distinctions, and specific forms of knowing." So in that sense, it would be a fair attribute of God.

I guess my critique was simply that "not-knowing" isn't usually used that way, and that what we're describing would more commonly be understood as omniscience, at least in the way we ordinarily use these "technical human terms," I suppose. I think this is especially true if we describe God as Infinite Intelligence. You definitely wouldn't, or at least I wouldn't, attribute a term (not-knowing) that usually implies "unawareness," "lack of insight," or "ignorance" in ordinary human language to such a being.


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Xonas Pitfall said:

"not-knowing" here probably means something like "the absence of bias, distinctions, and specific forms of knowing."

No.

Not-knowing is far deeper than that.

Literally, Reality is so relativistically advanced everything is unknowable.

The more conscious you become of God, the deeper the not-knowing will become until you realize that everything you know is nonsense. Nothing at all can be known, ultimately.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

God in a low state of Consciousness thinks the Earth is flat.

You think those contradictions are bad? How do you explain that God is Omniscient and God is a Flat Earther?

If God is Omniscient, why does Flat Earth and MAGA exist?

I shouldn't be explaining to you, you should be explaining to me how this is possible.

God in a low state of Consciousness can be a sadist who enjoys causing suffering.

You think those contradictions are bad? How do you explain that God is Absolute Love and God is simultaneously a sadist?

If God is All-Loving, why do hatred, sadism, cruelty, and suffering exist?

I shouldn't be explaining to you how this is possible. You should be explaining to me how God can be Absolute Love while simultaneously manifesting as beings who experience and inflict hatred.

And I could make the same argument about Infinity itself:

God in a low state of Consciousness experiences itself as a finite, limited being.

How do you explain that God is Absolutely Infinite and simultaneously finite?

If God is Infinite, why does finitude exist at all?

If God is Unlimited, why does God experience limitations?

Does that mean God isn't actually Infinite?

My point is that the existence of relative ignorance doesn't necessarily contradict Absolute Omniscience, just as the existence of relative hatred doesn't necessarily contradict Absolute Love, or the existence of finitude doesn't contradict Absolute Infinity.

In all three cases, God would be manifesting something at the relative level that appears to contradict its absolute nature.

So why do we accept that God can be Absolute Love while manifesting hatred, and Absolute Infinity while manifesting finitude, but reject the possibility that God can be Absolutely Omniscient while manifesting ignorance?

What makes knowledge fundamentally different from love or infinity in this regard?


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, Xonas Pitfall said:

What makes knowledge fundamentally different from love or infinity in this regard?

Totally different.

Love is Infinite and knowledge is finite.

Knowledge requires a finite point of view.

For you to know what a cheese wheel is, requires a finite relative perspective.

So to speak, there is no cheese wheel for God.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

It would make a lot more sense if you stopped treating God as something other to yourself.

 

Honestly, I don’t think this is where the issue lies. What I find confusing is that you seem to alternate between two different definitions of God. At times, you speak of God as a universal consciousness or being that transcends the limited human sense of self.Yet, at other times, as seems to be the case in this thread, you revert to a much more literal definition, equating God with “me” ..meaning the individual person I experience myself to be, right here and now.

These are two quite different propositions, and I don’t think we can move between them interchangeably. So I think we first need to establish exactly what you mean by God and remain consistent with that definition. Otherwise, we’re likely to end up talking past each other.

 


“God is the Alpha Omega .. the beginning-less  beginning and the endless end . 
He is the first without start . He is the last without end . He is the manifest actuality ..nothing covers him . He is the most hidden essence  ..nothing can grasp him .. nothing below him or more subtle than him .The ego is the belief I’m separate from god . Because being god is too good to be true .No matter how dark it gets or difficult it gets ..no matter how long it is going to take .. my destiny is the infinite happiness and infinite joy and love as the best thing ever ..God .  “

-that’s a me .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, Someone here said:

What I find confusing is that you seem to alternate between two different definitions of God. At times, you speak of God as a universal consciousness or being that transcends the limited human sense of self.Yet, at other times, as seems to be the case in this thread, you revert to a much more literal definition, equating God with “me” ..meaning the individual person I experience myself to be, right here and now.

Yes. good. That's right. Because God is a tricky thing to explain.

We are creating a flat map of a round Earth, so it looks crooked.

God is ineffable. Never forget that.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

Nothing at all can be known, ultimately.

Oh ! First time I hear you say such statement.
you always say there is such a thing as absolute truth and is totally knowable and accessible . Just requires the right state of consciousness.

Edited by Someone here

“God is the Alpha Omega .. the beginning-less  beginning and the endless end . 
He is the first without start . He is the last without end . He is the manifest actuality ..nothing covers him . He is the most hidden essence  ..nothing can grasp him .. nothing below him or more subtle than him .The ego is the belief I’m separate from god . Because being god is too good to be true .No matter how dark it gets or difficult it gets ..no matter how long it is going to take .. my destiny is the infinite happiness and infinite joy and love as the best thing ever ..God .  “

-that’s a me .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

Totally different.

Love is Infinite and knowledge is finite.

How so?

I'm wondering if there's some definitional gap here that I'm still missing, given the examples I've mentioned above.

To me, omniscience usually implies something highly conscious, integrative, infinitely intelligent, and all-encompassing. These qualities seem much closer to what God fundamentally is.

Even if we want to get technical about definitions, the term "knowing" seems to point toward God's nature much more accurately than "not-knowing."

For example, consider what these terms usually imply:

| Knowing                                | Not-knowing                               |
|----------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------|
| Awareness                              | Lack of awareness                         |
| Understanding                          | Lack of understanding                     |
| Insight and recognition                | Ignorance or uncertainty                  |
| Connecting and integrating information | Inability to grasp or recognize something |
| Comprehension                          | Absence of knowledge                      |

Of course, these are ordinary meanings, but that's precisely where my confusion comes from.

For example, we use the term LOVE to describe God because love, to me, implies unity, integration, acceptance, and the absence of separation or bias. Love recognizes the underlying connection between all things.

Similarly, we describe God as Infinite Intelligence, rather than Infinite Stupidity, because intelligence implies the ability to understand, generate, connect, and integrate. The greater the intelligence, the greater its capacity to recognize how everything fits together.

And if God is literally the ultimate creator, connector, integrator, and the unity of all possible perspectives, wouldn't "knowing" be a much more appropriate term than "not-knowing"?

Absolute Knowing seems much closer to God's nature than Absolute Not-Knowing.

Again, I might simply be misunderstanding what the term is pointing toward. I'm just trying to figure out why "not-knowing" would be a more accurate description of God's fundamental nature than "knowing," especially when we already describe God as Infinite Intelligence, Absolute Love, and Consciousness itself.

-

The only way I can really see the term "not-knowing" is if it's being used in a more mystical sense, meaning there is no conceptual knowledge, no distinctions, and no finite forms of knowing, because all of that belongs to relative reality.

In that sense, I can understand why "not-knowing" might be considered more accurate.

But still, if we simultaneously describe God as Infinite Intelligence, choosing the term "not-knowing" feels somewhat contradictory, at least definition-wise.

It's similar to how we call God Absolute Love rather than Absolute Hate, even though relative hatred exists, or Absolute Infinity rather than finitude, even though finite experiences exist.

We choose these terms because they seem to better represent God's ultimate nature.

Edited by Xonas Pitfall

🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

You are God and you don't even know what you are yet.

God's Omniscience depends on what state of Consciousness it is in.

God in a low state of Consciousness thinks the Earth is flat.

You think those contradictions are bad? How do you explain that God is Omniscient and God is a Flat Earther?

If God is Omniscient, why does Flat Earth and MAGA exist?

I shouldn't be explaining to you, you should be explaining to me how this is possible.

I think I see what you’re pointing to . It makes a bit more sense now 


“God is the Alpha Omega .. the beginning-less  beginning and the endless end . 
He is the first without start . He is the last without end . He is the manifest actuality ..nothing covers him . He is the most hidden essence  ..nothing can grasp him .. nothing below him or more subtle than him .The ego is the belief I’m separate from god . Because being god is too good to be true .No matter how dark it gets or difficult it gets ..no matter how long it is going to take .. my destiny is the infinite happiness and infinite joy and love as the best thing ever ..God .  “

-that’s a me .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, Someone here said:

Oh ! First time I hear you say such statements. 
you always say there is such a thing as absolute truth and is totally knowable and accessible . Just requires the right state of consciousness.

Yes, there is absolute Truth. Truth is not knowledge or knowing.

Yes, it requires the right state of consciousness.

Do you understand what Ralston called his book The Book Of Not-Knowing? Because knowledge is impossible. This is an extremely advanced understanding.

God is not knowing, God is Being. Omniscience is a very advanced kind of Being.

Unity means that knowing and not-knowing blend together.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Leo Gura said:

No.

Not-knowing is far deeper than that.

Literally, Reality is so relativistically advanced everything is unknowable.

The more conscious you become of God, the deeper the not-knowing will become until you realize that everything you know is nonsense. Nothing at all can be known, ultimately.

No.

Hatred and separation are far deeper than that.

Literally, Reality is so relativistically fragmented, filled with conflicting perspectives, suffering, hatred, and exclusion, that unconditional love becomes impossible.

The more conscious you become of all these relative perspectives, the deeper the separation becomes, until you realize that everything rejects or conflicts with something else.

Nothing can be loved unconditionally, ultimately. Absolute Love isn't real.

Something, something...


🃜 🃚 🃖 ಄ 🃁 🂭 🂺

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Xonas Pitfall Love is Infinity. Where is your knowledge in Infinity? Nowhere.

You are not as clever as you think.

If we collapse everything down to Infinity, Love remains. Knowledge does not.

Edited by Leo Gura

You are God. You are Truth. You are Love. You are Infinity.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now