Jirh

Member
  • Content count

    1,295
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Jirh

  1. The argument is structured as: "Premise A is true, therefore conclusion B follows." But in using the word "therefore," they are demanding that you accept a necessary, non-arbitrary link between their premises and their conclusion. If causation isn't real, "therefore" becomes a meaningless word. By trying to prove that causation is fake, they are relying on the reality of causation to make their case. They cannot escape the grammar of causality, because grammar is causality encoded in language. Also, logic itself is a practical application of causation. Causation is in the DNA of logic.
  2. Yes, that's the illusion caused by relative stability, aka the dream state.
  3. I don't view it as teaching. More like sharing what I know and learning more in the process. I prefer to call it exploring. Well, that's way too much to explore 😅 physicality, reality, real, illuminating. Each is its own journey.
  4. But this requires an infinitely complex and regressive system to occur. We take the infinite complexity for granted and reduce causality down to a few number of comprehensible reasons that we probably can control, for simplicity. The dog has to have an intact neural system, and gravity should work with its current settings, just to name two variables in order for the dog to feel the pain and yelp. If you do the same experiment on the moon, it will not work.
  5. Cool. What is the nature of thoughts, though? You don't have to answer of course. I'm just enjoying the inquiry.
  6. Maybe not placeholders, but more like hijackers of the stages. The stage is the underlying human capacity. The need for order, meaning, morality, transcendence, etc... Religion is a parasitic interpretation of that capacity. It doesn't generate stage Blue. Just like self-help doesn't generate stage Orange.
  7. Yes, absolutely. Spirituality is necessary and encoded in our brains. No arguments there. But my point still stands that religion is a placeholder for the laws, not the source. Then, self-help and religion are both placeholders of personal laws. Not chronically related, but different, almost opposite placeholders.
  8. I would ask Hume, though, what about the causation of causation? Did infinite complexity actually cause us to create the concept of causation? If so, then we have a clear and direct causation relationship between infinite complexity and the illusory concept of causation. It's fun contemplating this stuff, especially the mind-wrecking aspect
  9. The governing laws of a society don't have to be religious or spiritual. It just so happens that they mostly are in stage Blue societies. In this case, religion is a placeholder for the laws, not the source.
  10. Dude, why are you insisting on this idea? It's as if you're getting something from it. The differences between religion and self-help are enormous, both in content and structure, they are practically opposites. The differences make any similarities negligible. Self-help does not even attempt to answer the big questions. It completely bypasses them and focuses on material gains. I would love to see an example of religion's philosophy on improving life. All I know of religion's philosophy is that it says you shall pass through this life as a guest or a visitor and only take what's necessary for the trip from life to death, nothing more. Martyrdom is another interesting concept that contradicts self-help. It's a complete annihilation of the self, and it's completely religious, completely the opposite of self-help.
  11. Why assume that consciousness requires change/time to amount to an experience? You can have consciousness of a static object that's not changing over time. It's not rocket science.
  12. Lol. People be obsessing, trying looksmaxxing. My GF gives me fashion advice because she thinks I'm outdated How I got her with my outdated looks? You'll never know Your girl should take care of your looks, you shouldn't. You just follow the rules she gives.
  13. Actually, no. That's just ego attraction, based on comparison. Raw attraction is a seperate thing. It's a reflex. Something you cannot fake or make your way out of. My opinion depends on which one you're interested in.
  14. @Natasha Tori Maru I think you're nailing it. Good for you! I don't think you can top magic. It's just the best state to be. I do the same mostly. Sometimes, more intellectually, and other times more intuitively, depending on context. And generally, I try to balance my thinking with my feelings and vice-versa. You seem well-balanced.
  15. Sounds like a word salad that doesn't make any sense. And actually my experience suggests the opposite. But thanks for sharing your thoughts.
  16. Are you saying awareness is not aware? If it's not aware, then it's unaware. And awareness cannot be unaware. That would be a contradiction.
  17. That's a juicy one, for sure! Here are my thoughts after years of deep contemplation: Causality is an illusion; a perfectly solid and convincing one. But still ultimately an illusion. An illusion is something that seems there while it isn't actually there. Same goes for free will. We feel we are conscious agents doing stuff freely, but when we examine it deeply, we don't choose our motivations or capabilities or circumstances or anything, even our breath, so where's the freedom and agency? Determinism, on the other hand, is the truth that we refuse to accept, no matter how we try not to. We always seek change through causation. We aren't aware of our lack of free will. We feel capable of making a difference. But what difference are we making if the script is already written? From the moment we decided that we want to create change, to the moment our endeavour is over.
  18. Why would consciousness/awareness require time? I think that it's self-sufficient on its own. And that it is actually what creates the sense of time or the structure that you mentioned. There is awareness of something, simple as that. No need for time or anything else. There's also an awareness of time.
  19. So, it's aware of thoughts. I would say that it's not limited to just thoughts, but it's a good place to start. What are thoughts?
  20. I haven't felt like this in a very long time. I'm feeling peaceful and in-sync with reality. I feel complete. Perfect. When I first awakened, it was peaceful but chaotic. Then it was peaceful through different states, including sad, hurt, excited, tired, bored, etc... Things can change. But peace remains. I have it. I am it.
  21. @Basman I see your point and respectfully disagree. From my pov, religion is not about improving life, it's not even about life itself. It's about abandoning life for the afterlife (Abrahamic), or some samadhi state (Eastern), or something else. All the practices are motivated by a desire to "win" something immaterial, typically spiritual but it could be egoic too. It's the opposite of self-help because self-help is mostly a material endeavor for material gains, although spirituality slipped into self-help as means to improve mental health. But the same material motivation sits underneath. Better mental health, for a better life not a better afterlife. They are not just different styles (stick vs. carrot) like you outlined. They are polar opposites. Like you can't possibly do both at the same time. You can't combine them. Not because they're time-incompatible, but because they're actually antithetical to each other.
  22. How does the concept of God relate to self-help? I am finding it a bit difficult to make the connection. If anything, it seems like the opposite. Why pray when you could just set a morning routine? Why seek forgiveness when you could just reframe your trauma? Many religious ideas don't seem to correlate with anything in modern self-help. Examples: pilgrimage, resurrection day, charity, collective practices, seeking forgiveness, etc... God/Religion is the benchmark that proves you will never be good enough on your own.
  23. There it is; no-self, or emptiness. Though, what is awareness aware of?