Jirh

Member
  • Content count

    1,295
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Jirh

  1. Nah, it's precognition. But you don't like it because it's not yours
  2. You asked: Why is "that doesn't happen usually" relevant? It's relevant because it's not what most people who claim paranormal give. They don't usually give a point by point resembling story. It's often a loosely resembling one with multiple patches to make it sound more like it. And even those are rare enough to dismiss. The even more rarer examples that are more resembling are enough to consider a coincidence, nothing more. That's how I would think if there was no alternative way of thinking like rationality. That's why it's pre-rational. Okay, let's say there's psychic phenomenon. The thing is: we cannot control it or reproduce it. And more importantly, we cannot even tell whether it is occurring or not when it's occuring. We don't know when a dream or a thought is a psychic telling and when they aren't. And no amount of intuition or personal feelings or desperation for an answer can fix this problem. I'm flattered 😂 The relevance is in the example I gave right afterwards. Without the technology that made it possible for you know about a tornado happening miles away from you, you couldn't possibly have made that leap of faith that it was a precognitive dream. You based a big part of your reasoning on the knowledge that your dream actually happened in reality. But you could have easily missed that particular news. 500 years ago, you wouldn't even have the slightest idea that it happened at all. Unless you're suggesting that every thought we have and every dream we experience resemble some actual life event, which is totally nuts, and I don't think you are. I can reproduce the reasoning to anyone, and they will most likely agree with me, even you will likely agree. That's rationality. Nothing is impossibly unlikely according to the law of truly large numbers. It's not likely, but it can happen. We call that a coincidence. It's pre-rational because it existed before rationality because rationality was not established yet. People had to cling to myths and magical thinking to explain life. That's not enlightenment. That's just lack of proper mental capacity.
  3. Most AI chatbots that I've interacted with so far are more intelligent than most humans. They understand what I say more precisely than anyone I know like 95% of the time, even when I am being brief and vague.
  4. You're smart enough to know why. That's the core of your faulty reasoning.
  5. I'll give you the same answer you gave me: Where do you draw the line? When is something enough for you to consider paranormal/precognition? Example: I am using the English language to communicate with you. Jesus Christ! That must indicate something paranormal for you if you know how to connect the dots. But you're probably too blind and closed-minded to see. This is common and typical in schizophrenics. They make strange delusional connections and call them truth. Don't you see how it's your mind largely making things up and slicing the cake in the way that fits its delusions? And you would have no idea that it happened miles away from you without technology. You forgot the elephant in the room. Imagine experiencing the same dream 500 years ago. If you're rational, you'd just think it's a nightmare. Or if you're superstitious, you'd keep waiting for it to happen and possibly alarm everyone around you. The video didn't work. I cannot discuss this. From a practical perspective, I would think it's a useless thing, unless you find some way to reproduce it or some utility to it when it occurs. From a truth perspective, I would think it's a coincidence. An extremely unlikely one, but again that's just the law of truly large numbers. I cannot believe I have to answer these questions for someone as smart as you. And that's not a compliment. Open-mindedness does not mean abandoning common sense. I'd say that's trying a bit too hard to paint this as some sort of post-rational thinking, when in fact it's pre-rational at the core. Again, you're just lacking common sense.
  6. @Carl-Richard True, there's no clear differential point. But it's also true that paranormal reasoning is way below the curve. You're making a false equivalency between two completely different experiences. The difference is as clear as day. You don't need much more beyond common sense to see it.
  7. Well, my intuition tells me your map leads to desert In all seriousness, I think following intuition is a continuous process of first-hand verification. So yeah, I agree with you 🤝🏻
  8. True. It's a finger pointing to the moon. How would I know which map is trustworthy and leads to water anyway? I have to verify for myself.
  9. That's not what happens usually. Usually, it's a rare coincidental experience of loosely resembling story that connects vaguely with multiple patches and leaps of faith to an event. You can't compare normal perception to tales of paranormal. The consistency in perception is nowhere near the inconsistency in those tales. False. Cause and effect as the terms we know are not relative as you're suggesting. A cause is an event that happens first and ends, then another event happens, which is called an effect. For example, you feel thirsty, so you drink a glass of water (cause), then you feel quenched (effect).
  10. @Carl-Richard I've read even more interesting anecdotes back in the day in the book "Twin Telepathy: The Psychic Connection" by Guy Lyon Playfair. He tried to come up with all sorts of hypotheses. One that I remember specifically was biochemical, mainly related to adrenaline and acetylcholine. He said that perhaps we are all connected somehow in our autonomous nervous system, but that connection is maximal and most observable in identical twins. If one twin is in danger, the other will be alarmed. And then he went on and told some interesting stories. I kept his stories and ideas with me, carried them wherever I went. Tried to collect my evidence. But nothing seemed to work the way I expected. Some synchronicities happened, but I couldn't draw any truly meaningful connections. It's all coincidental, I concluded. Anyway, I think I've already given my answers to most of your points. You haven't really moved the post far from where it was. What you said still doesn't escape the law of truly large numbers, base rate neglect, and selection bias.
  11. @Inliytened1 Atoms is a map, a metaphor, a useful fiction at the relative level of human perception. Reality is not made of anything. It's infinite groundlessness.
  12. Ownership is an assumption. Thoughts don't have to be anyone's to be experienced. But that doesn't help your case of non-local awareness.
  13. Exactly 💯 I don't take electrons literally. I think they're a great scientific metaphor.
  14. Maybe. But it's not like you're a neurosurgeon. Nobody's gonna die in social interactions if you drop the weight and be authentic.
  15. The paranormal is not only possible. It's happening right here in front of you. You are using it right now to interact with minds without time or space limitations.
  16. Psychic abilities are not what you think. The materialist paradigm has a better chance at proving psychic phenomenon than any other paradigm. It's just not what you think, and most people won't like it, especially those spiritually-minded. Telepathy is achieved by communication technologies; the entire infrastructure. Precognition and clairvoyance are achieved through gathering and analysis of tremendous amounts of data, for example weather casts. That's all magic. And if you can't see it, it's your failure.
  17. They're not anything near what I would call "experiences". That's already a huge leap of faith. What they really are is beliefs and misinterpretations that remind me of conspiracy theories. You have to establish the validity of the logic that connects experience A with event B before making hypotheses about the nature of connection. And you have no solid argument for why experience A is related to event B, except for: "what are the odds?! 😅". The answer is simply that the odds are low, but still statistically existent. So you're just like that, huh? Pure and egoless, like an innocent newborn seeing the world with clear eyes, right? I could swear it's almost never about the truth, but about ego. If psychic abilities were normal everyday life, you would likely not have any interest in them. Notice how here I am pointing to the magic of technology, and you never even acknowledged it. You jokingly wrote me off as a nerd. I say you'd likely treat psychic abilities at that point as you treat causality, as an illusion that cannot be proven. It's not about which paradigm is fundamentally true. No paradigm is fundamentally true. It's about what actually works. You still didn't provide any arguments for the connection between experience A and event B. Give an example.
  18. I think responsibility and burden are two different things, though. A master is responsible but is never burdened. We actually need insane amounts of responsibility to achieve mastery. Still, that doesn't make it burdensome. I think burden comes from lack of authenticity.
  19. No goals, no game. Spain prefers control over open spaces. They don't let you breathe, but they don't score a lot either. The most boring recipe for sports. Very mechanical.
  20. That's just called lack of mastery. When you are a master, everything feels effortless. You don't feel a burden.
  21. It's over. Spain won. I only checked the score every 30 minutes. I knew it was gonna be a boring game.
  22. That's putting the cart before the horse. You don't take on what you like doing, you just like doing it. Is anyone forcing me to write out this comment? No. I simply wrote it out because I wanted to. It's that simple. Authenticity.