Karmadhi

Do you plan to release sometimes this year new videos especially more practical topics or epistemic? I miss those gems

To be honest @Nivsch as much as we argue with each other on this forum you are one of the most reasonable and fair minded Israelis I have seen (I have talked with tons online) and therefore firstly I commend you for that and also I do geniouly value your input Do you support this war Israel is doing with Iran? Do you support Israel having nuclear weapons illegally and not declaring it? I want to hear your thoughts

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cn7vje365rno https://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/en/news/backstories/3647/ Read these two one after the other and you will see there is basically not much difference between the two @Leo Gura Since you put Russia as more barbaric than Israel, how do you explain such similar treatment to captured people from the other side ?

It is not about nukes but regime change so Iran will become Israel's new puppet and allow them to take more land in Palestine That is the true reason for this war It happened now because Iran is at its weakest

Why should Israel have nukes ILLEGALLY and Iran cannot? I do not want Iran to have nukes but the idea that Israel is somehow "ok" to have nukes and Iran cannot is pure bias and bullshit Israel are Jewish supremacists and Iranians are Islamic ideologues North Korea has nukes and they have not used them, why would Iran use them? North Korea chants "Death to America" too you know, they hate USA as much as Iran government does not yet they never used nukes It is simply a deterrant not to be invaded by you This is Israel. I like this guy because he is very honest about what Israel truly is instead of lying like most "moderates" in Israel do. This country has nukes and lectures others not to have nukes

North Korea is as crazy as it gets for a regime and they have not used them, they also say death to America yet do not do shit The idea that Iran would nuke Israel out of the blue is not proved by anything Firstly there is no concrete proof they want to build one and even if they have one, it is mostly for them to be assured Israel wont attack them Keep in mind Israel has nukes and has them illegally yet they tell people not to have nukes And the genocidal statements from Israeli politicans (tons have been sent here) are not any less radical than Iranian statements Israel simply wants a regime change so they can make Iran its bitch as they did for the Suni states and they can keep annexing Palestine Israel said the exact shit for Iraq, why believe them now?

So ironic that Israel accusses everyone of using civilians as human shields and having important military infrastructure in dense civilian areas meanwhile they have an important military center in the heart of Tel Aviv Hypocrisy much

Apparently Israel bombed Iranian state tv and killed many workers there A clear war crime and shameless Attacks on media and journalists are a clear violantion of international law and should be condemend as acts of terrorism https://www.bbc.com/news/live/c2kqkd03xn5t

Do they actually have the capacity to do that? I feel like both Israel and Iran have powerful air defense systems and neither can do massive damage to the other. I saw Iran hit some buildings yesterday and they did do a lot of damage but I think that is the best they got. I dont think Iran can wipe off Israel off the Map as they claim even if they want. Same with Israel (not including the very first day where Iran got totally caught off guard) Now I am sure Israel may be able to do more damage to Iran than via versa but for them to be able to bomb 100 fold more I think is not possible. Perhaps a 5-10 fold at the most.

@Leo Gura What are your thoughts on this whole war? Do you think Isarel has legitimate self defense reasons to do this attack or you think it is wrong?

The core issue in my opinion is that when people feel like they have no other choice or option they will resort to radical far rights components of their society. The far right has always gained power at times of crisis, when people were desperate Hamas is nothing more than the extreme far right component of Palestinian society, similar to how the Nazis were the extreme far right compoent of German society Smotrich and Ben Gvir are the extreme far right component of Israeli society The extreme far right is brutal, toxic and not conductive to peace The only way to solve this is to remove the need for the extreme far right to begin with In the case of Palestine it is to establish a Palestinian state with a co-goverment monitored by the Arab states and UN I am pretty sure if Palestinians had no more occupation, siege and abuse they would slowly turn away from their far right elements and embrace more moderate elements. This would in turn eventually reduce and finally eliminate the terrorist attacks in Israel which would lead to the extreme far right in Isarel being replaced by more moderate voices. That cannot be done in my opinion without a palestinian state I am not saying it will be instant, but in the mid to long run things will improve. Otherwise you can indeed destroy Hamas but they will be eventually replaced by another extreme far right group and there will not be peace There were terrorist attacks in Israel before Hamas you know. The PLO used to do such attacks and they were not religious zealots as far as I know, they were more nationalistic group. So to just blame it on radical Islam is not a serious argument. Just because Hamas uses religion as their fuel does not mean another more nationalist extreme far right group will replace them that will not use religion as their fuel but simply past grievences and the constant abuses Israelis do to Palestinians on a daily basis The current Israeli government not only does not think like this, they double down on their illegal settlements alongside other war crimes in Gaza.

Nazi Germany blamed Jews for their country and government collapsing, its economy collapsing and massive unemployment and disorder In their minds that was Jewish fault Such things are far more damaging to a society than a couple hundred dead civilians Russia just lost over 150 civilians in 1 massacre in a concert hall and they did not lash out in any big way They blamed Ukraine for it (irrelevant if true) and basically there was no real revenge on Ukraine for it. I was honestly worried that they would go on killing spree in Ukraine since they openly blamed Ukraine for it, killing thousands of civilians in retaliation yet none of that happened. Difference!

Syria, Egypt and Iraq were not doing it on the name of religion They were typical ruthless secular dictatorships Israel does its evil on the name of religion, their government are religious zelots that want to get land based on what their bible says The worst parts of Israeli politics and society (like the illegal settlers) are religious fundamentalists Which is why I used Iran, ISIS and Al Qaeda as examples, they are also religious fundamentalists Egypt, Sadam and Syria were not Ironically only after their regimes were changed, the religious nutcases started running amok Last case is the new leader in Syria

They should blame ISIS and Al Qaeda yes Iran government too

If I was a jew in the USA I would partially blame Israel for it They are giving Jews around the world a horrible name and reputation Just like Hamas gives all Gazans a bad rep

I am open to sources Point is that Israel should be deradicalized and the hatred and ethno supermacy they have towards Palestinians be removed through international pressure

That makes Israel look worse as many people there see all Gazans as the enemy including kids https://www.timesofisrael.com/far-right-minister-says-israel-should-bomb-humanitarian-aid-starve-gazans/ https://forward.com/opinion/723508/why-israel-extremists-must-be-stopped-netanyahu-trump-smotrich/ https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/08/israel-finance-minister-bezalel-smotrich-gaza-starve-2m-people-comments https://www.ndtv.com/world-news/moshe-feiglin-every-baby-in-gaza-is-an-enemy-ex-israeli-lawmakers-shocking-remarks-8477020 More than 15% of Israelis voted for parties whose elected people said such stuff Shows how huge the hatred is SAD

I think majority think it is stolen land but i dont think the majority wants to actually genocide the Jews That is the conclusion I got after talking to dozens and hearing another dozens speak in genocidal language Many told me that they were pro peace and pro two state before October 7th and now they see all Gazans as the enemy Israel gets beaten into submission by the international community until they learn and change their ways Just like Nazi Germany was Apologise for all the wrong they did, recognize a Palestinian state and learn not to see Arabs Muslims as inferior race and religion. Simple as that The hatred they have towards Muslims is truly shocking, especially considering it was actually Christians those that badly oppressed Jews for 2000 years.

This is how the "internal forces" in Israel treat someone that points out something they do not like https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-05-28/ty-article-magazine/.premium/yes-to-transfer-82-of-jewish-israelis-back-expelling-gazans/00000197-12a4-df22-a9d7-9ef6af930000 Sorry but when the majority actually supports ethnic cleansing, it shows that the entire society is rotten, not just Bibi and his government The core issue here is that the majority of Israeli Jews, think that "EVERY Gazan supports Hamas and wants to wipe out all the Jews in Israel" They always use the same bullshit argument that "there were civilians that took part in October 7th" Yes there were, couple of hundred out of 2.2 million Maybe 5% of Gazans want to genocide the Jews But that is 5%, not "most" as Israelis claim with 0 proof I am very dissapointed at how low Israel has fallen They have basically reached WW2 Nazi Germany level of dehuminization towards Palestinians, their hatred is disturbing It took them 800 civilians to be killed for them to become like this Imagine Palestine that has lost tens of thousands even before October 7th How are they supposed to feel? I wonder how genocidal Israel would become if they actually suffered the same as Palestinians have They endured 1/10 of it and already lost all their shit

Those are radical dumb leftists I am talking about proper leftie Proper lefties want all bad actors that have blood on their hands to face justice and make sure they are held to account They do not like a world where the "civilized liberal loving international law enforcing community" lets a country get away with genocide and ethnic cleansing Additionally, to add salt to the wound, the leftists see them doing everything to make Russia pay and they see them doing nothing to make Israel pay The hypocrisy angers them as well Lastly I have noticed leftiest tend to measure how a bad a party is based on how much human suffering is inflicted on civilian population rather than who started what Technically in Israel, it is true that Hamas attacked first (although provoked), meanwhile Russia attacked Ukraine first But since the human suffering on the civilian population in Gaza is much higher than in Ukraine, they tend to be more angry at Israel, although Israel has some justification on conducting the war. At least more than Russia does.

Those are just wishful thinking and radical leftists. I am talking about true leftists that want a two state.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/may/27/former-israeli-pm-ehud-olmert-says-his-country-is-committing-war-crimes When an ex Israeli PM says this, you know you lost the plot...

They say that is was a terrorist attack, that Hamas are terrorists and that it was wrong. I dont know what more you want them to say. You can have a brutal immoral terrorist attack done by terrorists that has been fundamentally caused by oppression and bad policies of the other party Those two truths can be at the same time That is what leftists say I do not see romantization or glorification of Hamas from leftists which would indeed be shameful.

Leftists describe things as they should be, not as they function You say here how power works, leftists yell about how justice works It is not that they are naive about how things work, they just want things to be better You are pragmatic and grounded in brutal reality, they are idealistic and grounded in the fight for a better world That is the core difference

Perhaps but leftists are still more honest about the causes of the war than most pro Israelis that seem to think this all started on October 7th, ignoring decades of abuse and oppression which fundamentally caused it. Leftists dont condone Hamas actions, but they call them the sad consequences of oppression and bad policy by Israel. Compare this with pro Israelis that just say "unproved attack out of the blue" That is a fair point, but still they seem to me closer to truth than pro Israelis, although not 100% perfect As far as I know leftists support the two state solution which is I think the most reasonable solution to this problem They do not say "lets destroy Israel" or anything like that And many reputable scholars and international organizations have said that there is genocide or genocidal intend at Gaza so screaming genocide is not some unreasonable totally detached from reality claim that they say. I do agree sometimes they way of communication and loud noise can be seen as annoying but the substance is what matters not the communication style