Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Joshe

ICE's $495 million Appleton prison purchase

1 post in this topic

Yall heard of this story where ICE purchased a dilapidated prison in Minnesota for $495 million when the same prison was offered to the state for $75 million just a year earlier? 

It's a $420 million dollar gap. "420" makes me think of Elon. Surely just a coincidence, lol. 

CoreCivic, the owner of the prison donated $500,000 to Trump's 2024 run. They've sold ICE billions worth of prisons since Trump's takeover. And Trump owns stock in the company. lol 

Congress is now demanding answers. 

Here's the article: 

https://www.kare11.com/article/news/investigations/congress-demands-answers-to-ices-495-million-appleton-prison-purchase-mn/89-a2af91a8-2002-4fbe-9b31-5e295130c779

Or read it below:

---

APPLETON, Minn. — Congress is now demanding answers from Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin about the federal government's $495.6 million purchase of a shuttered Minnesota prison in Appleton, citing a KARE 11 investigation that revealed the same facility had been offered to the state for $75 million a year earlier.

A letter, led by Congresswoman Betty McCollum and Bennie G. Thompson, Ranking Member of the House Committee on Homeland Security, raises concerns about what the lawmakers call an overpayment of taxpayer dollars, the terms of the federal government's agreement with CoreCivic, and the safety of people detained at the facility.

"This is just one more example of the Trump administration wasting taxpayer dollars on dubious projects," said Congresswoman McCollum.

“DHS should not be wasting taxpayer funds to purchase – and grossly overpay for – private prisons to boost those corporations’ bottom line and expand the Trump administration’s grossly inhumane mass deportations," Ranking Member Thompson said. "DHS must answer for its actions.”

"We are deeply concerned"

The members of Congress cite KARE 11's investigation, which uncovered a May 2025 email showing CoreCivic offered to sell the Prairie Correctional Facility to Minnesota for $75 million, including upgrades needed to reactivate it. The federal government ultimately paid nearly $495.6 million for the same facility.

"We are deeply concerned by this overpayment and the apparent misuse of taxpayer dollars," the letter reads.

It also raises concerns about the facility's medical infrastructure, staffing, emergency care, suicide prevention measures and whether it will detain both men and women.

Members of Congress are now requesting documents detailing the purchase agreement, the prison's valuation and appraisal, and when the Department of Homeland Security learned CoreCivic had offered the facility to Minnesota for a fraction of the federal purchase price.

They are also questioning why the federal government is paying CoreCivic more than $536 million over five years to operate a facility it now owns, and whether the government considered operating the prison itself.

Congresswoman McCollum and Ranking Member Thompson were joined by Sen. Tina Smith, Rep. Ilhan Omar, Rep. Angie Craig, Rep. Kelly Morrison, Rep. Sara Jacobs, Rep. Rashida Tlaib, Rep. Veronica Escobar, Rep. Stephen Lynch, Rep. Madeleine Dean, Rep. Eleanor Holmes Norton, and Rep. Mike Quigley in demanding answers on the prison overpayment.

The letter requests written responses from Mullin by December 3.

This follows an investigation by the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, and a request that DHS and CoreCivic preserve all records dating back to January 1, 2025, and on an ongoing basis.

A $420 million gap

Minnesota declined CoreCivic's $75 million offer in 2025, citing concerns about staffing and the services needed to operate a prison in a remote community roughly three hours from the Twin Cities. KARE 11 investigates uncovered the federal government's purchase price was more than six times what CoreCivic had offered Minnesota for the same prison—a $420 million gap.

In a recent interview, Minnesota Corrections Commissioner Paul Schnell told KARE 11 he was stunned by the federal purchase price, saying he still couldn't understand how the government could justify spending nearly half a billion dollars.

“Did Minnesota miss out on the real estate deal of the century, or are taxpayers potentially getting taken for a ride here?” KARE 11’s A.J. Lagoe asked.

“Well, I mean, that's the only thing I can believe,” Schnell replied. “That the taxpayers - I don't know how they could justify this amount.”

Financial windfall

CoreCivic has become a major financial winner during President Trump's immigration crackdown.

The company's then-CEO Damon Hininger told investors shortly after Trump returned to the White House that he anticipated significant growth opportunities, potentially the most significant in the company's history.

Hininger said the administration's immigration policies were creating enormous business opportunities by increasing demand for detention beds.

CoreCivic also donated $500,000 to the Trump-Vance inaugural committee. Hininger also made significant personal contributions to Trump-affiliated political committees.

When KARE 11 requested an interview, a company spokesperson declined an on-camera interview.

In a written statement, CoreCivic said independent appraisers used a cost-based methodology and that the federal government ultimately determined the sale price following its assessment process.

Multibillion-dollar prison buying spree

The Appleton prison was one of several facilities CoreCivic sold to the federal government this year.

The company also sold a facility in Kansas for $238 million and two prisons in California for a combined $1.5 billion.

The total price tag for the four facilities exceeded $2.2 billion.

Federal auditors raise concerns

The purchase comes amid broader questions about ICE's detention facility expansion.

The nonpartisan Government Accountability Office recently warned ICE's detention facility purchases have the potential to result in waste, finding the agency had not assessed the long-term affordability of owning the facilities.

The GAO's September report called for urgent planning to avoid further waste of taxpayer dollars.

ICE also spent $1.07 billion purchasing 11 warehouses it planned to convert into detention centers. The agency later reversed course and planned to sell seven of them.

By then, the GAO found ICE had spent more than $20 million on unrecoverable costs, including utilities, security and other services.

Federal response

In October, a handful of officials with the Trump administration traveled to MN to discuss fraud; however, when asked by KARE 11's Lou Raguse about the prison purchase, U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent claimed answering the question "was a waste of our time."

"I don't know anything about that," Bessent responded when asked about the sale. "What we're here to do is to prosecute criminal fraud and any question like that, that deflects away from it, I think, is a waste of our time."

While not addressing KARE 11's request for an on-camera interview or the questions submitted in writing, DHS provided the following statement on 11/02/26, attributed to an unnamed spokesperson:

“DHS acquired the Prairie Correctional Facility to strengthen America’s ability to enforce its immigration laws and carry out the American people’s mandate for mass deportations.

The 1,600-bed site gives ICE immediate capacity to detain and remove those who have no legal right to remain, protecting American communities and restoring the integrity of our borders without waiting years for new construction.

The purchase price was set through the standard federal appraisal process. Independent appraisers applied a replacement-cost method, current cost of equivalent secure space, adjusted for depreciation, land, and condition, including the security and fire upgrades required for ICE operations.

The $75 million figure was a preliminary, non-binding indication offered during earlier discussions with the Minnesota Department of Corrections. Those talks never advanced to formal appraisal or agreed scope. The number was not based on replacement-cost analysis and did not reflect the intervening rise in construction costs or federal operational standards. Minnesota’s own estimate to replace Stillwater was roughly $1.3 billion.”

DHS Secretary Mullin has not directly responded to our questions.

Edited by Joshe

-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0