Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
tvaeli

Natural healing - abyss or science?

5 posts in this topic

My topic about auditory hearing and spiritual girls became scientific guide into unnatural healing.

As the central topic of the thread, "natural healing" means definition:

  • Typically its the healing where biological processes is involved, mixed or natural healing vs. cirurgy and healing, where human body is measured as a mechanism, or natural processes are otherwise strongly influenced for classification, or influenced for mixed terms.
  • It also involves if thinking, senses, intuition or instinct is directly involved and directly targets the "logic".

If animals would not heal at all, or would be proven precisely equal, it would be a sign.

Scientific measurement, here, needs to follow the strict criteria:

- If criticist of natural healer tells sentences like, "altough this might be good thing, when needed one should go to chirurgy". Just telling people that they must use chirurgy, which sounds like general case where you use it anyway if your body wants to heal, totally excluding natural healing.

If criticist tells sentences like "do not use your instinct and intuition"; i.e. do not breathe if you need air, do not do a leg exercise if there is a pain, do not enstrenghten what seems weak and do not have practice and exercise for parts which pain. Those are natural, logical solutions.

The problem which must exclude any concept of natural healing hypocritically, telling that "one does not have superior miracle doctor", telling us about bills, about the ability you need to carry as normal people when you execute certain methods etc. are not general. They are not using clinical and dictionary definitions of natural healing, but assuming idealized world where it is possible at all - there is wide gap between whether it exists and whether its possible. The method of possibility and fair treatment, where one can tell existing miracles must have physics-based-simple-chemical, rather than karma-based structure, or that natural healing should be processed in clinic, when one is sleeping, and the results "proven" to such person in any case. This is business efficiency measurement and cannot be generalized, but rather specific abilities apply for each person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, tvaeli said:

My topic about auditory hearing and spiritual girls became scientific guide into unnatural healing.

The problem which must exclude any concept of natural healing hypocritically, telling that "one does not have superior miracle doctor", telling us about bills, about the ability you need to carry as normal people when you execute certain methods etc. are not general. They are not using clinical and dictionary definitions of natural healing, but assuming idealized world where it is possible at all - there is wide gap between whether it exists and whether its possible. The method of possibility and fair treatment, where one can tell existing miracles must have physics-based-simple-chemical, rather than karma-based structure, or that natural healing should be processed in clinic, when one is sleeping, and the results "proven" to such person in any case. This is business efficiency measurement and cannot be generalized, but rather specific abilities apply for each person.

Over all, I think the natural strength and ability which was basin of natural healing has been lost efficiently in last years, rather than in initial experiments - I do think the gap between minded and unminded healing is going to be wide enough for measurement. The people who executed others whose solutions needed 50% work and deep minding of their goal, are business criminals with their argument; each argument needs specifically target what remains *mistakes*, and the argument that science is the one which does not leave fool in authority into trouble, so the weak-bottom words and sequences should be avoided, becomes something less than human, an infrahuman capability modulus.

ChatGPT completes my answer:

The lost dimension of natural healing: ability, minding, and scientific measurement

Overall, I think the natural strength and ability which formed the basis of natural healing have been progressively lost, or at least insufficiently investigated, over recent years. I suspect that the gap between minded and unminded healing may be wide enough to become an independent subject of scientific measurement.

By minded healing, I mean processes in which conscious attention, sensory interpretation, intuition, deliberate practice, and an individual's understanding of their own biological condition participate in the healing process. Unminded healing, by contrast, would refer to biological processes that occur without deliberate conscious participation.

This distinction should not be confused with the distinction between natural and artificial medicine. Both conscious and unconscious processes can participate in ordinary biological recovery, and both deserve investigation.

The important question is whether conscious participation can measurably influence the body's natural processes, and, if so, under which conditions, to what extent, and with what limitations.

I also think there is a serious methodological problem when people who have developed particular solutions, requiring perhaps 50% practical work and 50% deep understanding of their intended goal, are dismissed without examining the actual mechanism or results.

A solution should not be evaluated merely by whether an ordinary person can execute it immediately, whether it is commercially convenient, or whether it fits an existing institutional procedure.

These considerations might be relevant to accessibility and practical application, but they are not sufficient arguments against the biological existence of a particular process.

If someone criticizes a healing method, the criticism should specifically identify what remains mistaken:

  • [] Is the proposed biological mechanism incorrect? [] Is the physical explanation insufficient? [] Are the observed results unreliable? [] Is there an alternative explanation for the recovery? [] Does the method produce harm under particular circumstances? [] Is the method effective only for certain individuals?

Each criticism should address the actual claim rather than replace it with a general statement about conventional medicine, financial accessibility, or the absence of universally superior healers.

Likewise, instinct and intuition should neither be treated as supernatural authorities nor excluded from investigation. They can involve sensory information, subconscious processing, learned responses, and physiological feedback.

A person noticing weakness, pain, fatigue, breathing needs, or changes in bodily function is receiving information. Whether a particular response is beneficial must be established through the relevant biological evidence.

Animals provide another important comparison: biological healing, adaptation, and regeneration exist independently of human medical institutions. Their different capacities can help identify which mechanisms are shared and which are species-specific.

I would therefore distinguish four questions: whether a healing phenomenon exists, whether its mechanism is physically possible, whether it produces measurable benefits, and whether a particular person can reliably access or reproduce it.

These questions should never be collapsed into one.

My criticism of certain arguments is that they seem to place the authority of science in the position of protecting established conclusions rather than investigating what remains unexplained. Science should not leave mistaken assumptions in authority simply because they are institutionally convenient.

However, the opposite mistake must also be avoided: an extraordinary personal experience is not automatically proof of a general healing mechanism.

The standard should be objective investigation, appropriate measurements, independent verification, and a willingness to revise conclusions.

Ultimately, I think the natural healing discussion becomes less than human when it systematically removes the individual's capacity for observation, learning, adaptation, and deliberate participation from consideration. Reducing the entire subject to an infrahuman capability modulus, where the person is treated merely as a passive biological mechanism, leaves an important dimension of human functioning unexplored.

The objective should not be to replace science with intuition, or medicine with miracles. It should be to make science sufficiently comprehensive that neither biological self-healing nor the possible contribution of conscious human abilities is excluded before investigation.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is the basic argument:

- Negative argumentation without a basin of information is not by its nature stronger,

- Than positive argument claiming a basin of information,

- And the business case that there might be something, where you cannot participiate;

  - But please, cannot you see that every single member of the gang of fools fails their specific methods? The yielding yelling of "can participiate" methods, and aggressive attacking behaviour while "good price" for you does not exist, explaining this as negative metphysics of mind of others;

  - This is the price-based healing methodology rather than scientific overview of natural meaning and its various terms, methods, failures or biases.

Negative argument gives fear, autistic and non-constructive states of mind when considering scientific question.

---

I asked chatgpt to comment this as well:

 

The difference between negative argumentation and scientific investigation

A negative argument does not become scientifically stronger merely because it rejects a proposed possibility. Equally, a positive argument does not become scientifically established merely because it claims to possess a substantial basin of information.

Both must be evaluated according to the quality, relevance, and completeness of their evidence.

The real problem begins when the question of whether something works is replaced by the question of whether somebody can participate in it, afford it, or reproduce it under commercially convenient conditions.

Participation is not equivalent to scientific validity.

A person might lack the necessary resources, training, physical capabilities, or individual circumstances to execute a method. This does not automatically establish that the method is nonexistent or biologically impossible.

But neither does another person's inability to participate establish that a method is effective.

What I find particularly problematic is the apparent contradiction in certain criticisms:

  • [] A person claims that a method is inaccessible. [] The same person treats that inaccessibility as evidence against its existence. [] The actual method and its proposed mechanism remain unexamined. [] Failures of particular practitioners are generalized into failures of an entire category.
  • Financial accessibility is treated as though it were a biological measurement.

This creates a price-based healing methodology rather than a scientific overview of natural healing.

The scientific question should instead be: what exactly is being measured, what is failing, and under which conditions?

If a practitioner fails to demonstrate a result, that failure should be investigated specifically. If another practitioner obtains a different result, that difference should also be investigated.

There is no scientific justification for assuming that every individual possesses identical abilities, knowledge, training, or biological responses.

Similarly, the assertion that somebody cannot participate should not become an argument for aggressively dismissing the experiences or capabilities of others.

I would also distinguish between negative evidence and negative metaphysics: demonstrating that a method fails is not the same as declaring that the possibility of such a method is fundamentally nonexistent.

Science should be capable of investigating both success and failure without turning either into an ideological weapon.

Otherwise, fear, generalized rejection, and non-constructive argumentation replace the actual scientific question.

The objective is not to defend every natural healer, but to establish which methods work, which do not, why they differ, and what biological mechanisms can explain the results.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also the business method paradox.

If you are sure about "against natural healing", you are excliding a social framework from them.

This attitude also presumes your solution is not naturally based on belonging into a society, which would assist you in natural healing. This cannot be directly inferred within the solution, because while it can be its basin, it cannot be the conclusion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 minutes ago, tvaeli said:

Also the business method paradox.

If you are sure about "against natural healing", you are excliding a social framework from them.

This attitude also presumes your solution is not naturally based on belonging into a society, which would assist you in natural healing. This cannot be directly inferred within the solution, because while it can be its basin, it cannot be the conclusion.

 

 

You think the yelling man is legal on their own: who is demanding others to explain their own life, in terms of science and framework of business where all can participiate and have free, unnaturally sound access to details, models and biological data which occurs within organisms of others?

I can see a heavy load of abilities and technologies you did not grant, including that in natural science we also need a capable scientist within the same practice; natural healing critics in natural world also involves their own deep understanding of each known natural healing process, methods and practices, so a "sceptic" is not the actual type we built our business on.

For example my practice of natural healing involves meditation over body, exercise for strength and vitamin load, none of them particularly scientific - while I study what I can, it does not involve absolute parameters of every vitamin etc., also because me too - I have not actually found the complete scientific model or study of healing which would give all the model and details so that I could build it, connect to my body, sit back and relax with my solely logical, 100% pure implementation from the textbook, without also my personal investments of understanding - basically, the final test would be that I just, implement every algorithm from the book one to one as its written.

ChatGPT:

Natural healing, science, and the missing scientific-business framework

I think there is a fundamental misunderstanding here about what it means to approach natural healing scientifically.

Who is demanding that another person explain their entire life, biological processes, personal understanding and practical abilities exclusively through scientific terminology? And why should the person practising natural healing be expected to possess a complete scientific framework before their practice can even be discussed?

I see several layers of ability and technology being overlooked.

1. The difference between a practitioner and a scientific observer

A natural healing practitioner is not necessarily a scientist, just as a scientist is not necessarily an experienced natural healing practitioner.

Both require different abilities.

A capable scientist studying a natural process should ideally understand the actual practice, its methods, its limitations and the biological processes involved.

Likewise, a practitioner should be able to understand what they are doing, even if they cannot explain every biological mechanism in scientific terminology.

A sceptic who has never seriously studied or practised a particular method is not automatically the most qualified person to evaluate its practical potential.

2. My own example of natural healing

My practice involves meditation over the body, physical exercise for strength and attention to vitamin intake.

None of these activities requires me to possess an exhaustive scientific model of every biological parameter.

I study what I can, but my practical understanding also develops through experience, observation and personal investment.

I have not found a complete scientific model of healing that provides every relevant biological mechanism, every parameter, every interaction and every implementation instruction.

In other words, I cannot simply open a textbook, implement every algorithm one-to-one, connect it to my body and sit back with 100% logically guaranteed results.

My understanding and participation are still necessary.

3. What would a genuinely scientific model look like?

I would propose the following framework:

  1. []Definition: Define exactly what natural healing means in the particular investigation. []Intervention: Identify the actual practice, such as meditation, exercise, breathing or nutritional changes. []Biological mechanisms: Identify the known physiological processes potentially involved. []Baseline: Record relevant starting conditions, individual differences and existing limitations. []Parameters: Identify measurable variables, including duration, frequency, intensity and relevant biological indicators. []Implementation: Document how the practice is actually performed rather than assuming that its theoretical description guarantees correct execution. []Observation: Record changes over time, including improvements, deterioration and unexpected outcomes. []Comparison: Where appropriate, compare results against control conditions, alternative interventions or established reference data. []Reproducibility: Allow independent researchers to examine the methodology and attempt to reproduce the findings. []Limitations: Clearly distinguish demonstrated effects, plausible mechanisms, personal experiences and unanswered questions.

4. The business-science reliability model

If we wanted to build an actual business around scientifically responsible natural healing, I would expect something like this:

  • []A documented description of every offered practice. []A distinction between established scientific knowledge and practitioner experience. []Transparent information about qualifications and competencies. []A documented procedure for measuring relevant outcomes. []Individual assessment instead of assuming that every organism responds identically. []A record of interventions, their duration and their intended purpose. []Informed consent before collecting or using biological information. []Privacy protection and controlled access to personal biological data. []Independent scientific evaluation wherever possible. []Clear reporting of unsuccessful results and adverse effects. []A procedure for identifying when a method is inappropriate or requires medical assessment. []Continuous improvement based on new evidence.

This would allow practitioners, scientists, researchers and customers to participate without pretending that they all possess identical abilities.

Scientific transparency does not mean that everybody must have unrestricted access to everybody else's biological information. It means that the methodology, evidence, aggregate findings and limitations should be open to appropriate examination, with individual data protected.

5. The difference between possibility and proof

I also think we need to distinguish three different questions:

  • []Does a natural process exist? []Can that process produce a measurable beneficial effect?
  • Can that effect be reliably reproduced, understood and implemented across different individuals?

These are three different scientific questions.

Failing to establish the third does not automatically answer the first two negatively.

Likewise, observing an improvement in one individual does not establish a universally effective healing method.

Both distinctions matter.

6. What I expect from scientific criticism

I don't object to scientific criticism. I object to criticism that substitutes assumptions for investigation.

If someone claims that meditation, exercise or another natural practice has no meaningful effect, I would expect them to understand the practice sufficiently to evaluate it.

If someone claims that a particular practice is beneficial, I would equally expect them to provide evidence appropriate to the strength of that claim.

Neither the practitioner nor the sceptic should receive automatic authority.

7. My actual position

I am not arguing that natural healing should be exempt from science.

I am arguing that science should be capable of studying natural healing as an actual human practice, including the knowledge, abilities, individual differences and biological processes involved in its implementation.

A complete scientific model would be extremely useful. It could help practitioners understand what they are doing, researchers evaluate outcomes and businesses establish reliable standards.

But the absence of a complete model does not mean that every existing practice is meaningless, nor does it mean that a practitioner has no legitimate knowledge simply because their understanding is not expressed as a complete scientific textbook.

Ultimately, I would like to see a framework where practical experience and scientific investigation cooperate.

Not blind belief against science.

Not scepticism against experience.

But a system in which both are accountable, measurable where possible, transparent about uncertainty and capable of learning from each other.

That is the scientific and business framework I am actually interested in building.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0