Nercohype

Truth vs Duty

83 posts in this topic

10 hours ago, oOo said:

If you turn down another lift because I offered to collect you, a duty that began with my own choice has become something you have good reason to count on.

Here, the cognition is "faith".  Faith is simultaneously beyond the realm of intellect and emotions and at the same time superimposed on them.  Faith is fanning the metaphorical flames ( or splashing the metaphorical cold water** ) on the psyche.  Details are below:

A "good reason to count on" cultivates "trust".  Then, when the trust is fulfilled, the "trusting" is being magnified into "faith".  The difference between trust and faith is:  trust is tethered to specific set of circumstances; faith is open ended, boundless.  Because faith is open and boundless, the magnification of trust into faith is on-going.  That's what produces the pleasure ( or pain** ).  

** ( Whether it's pleasure or pain depends on the set of circumstances which were being trusted.  Is the trust that something helpful is going to happen then it does.  Or, is the trust that something harmful is going to happen, then it does. )

10 hours ago, oOo said:

What I mean by honour is the regard I have for someone’s trust, which can move me to keep their confidence even when a superior orders me to betray it.

I would call this "teamwork".  Opposing forces are brought together such that all are "winning" and none are "losing".  Like bringing fire, water, and a vessel together for the purpose of making tea.  Or like bringing together the stars and the nearly endless darkness of outer-space.  Or like bitter-sweet chocolate.  All the constituents are able to co-exist peacefully in spite of their natural inclination to nullify each other.

10 hours ago, oOo said:

When you remember a promise, before you decide what to do, does the quiet recognition I gave my word carry the whole sense of obligation for you?

For me, speaking only for myself, I consider it like Schrodinger's cat.  From the finite perspective, both events ( obligation fulfilled and obligation lacking fulfillment ) and their corresponding branchings of outcomes, co-exist in the realm of "could-be" events.  Then, when the choice is made to fulfill or abandon the obligation, the corresponding timelines of branching outcomes resolve and assimilate into the realms of "is" , "was", "isn't", "wasn't" depending on the choices which are made.

From the infinite perspective all causes and their corresponding outcomes co-exist on nearly infinite branchings ( or timelines ) superimposed on each other in the form of a cloud or web of possibilites.

The last piece of the puzzle is including myself, my affinities, my aversions.  When I do that, I am always looking forward to commitments fulfilled in selfless acts of devotion for the sake of helping of others.  That's the sort of reality I want to live in.  My mind's eye is always turning towards events which validate these desires.  Because of that, if you give your word, I am expecting it to be fulfilled and imagining how "good" that would be.

10 hours ago, oOo said:

An expansionist might despise the people harmed yet revere the mission, while a dissenter who rejects the mission and describes feeling bound without drawing on respect would give me reason to drop respect as a requirement.

For me, I'm seeing 3 independent motives.  The first motive is whether or not to accept the mission.  The second motive is carrying out the mission.  The third motive is bringing those two motives together such that both can occur simultaneously without nullifying each other.

Accepting the mission is "submitting".
Carrying out the mission of expansion is "charging to victory".
Bringing those two together simultaneously is "teamwork". 

Submission << Teamwork >> Victory

or, metaphorically,

Water << Vessel >> Fire

Edited by Ziran

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ziran, your forgotten promise lets us distinguish what I owe you, whether I feel bound to do it and whether you get home heh.

8 hours ago, Ziran said:

Here, the cognition is "faith".  Faith is simultaneously beyond the realm of intellect and emotions and at the same time superimposed on them.  Faith is fanning the metaphorical flames ( or splashing the metaphorical cold water** ) on the psyche.  Details are below:

A "good reason to count on" cultivates "trust".  Then, when the trust is fulfilled, the "trusting" is being magnified into "faith".  The difference between trust and faith is:  trust is tethered to specific set of circumstances; faith is open ended, boundless.  Because faith is open and boundless, the magnification of trust into faith is on-going.  That's what produces the pleasure ( or pain** ).  

You can be right twice over, both in predicting I’ll leave you waiting and in saying I owe you the lift I promised.

 

Quote

** ( Whether it's pleasure or pain depends on the set of circumstances which were being trusted.  Is the trust that something helpful is going to happen then it does.  Or, is the trust that something harmful is going to happen, then it does. )

I would call this "teamwork".  Opposing forces are brought together such that all are "winning" and none are "losing".  Like bringing fire, water, and a vessel together for the purpose of making tea.  Or like bringing together the stars and the nearly endless darkness of outer-space.  Or like bitter-sweet chocolate.  All the constituents are able to co-exist peacefully in spite of their natural inclination to nullify each other.

My motives could be in harmony whether I keep my friend’s confidence or give my superior the name, yet those choices serve different people, just as your monarch could serve his court while others paid the price.
 

Quote

For me, speaking only for myself, I consider it like Schrodinger's cat.  From the finite perspective, both events ( obligation fulfilled and obligation lacking fulfillment ) and their corresponding branchings of outcomes, co-exist in the realm of "could-be" events.  Then, when the choice is made to fulfill or abandon the obligation, the corresponding timelines of branching outcomes resolve and assimilate into the realms of "is" , "was", "isn't", "wasn't" depending on the choices which are made.

From the infinite perspective all causes and their corresponding outcomes co-exist on nearly infinite branchings ( or timelines ) superimposed on each other in the form of a cloud or web of possibilites.

I might forget I promised and stop out of kindness when I see you waiting or set out precisely because I feel bound and have my car break down halfway.

Quote

The last piece of the puzzle is including myself, my affinities, my aversions.  When I do that, I am always looking forward to commitments fulfilled in selfless acts of devotion for the sake of helping of others.  That's the sort of reality I want to live in.  My mind's eye is always turning towards events which validate these desires.  Because of that, if you give your word, I am expecting it to be fulfilled and imagining how "good" that would be.

I can see the good in getting you home and still wish I’d never offered, so what would help me recognise pleasure in the pull of I gave my word?
 

Quote

For me, I'm seeing 3 independent motives.  The first motive is whether or not to accept the mission.  The second motive is carrying out the mission.  The third motive is bringing those two motives together such that both can occur simultaneously without nullifying each other.

Your Manifest Destiny link led me to Grant, who admired his commander and earned promotion for bravery in a war he condemned, yet later said he lacked the courage to resign.
 

Quote

Accepting the mission is "submitting".
Carrying out the mission of expansion is "charging to victory".
Bringing those two together simultaneously is "teamwork". 

Submission << Teamwork >> Victory

or, metaphorically,

Water << Vessel >> Fire

That brings me back to Nercohype’s seeker. Given the half-truth he was told, I’d judge his decision to leave by the danger he could reasonably have foreseen. On top of, I’d ask what warning those who knew could safely have given him.

Edited by oOo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, oOo said:

I can see the good in getting you home and still wish I’d never offered, so what would help me recognise pleasure in the pull of I gave my word?

universal reciprocity and my gratitude, among others
 

23 hours ago, Ziran said:

For me, I'm seeing 3 independent motives.  The first motive is whether or not to accept the mission.  The second motive is carrying out the mission.  The third motive is bringing those two motives together such that both can occur simultaneously without nullifying each other.

Accepting the mission is "submitting".
Carrying out the mission of expansion is "charging to victory".
Bringing those two together simultaneously is "teamwork". 

 

14 hours ago, oOo said:

Your Manifest Destiny link led me to Grant, who admired his commander and earned promotion for bravery in a war he condemned, yet later said he lacked the courage to resign.

If I understand, in this example, there wasn't any true "submission" nor was their any true "victory".  What appears to be submission is actually denial.  What appears to be charging out to victory is actually shame.   If so, here's how I would describe the motives contributing to the event.

Following orders is "denial" of their objections.
Carrying out the orders is "avoiding" shame and incarceration.
Bringing those two together simultaneously is still "teamwork".  Lacking "teamwork", "denial" and "avoidance" nullify each other.

14 hours ago, oOo said:

That brings me back to Nercohype’s seeker. Given the half-truth he was told, I’d judge his decision to leave by the danger he could reasonably have foreseen. On top of, I’d ask what warning those who knew could safely have given him.

Quote

In [the] story, [the seeker] actually leaves his home without knowing the full truth. He's been lied to for a good reason, as the truth could put his people in danger. But by pursuing his own freedom, he might unknowingly put them at risk. 

From my POV, there are three wholly destructive motives which should always be avoided:  Chaos, Vain-Glory, Falsehood.  If the MC in the story is being nourished by any of these three, then the MC's motives are certainly impure and the outcome is liable to be harmful to both the MC and the others.  However, since we don't know the MC's motives, it's impossible to judge.

The most common archetype for this genre of story-telling is the "fool's journey" where the motive is innocent to a degree.  The choice to journey beyond, into uncharted territory, is brought forward in the MC's heart-and-mind by curiosity, a natural desire for Truth.  Then tension is generated within the heart-and-mind of the audience via their knowledge of the danger that could result from the journey, from the Truth, while at the same time the MC is unaware of what might happen.

If so, then, I would expect that the inner-conflict of the MC is whether to maintain the status-quo ( order ) or instead to seek the truth in spite of the risks ( chaos ).

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now