-
Content count
1,174 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Xonas Pitfall
-
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Maybe this? I think it's also possible that this is the distinction: God doesn't really "know" reality; it IS. Which is completely fine; I agree. However, if "knowing" is a relative, finite activity, and God possesses a higher-order version of knowing, namely pure BEING itself, then surely relative knowing would be a piece of cake for God? It's similar to how we distinguish between relative love and Absolute Love. If hatred, separation, and conditional love are all finite expressions of Absolute Love, while God possesses the highest, most inclusive form of Love, then of course God can manifest all those "lower" relative forms of Absolute Love. +------------------------------------------------+ | INFINITY (GOD) | | | | ABSOLUTE BEING / CONSCIOUSNESS / LOVE | | | | +--------------------------------+ | | | RELATIVE REALITY | | | | | | | | Knowing / Concepts | | | | Distinctions / Perspectives | | | | Conditional Love / Hate | | | | Finite Experiences | | | | | | | +--------------------------------+ | | | | God IS the whole, including every part. | +------------------------------------------------+ You could imagine it as two nested sets: The larger set is INFINITY, where God possesses absolute BEING, LOVE, and CONSCIOUSNESS. Within that larger set are all the finite, relative expressions of those properties. For example, relative knowledge could be understood as a limited form of Being. Because a finite human cannot literally BE everything, they instead try to understand reality by mentally conceptualizing, separating, and categorizing it. But God doesn't have that limitation. God literally IS everything that the human is trying to know. So if God already possesses the higher-order reality of BEING, why would the lower-order activity of "knowing" be problematic for God? I completely understand why this would be impossible for finite beings. A finite human cannot attain or embody the totality of Infinite Love, Being, or Consciousness. But God certainly can, because God IS that totality. It's like saying that I possess an infinite reservoir of water, but somehow I'm incapable of filling a single bottle. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
And no worries at all! Again, I don't think people (or at least I hope not) expect you to know everything. I think the issue is more when someone makes very confident, absolutist statements like "This is the truth. How do you not understand? This is just how it is," etc. Then, at least for me, I start thinking, "Oh fuck, if this is really THAT obvious and they're THAT confident about it, what am I missing here?" And that can actually leave me even more confused, haha. Whereas if there were some acknowledgment from the start, like "Hey, this is a tricky topic, and I'm not entirely sure myself," then it could turn into a much more fun and open discussion where we're all trying to figure things out together and bounce ideas off each other -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I guess, to contemplate this I don't see a reason why God wouldn't know. Again, I completely agree that, as humans, we can't. We're relative beings, and when you start talking about God and ass hairs, you're talking about an infinite timeline, all possible iterations, and potentially infinite variations of existence. Even if a human somehow tried to "download" all that knowledge, their brain would probably explode. But again, we're talking about GOD here. God IS that hairy ass, every hair on it, every bit of skin, and every possible iteration of hairy asses you could ever conceive of. So why would God necessarily have any limitations in observing or knowing its own ass hairs? God is simultaneously the observer, the observed, and every possible finite perspective through which those observations occur. If God really couldn't know something about itself, my question would be: What exactly is imposing that limitation? What is preventing God from knowing or observing some aspect of its own existence? If anyone could know every hair on its own ass, wouldn't it be an Infinite Self-Referencing Intelligence that literally IS every self, every observer, and everything observed, with nothing outside itself? And if God itself imposes that limitation, is it really a limitation definitionally? But again, as I've said before, if we define "knowledge" as something inherently finite and conceptual, then sure, I can understand that. What I still don't understand is why "not-knowing" would be a better description. Doesn't not-knowing ordinarily imply some kind of lack, absence, or negation? I've never really encountered a technical definition of "not-knowing" that would make it a more appropriate description of Absolute Infinity. Usually, when we choose words to describe God, we favor terms like: Love rather than Hate: Because love implies inclusion, acceptance, and unity, whereas hate implies rejection, exclusion, or separation. Infinite rather than Finite: Because finitude implies boundaries and limitations, whereas infinity transcends them. Intelligent rather than Unintelligent: Because intelligence implies the capacity to understand, connect, create, and integrate, whereas unintelligence suggests a lack of understanding or capacity. Conscious rather than Unconscious: Because consciousness implies awareness, whereas unconsciousness suggests an absence. Powerful rather than Weak: Because power implies capacity and ability, whereas weakness implies limitations or an inability to act. Omnipotent rather than Impotent: Because omnipotence implies unlimited power, whereas impotence implies an inability to exercise power. The reason we favor these terms, at least as I understand it, is that they seem to point toward something more integrative, unlimited, and free of separation or "otherness." For example, we don't fundamentally describe God as finite because finitude implies some boundary beyond which something else exists, an "Other" that is somehow limiting God. We don't describe God as unintelligent because that suggests there is something God cannot understand, integrate, or comprehend, an "Other" that is somehow outside of God's reach. We don't describe God as unconscious because that suggests some aspect of reality exists outside its awareness, an "Other" that is somehow outside of God's reach. And we don't describe God as weak or impotent because those terms suggest limitations on its ability or power, an "Other" that is somehow limiting God. Yet when it comes to knowledge, we suddenly seem to reverse this pattern and describe God as fundamentally not-knowing rather than all-knowing. So that's my question: Why does "not-knowing" fit better here? What exactly is limiting God? Again, I apologize if there's some deeper technical or mystical definition I'm missing. If "knowledge" is being defined as inherently finite, while "not-knowing" somehow refers to a more unlimited, nondual state of Consciousness, then I can understand the distinction. But I've never encountered these terms being used that way. Usually, when I hear "not-knowing," I understand it as implying a lack of awareness or understanding, something unknown, inaccessible, or beyond one's ability to grasp. In other words, something "other" that escapes one's consciousness. And that seems difficult to reconcile with the very definition of God as Absolute Infinity, Infinite Intelligence, and pure Consciousness, where nothing exists outside the totality of what God is. So I'm trying to understand why not-knowing would be considered a more fundamental or accurate description of God's nature than Absolute Knowing. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I see! But my question then is: why stop at "nothing"? Or, I guess, to give a better example: I keep drawing the comparison between love and evil/hate because I feel like it illustrates my "confusion" well. "You can, however, get closer and closer to loving everything (which is what the evolution of consciousness is all about); and the closer you get to loving everything, the more it will feel like loving nothing... because, again, everything and nothing are two sides of the same coin." So, following that reasoning, I could conclude that the foundation of reality is Evil (loving nothing), because eventually you go from loving everything to loving nothing. Therefore, both Love and Evil would have to be equally fundamental properties of God. But that doesn't seem like what most of us would agree with here. So why should we privilege "not-knowing (knowing nothing)" over "omniscience (knowing everything)" when describing the Absolute? In the same way, why don't we privilege "loving nothing" (Absolute Neutrality) over "loving everything" (Absolute Love) when describing God's fundamental nature? If you say that something knows "everything, or is quote and quote approaching ever more," you wouldn't normally consider that closer to the definition of "not-knowing" than omniscience. I mean, if something is getting closer and closer to knowing absolutely everything (along a relative timeline, since there isn't really "time" for God), wouldn't you naturally describe it as approaching omniscience rather than not-knowing? At the very least, you'd call it the closest thing to omniscience there is. That's how I understand it. Using the example you gave, you could imagine God as something like an integral that keeps approaching infinity in terms of knowledge, until, at its highest point, it achieves complete omniscience or total, absolute consciousness. Similarly, you could say that God progressively approaches complete understanding or Absolute Love as it unites with everything, until there are no remaining fragments, distinctions, biases, or separations. It is all Unified, all One, all Love; hence, we don't say God is Absolute "Evil". -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Hehe... this can be sometimes true... -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Hahaha Hey, hey now! I'll have you know that some of my JAQing off sessions have led to wonderfully productive awakenings! -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
But what exactly does "Infinite Intelligence" mean? I definitely heard you use this term before. If God, or Infinity itself, is infinitely intelligent, wouldn't that be the closest possible thing to what we'd call Absolute Knowledge or Absolute Omniscience? I mean, if this "being" (for lack of a better term) can create, understand, integrate, and unify every possible distinction and perspective, what could possibly be a higher form of knowing or understanding than that? What else would we call something like that, if not Absolute Knowing? I'm genuinely curious how Infinite Intelligence can be a fundamental property of God while not-knowing is simultaneously considered more fundamental than knowing. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Again, just to clarify, I'm not trying to be "clever" or anything. I'm genuinely just asking questions because I'm confused, haha 😅 Maybe I simply don't understand what "knowledge" means in this context? That's why I keep asking for more precise, "technical" definitions. Because I could equally argue that "not-knowing," definition-wise and technically speaking, seems like a rather unfitting term to attribute to God (as I tried to illustrate with the comparison table above). But again, maybe I'm just misunderstanding what the term is actually pointing toward. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
No. Hatred and separation are far deeper than that. Literally, Reality is so relativistically fragmented, filled with conflicting perspectives, suffering, hatred, and exclusion, that unconditional love becomes impossible. The more conscious you become of all these relative perspectives, the deeper the separation becomes, until you realize that everything rejects or conflicts with something else. Nothing can be loved unconditionally, ultimately. Absolute Love isn't real. Something, something... -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
How so? I'm wondering if there's some definitional gap here that I'm still missing, given the examples I've mentioned above. To me, omniscience usually implies something highly conscious, integrative, infinitely intelligent, and all-encompassing. These qualities seem much closer to what God fundamentally is. Even if we want to get technical about definitions, the term "knowing" seems to point toward God's nature much more accurately than "not-knowing." For example, consider what these terms usually imply: | Knowing | Not-knowing | |----------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------| | Awareness | Lack of awareness | | Understanding | Lack of understanding | | Insight and recognition | Ignorance or uncertainty | | Connecting and integrating information | Inability to grasp or recognize something | | Comprehension | Absence of knowledge | Of course, these are ordinary meanings, but that's precisely where my confusion comes from. For example, we use the term LOVE to describe God because love, to me, implies unity, integration, acceptance, and the absence of separation or bias. Love recognizes the underlying connection between all things. Similarly, we describe God as Infinite Intelligence, rather than Infinite Stupidity, because intelligence implies the ability to understand, generate, connect, and integrate. The greater the intelligence, the greater its capacity to recognize how everything fits together. And if God is literally the ultimate creator, connector, integrator, and the unity of all possible perspectives, wouldn't "knowing" be a much more appropriate term than "not-knowing"? Absolute Knowing seems much closer to God's nature than Absolute Not-Knowing. Again, I might simply be misunderstanding what the term is pointing toward. I'm just trying to figure out why "not-knowing" would be a more accurate description of God's fundamental nature than "knowing," especially when we already describe God as Infinite Intelligence, Absolute Love, and Consciousness itself. - The only way I can really see the term "not-knowing" is if it's being used in a more mystical sense, meaning there is no conceptual knowledge, no distinctions, and no finite forms of knowing, because all of that belongs to relative reality. In that sense, I can understand why "not-knowing" might be considered more accurate. But still, if we simultaneously describe God as Infinite Intelligence, choosing the term "not-knowing" feels somewhat contradictory, at least definition-wise. It's similar to how we call God Absolute Love rather than Absolute Hate, even though relative hatred exists, or Absolute Infinity rather than finitude, even though finite experiences exist. We choose these terms because they seem to better represent God's ultimate nature. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
God in a low state of Consciousness can be a sadist who enjoys causing suffering. You think those contradictions are bad? How do you explain that God is Absolute Love and God is simultaneously a sadist? If God is All-Loving, why do hatred, sadism, cruelty, and suffering exist? I shouldn't be explaining to you how this is possible. You should be explaining to me how God can be Absolute Love while simultaneously manifesting as beings who experience and inflict hatred. And I could make the same argument about Infinity itself: God in a low state of Consciousness experiences itself as a finite, limited being. How do you explain that God is Absolutely Infinite and simultaneously finite? If God is Infinite, why does finitude exist at all? If God is Unlimited, why does God experience limitations? Does that mean God isn't actually Infinite? My point is that the existence of relative ignorance doesn't necessarily contradict Absolute Omniscience, just as the existence of relative hatred doesn't necessarily contradict Absolute Love, or the existence of finitude doesn't contradict Absolute Infinity. In all three cases, God would be manifesting something at the relative level that appears to contradict its absolute nature. So why do we accept that God can be Absolute Love while manifesting hatred, and Absolute Infinity while manifesting finitude, but reject the possibility that God can be Absolutely Omniscient while manifesting ignorance? What makes knowledge fundamentally different from love or infinity in this regard? -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I feel like this same argument could be used when we talk about God being all-loving rather than all-hating. For example, when I say God is all-loving, that doesn't mean God can suddenly cure the sadism of a serial killer, or eliminate the hunger and survival instincts of a tiger chasing a gazelle to hunt, cannibalize, and eat. You should not expect God to have that kind of ability in the relative sense. You can, of course, define terms however you like, but you have to be careful because you can define terms in counterproductive ways. Do you know how to make a sadist suddenly fall in love with charity? Neither does God. So, following the same reasoning, I could argue: See? God isn't all-loving after all. God cannot make every finite being loving, eliminate all hatred, or cure every instance of suffering. But of course, that would be an incorrect understanding of what Absolute Love means. If we wouldn't reject God's Absolute Love simply because hatred and suffering exist within relative reality, why should we reject God's Absolute Knowing simply because particular forms of relative knowledge aren't available from a finite perspective? I think the way I understand it is that, definition-wise, "not-knowing" here probably means something like "the absence of bias, distinctions, and specific forms of knowing." So in that sense, it would be a fair attribute of God. I guess my critique was simply that "not-knowing" isn't usually used that way, and that what we're describing would more commonly be understood as omniscience, at least in the way we ordinarily use these "technical human terms," I suppose. I think this is especially true if we describe God as Infinite Intelligence. You definitely wouldn't, or at least I wouldn't, attribute a term (not-knowing) that usually implies "unawareness," "lack of insight," or "ignorance" in ordinary human language to such a being. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Sorry! Just to clarify, when I type these things out, it's mostly me trying to deconstruct these ideas for myself. I'm not expecting you to explain everything to me or anyone else. It's more like I'm having a debate with myself and others to deepen my own understanding, haha. All love to Leo! ❤️ -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I guess, to point out the contradictions I've noticed: Contradiction 1: You say "knowledge is a very technical term." I could say the same about the term "not-knowing." This is what I find when I look it up: Ignorance: A lack of knowledge, information, or understanding (neutral in its literal sense, though often used as a harsh label). Unaware / Oblivious: Lacking consciousness or attention toward a specific fact or event. Unknowing / Unwitting: Acting or existing without knowledge or intent. Nescient: A formal or literary term meaning lacking knowledge or ignorant. Incognizant: Lacking awareness or failing to notice something. All of these imply a lower level of consciousness, something that "escapes" God's awareness. None of these definitions describe "having no distinctions or concepts." What you're pointing toward seems closer to: Not-knowing in the mystical sense: A form of openness in which reality is experienced without being reduced to conceptual knowledge. You're pointing toward a nondual understanding of consciousness. That was my original issue. For example, we have no problem using the term "infinity" to describe God, and we don't dismiss it as merely a "human mathematical concept." But when it comes to knowledge, we're choosing a term that ordinarily implies ignorance and attributing it to the Absolute, to God. Hence my confusion. Contradiction 2: Just as people argued that you wouldn't call God "all-hateful," even though relative hatred exists among finite beings, I could make the same argument about not-knowing. You wouldn't call God fundamentally "not-knowing" if that term implies a finite limitation, namely, God's inability to access or be aware of something. That wouldn't accurately describe God's fundamental nature, because God is awareness itself, pure consciousness. So using "not-knowing" in that sense would be flawed. But again, if "not-knowing" is being used to imply the absence of dualities and conceptual distinctions, rather than a lack of awareness of finite things, then sure, I can understand that. I'd just say that this definition of "not-knowing" is not one I'm familiar with, and it seems quite different from how the term is ordinarily understood. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Claim: God cannot possess complete relative knowledge of everything it manifests. Therefore, God's property isn't "knowledge"; it's "not-knowing." My question is: if God is both finite and infinite, all there is, everything and nothing, then we'd have: Absolute consciousness, which is prior to all distinctions. Relative consciousness, which generates distinctions and knowledge of the "relative". One total reality that encompasses both without contradiction. If God's consciousness is absolutely unlimited, and there is no division between the knower and the known at the absolute level, what could make any aspect of God's own being inaccessible to God's consciousness? What is this "other" made of, if not God's own substrate, that would even allow for such a blockage? - Again, this is a completely valid argument for a human and why a human might not be capable of knowing everything. But we're talking about GOD, THE ABSOLUTE, INFINITY. From a human perspective, of course I cannot be conscious of everything. My brain is only partially aware of things like my heartbeat, blood circulation, nervous system, motor functions, and countless subconscious processes. But we're talking about God, which you define as absolutely EVERYTHING. God is everything, creates everything, and there is no separation. It's the total unity of all that exists, encompassing both every relative perspective and the Absolute itself. So why couldn't that totality be omniscient? God is simultaneously my heartbeat, me experiencing that heartbeat, my family observing me, and every other perspective and interaction involved. God IS all of it simultaneously. - To explain it further, let's say a scientist wants to perfectly KNOW something, like a mosquito. What would that scientist ideally want to do? They'd want to observe the mosquito in the wild, in a laboratory, zoomed in, zoomed out, throughout its entire lifespan, and across all of time. They'd want to understand every aspect of its biology, behavior, and interactions with its environment. Would the scientists want to become the mosquito? To experience reality from its perspective? And then become the mosquito it mates with, the predator that hunts it, the human it bites, the blood it consumes, the environment it inhabits, and every single organism and process that interacts with it? And not just from one perspective, but from ALL perspectives, throughout all of time, including every possible interaction, relationship, and experience. Now, of course, a scientist cannot do this because they're finite and limited to a particular perspective. But God has ZERO limitations. God isn't merely observing the mosquito from outside. God IS the mosquito, its environment, every observer, every interaction, and the entire reality in which all of this takes place. In that sense, God would be the perfect scientist, perfect knower, and the perfect experiencer, because there is literally nothing outside of God that could remain inaccessible to it. Am I making sense? Wouldn't you call this the closest possible thing to omniscience? - If you say that knowing is finite and limiting, but not-knowing is unlimited and fundamental, we need to define exactly what not-knowing means. If it means the absence of conceptual distinctions, then I understand. But I'd question whether this is the correct "technical" term. If anything, I could argue that you can call it complete knowing, not "not-knowing". When we say God is UNITY, LOVE, "COMPLETE UNDERSTANDING," integration, these all point toward "integrative knowing" definitions, not not-knowing. Similarly, you wouldn't call God the ultimate destroyer, the ultimate hater, or the ultimate not-knower, because that implies a "lack," something missing, something that escapes the "unity." What is God not able to be aware of? What escapes this "unity" for God to not know? But if it means the inability to be conscious of some aspect of reality, why would that be an essential characteristic of an absolutely unlimited God? I think when most of us say "not-knowing," we'd define it more closely as this: the inability to be conscious of some aspect of reality, or the inability to grasp a concept of reality. -
Got it, then I apologize and agree. I guess the "successful" part wasn't necessary, so I misinterpreted it. I was wondering why you'd only leave after being successful, but yeah, I agree with the point you made now that I understand.
-
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Hmm... This (maybe?) sounds like some kind of definitional issue. Again, I fully agree that if the issue is "How would you define the question?" as in, "What counts as an ant?", "Where exactly?", "At what point in time?", etc., then yes, things get tricky. It's ultimately up to whoever is asking the question to define precisely what they're asking. So in that sense, I fully agree. But I don't see why "not knowing" would be any more fundamental to God than "knowing." If you are everything throughout all of time and infinite space, both the observer and the observed, then why wouldn't omniscience be an inherent property of your being? Why would "not knowing" be more fundamental than absolute self-knowledge? Why would God be limited to knowing only the Absolute Self? If God is also every relative being, then shouldn't all relative knowledge be accessible to God as well? Again, I'm not saying this knowledge would be accessible to an individual ant or human. I fully agree that their perspectives are limited. But if God is simultaneously a singular relative self in the form of an ant, every ant that exists right now, every ant that has ever existed or will ever exist, and not only that, but also everything observing and surrounding those ants, then wouldn't God necessarily possess all relative knowledge as well? If God is both the Absolute and every possible relative perspective, both the observer and the observed, across all of space and time, then wouldn't that imply omniscience of both the Absolute and all relative reality? And wouldn't "hate" be considered "lower" than love, in the same way that "not knowing" would be "lower" than knowing or omniscience? If we're talking about God as absolute infinity, why would the absence of knowledge be more fundamental than its complete presence? -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Gotcha, then I understand. If the issue is how you'd define or even pose the question, since the question itself relies on relative definitions, then sure, I agree. God would still know all the "ants", but the issue would be in posing the question precisely enough to define what you're actually asking. I feel like that's a more accurate way of framing it. But in terms of "knowing" as in absolute self-knowledge of its own infinity, I think that still necessarily follows. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Yes, this is completely valid if we're talking from the relative perspective of an observer. But we're talking about God. If God is the substrate of everything (and not just "substrate" but IS that), then all these things are essentially God. So when you ask: My point is that the ants, their mutations, the eggs, the ocean, Australia, the boundaries, and even the observer making these distinctions are all God. Every single aspect of that scenario is God itself. Hence my original question: What if you are literally all of these things simultaneously, across all of time, including everything observing and everything being observed? If you ARE all of it, every perspective, every experience, every interaction, across infinite time, then wouldn't that necessarily imply omniscience? After all, what could possibly be unknown to God if there is nothing outside of God to begin with? --- However, if your point is that when we ask about an "ant," we haven't clearly defined what we mean by "ant," then sure, I agree. But that's more an issue with how the human asking the question defines their terms, not an issue with knowledge itself. There's no reason God wouldn't know about half-eaten ants, mutated ants, unhatched ants, or any other variation. When you ask, "How many ants are there right now?" you simply need to define what counts as an ant, what "right now" means, and where exactly you're counting. The ambiguity lies in the question, not necessarily in God's capacity to know the answer. Hope I'm making sense -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Interesting. Thanks for the input! I guess, out of curiosity, I understand why we as humans wouldn't be able to achieve that, but why not God? If I were an ant, and everything surrounding it, observing it over infinite, boundless time, wouldn't I eventually acquire practically perfect knowledge of that observed point and every other point? Imagine you're a being that has infinite time, and you are simultaneously everything that's being observed and everything that's observing it. You're both the observer and the observed. Why would complete omniscience be an issue? That makes sense from the perspective of a human or an ant. But what if you ARE every ant that has ever existed or will ever exist, the ground beneath them, the wind touching them, the colonies they've built, the queen ants, the worker ants, and even the scientists observing and experimenting on them? What if you are literally all of these things simultaneously, across all of time, including everything observing and everything being observed? If you ARE all of it, every perspective, every experience, every interaction, across infinite time, then wouldn't that necessarily imply omniscience? -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
How do you define it? I may or may not agree, depending on what the "technical" definition is. The same can potentially apply to the term "infinity." You could use its "technical" definition, but then one could argue that it's merely a human-made concept. For example, infinity can be defined as an indefinitely great number or amount. But by that definition, God wouldn't be infinite. We'd need some entirely different word that hasn't even been invented yet, because the definition itself relies on terms like "number" and "amount," which are also finite human concepts. Hope that makes sense. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/know know : to perceive directly : have direct cognition of (2): to have understanding of importance of knowing oneself : to recognize the nature of : discern : to recognize as being the same as something previously known : to be acquainted or familiar with : to have experience of : to be aware of the truth or factuality of : be convinced or certain of b: to have a practical understanding of This fits quite well, in my opinion, when it comes to God's "capabilities, properties." -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Maybe we just have different definitions of knowledge. Knowledge isn't necessarily a "human" property, is it? By that same line of reasoning, you could argue that God is something "beyond infinity" because infinity is merely a human mathematical concept. But when we use these absolute terms, we're pointing toward something beyond their ordinary "human" conceptual meanings. When I say "infinite," I mean absolute infinity, not infinity in the "human" mathematical sense. Similarly, when I say "knowledge," I don't mean intellectual, academic, or conceptual "human" knowledge. I mean absolute self-knowledge, God's complete awareness of itself. If God is all that exists, and there is nothing outside God, then what could possibly prevent God from knowing itself absolutely? There is nothing external that could impose such a limitation. The only thing that could limit God is God itself. But then, is that really a limitation in the absolute sense? And more fundamentally, if knowledge is inherently a limitation, why wouldn't the absence of knowledge also constitute a limitation? On what grounds are you assuming that knowledge is necessarily finite rather than potentially absolute? -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Yes, but that was exactly my point. Absolute infinity should have infinite knowledge of itself, hence no finite limitation of "not knowing." The experience of not knowing arises from finitude, from a finite or relative point of view. -
Xonas Pitfall replied to Someone here's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Wouldn't this be a "limit" on God, a form of "finitude," and therefore contradict the very definition of God (Infinity)? -
This sentence also illustrates the issue I was talking about. "Of course he's gonna look to split with his partner." That phrasing alone implies that this is somehow the natural, obvious, reasonable outcome. That means that you can have a long-term relationship in which your partner has supported you and contributed to your success, whether directly through your career or business, or indirectly by raising your children, managing responsibilities, and taking care of other aspects of your shared life so you could focus on building something. And yet, as your sentence suggests, once the man becomes "successful," it's somehow expected, or even justified, that he'll want to leave. Even though you've both aged, she's raised your children, and she's invested years of her life building that family alongside you. And also, why is he only leaving once he's "successful"? If you're genuinely unhappy in your relationship and don't see a long-term future with that person, why not leave when you come to that realization? Why do you wait for your partner to build you up and help you succeed, only to ditch them afterward? What is that? As @something_else said, there's nothing inherently wrong with evaluating the "value" of a relationship, especially early on, or periodically reassessing whether it's healthy or sustainable. But once you've built a long-term partnership, especially one involving children, shared sacrifices, and decades of mutual investment, the concept of "value" becomes much more complicated. It shouldn't be reduced to a transactional calculation of what your partner currently offers you, as though everything they've contributed over the years suddenly becomes irrelevant. And at the very least, we shouldn't be normalizing or encouraging the idea that leaving your aging partner once you've achieved success is some inevitable or perfectly natural progression. You're essentially giving an expiration date to your relationship from the very beginning. And as I said earlier, I find it surprising that one'd expect anyone to genuinely commit to that.
