-
Content count
1,285 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Anton Rogachevski
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Here and now, it's eternal. It's another way to look at the nature of experience. Phenomenologically speaking there is no such thing as "time" besides a conception of it. There cannot be an experience of something that doesn't exist, if that is seen, it all becomes an eternal now. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@DocWatts Wow! Thank you for the amazing feedback. I love to see that at least someone finds this kind of writing useful. I'll be sure to check out your essay as soon as possible. It's funny you should mention these kind of sources as I haven't even touched any of them. I do have trouble with reading books. The commitment to such a large volume always deters me. I do learn a lot from podcasts and the like. (I need to be really engaged to get those receptors to perceive at least something) Of course that means I might reinvent the wheel a couple of times, but on the plus side I get the nice feeling of eureka even though someone must have thought about it at one point. Most of the inspiration is from personal contemplation of direct experience. Trying to put things together to make sense of what experience is. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@UnbornTao I'm only conscious of the ever present now, and not of anything else. There's not a thing that is not Now, nor would such a thing make sense. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Are you directly conscious of Being as absolute? What does "absolute" even mean? In what way? "What is now?" That question doesn't make sense. What isn't Now? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Might be good enough for non dual gurus, but it's very problematic if you want some serious philosophical argument. What do you mean by "what is"? These are the same - pure experience - pure hallucination -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@Reciprocality Oh I get it now, it's about the previous essay about Deconstructing reality that was linked in the introduction. In that case your paraphrasing is spot on. In this essay I try to make it as technical and rational as possible to be introduced to a serious philosopher rather than the old essay which is like a modern Buddhism take. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
The formation of a Duality between experience and the external world Experience, as it is lived – or seen from within, is inherently non-dual – there is no internal split between “subject” and “object” within the immediacy of perception. However, when one reflects on experience from a “meta-level” (which unsurprisingly itself arises within experience), a distinction appears between “what is experienced” and a supposed “external world” that causes it. This is basically the hard problem in a nutshell – the nature of experience is such that it can’t yet be explained in terms of physics, it’s more like magic. In that sense there is an apparent duality that is yet to be resolved by science. I believe we might solve it someday, and explain how such a phenomenon can exists within the brain cells, and can even generate a sense of self awareness in those cells that are aware of this phenomenon, but we are still not there. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
This makes sense. I don't see any other thing besides experience itself as a substance of me. In what way is it absolute? How to verify this in experience? I say to leave all speculation and focus on what is directly available to us right now the true nature of experience. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
I was really interested in what kind of truth you are talking about and the kind you are really interested in. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Basically nothing can obscure experience within itself because the substance of belief is also experience. -- You are positing some very interesting questions but at points they seem to digress from the topic. Some of the new and interesting topics you raised like "constructivism" I'm simply not familiar with yet. Sure if you chose to paraphrase it would be nice to cite the original so I could know exactly the point I was trying to make. It just seems you "saw" in my points something that wasn't originally meant. I really appreciate your answers and most of all your interest in this! So thank you dear friend. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
I'm not as optimistic about it ever bringing me closer to what's actually real. The most it can do is to get to the deepest layer of the substance of experience. But you won't get an explanation of what it is and what's it is made from, but rather you become pure experience and you can just be it. (Spoiler alert you already are it - pure experience) In that sense maybe "Being" is somewhat correct. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Are simply the grammar of how the mind works, they are not tools of truth, but of practicality and survival. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
If by reality you mean the noumena then beliefs are the best you can wish for. If we talk about Truth as Phenomenological Truth, then all concepts are pure hallucination, because raw unfiltered experience is completely empty - so any attempt whatsoever to think about it will be wrong the moment you start thinking about it. I think you may have misunderstood. It's hard to see what you are referring to in the original. I propose a duality between the unreachable by science (yet) experience, and the actual physical world which can be described by science in some sense. (also not complete ofcourse) What kind of truth are you talking about? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Why do you keep saying it's Ontological? In what sense? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Epistemology – How can we know anything? What does it mean to “know”? The brain has evolved to survive, not to access Ontological truth. It may or may not be able to actually derive truth about the external world, but we can’t know that for sure. How do you know you aren’t dreaming right now? If we are dreaming right now, then everything we think we’ve figured out – about truth, reality, physics, philosophy, even this theory – could be meaningful only within the dream, and meaningless outside it. This is a framework for understanding how knowledge arises within experience, one that avoids making claims about what really exists “out there.” Instead, it reflects critically on how experience produces the appearance of an external world and uses a probabilistic model to explain belief, perception, and sanity. It is grounded in what can be directly verified phenomenologically, while remaining skeptical of ontological conclusions. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
How does he not see that his contemplation most likely had led to this, I don't think it's just spontaneous. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@UnbornTao I only heard it from Alex O'connor but i guess you can ask GPT for the source. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@UnbornTao Thomas Aquinas the world's most famous theologian has said the same about all his books after an experience. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Kill him! Yes when there's a powerful experience all the previous theories that sounded profound sound all like baby babbling. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Can we really? I think we can only be directly conscious of what's True without thinking about it. Thank you dear friend "Before Enlightenment carrying water and chopping wood" - We just love thinking about progress as humans -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Defining the Key Terms Phenomenology Phenomenology is the study of experience as it appears, from the first-person perspective. It asks: What is it like to be here, right now? It suspends, or “brackets,” questions about whether what we experience corresponds to an external reality. Meta-Phenomenology Meta-phenomenology is the reflection on phenomenology itself - it observes how we observe, how we interpret our experiences, and how we make inferences about the world from within experience. Ontology Ontology is the philosophical study of what exists “out there,” independent of perception. This framework avoids ontological claims entirely - it neither affirms nor denies what ultimately exists, because such claims can’t be directly verified from within experience. Phenomenological Truth A phenomenological truth is something undeniable within experience itself, regardless of whether it corresponds to external reality. Seeing red is a phenomenological truth; knowing what “red” is in the world is not. Phenomenological Empiricism This theory rests on a simple but powerful principle: every claim must be directly verifiable within your own immediate experience. Don’t take my word for it - look carefully for yourself, observe your moment-to-moment experience, and see if what I’m saying holds true. The only true ground for this framework is what you can find firsthand. Descartes’ Demon Descartes’ famous thought experiment challenges the very reliability of our minds. He imagines an all-powerful, malicious demon capable of deceiving us about everything we perceive — not just in small ways, but entirely. What if all that we see, hear, and experience is nothing more than an elaborate illusion of the demon’s making, with no way for us to peer beyond it? In such a world, everything we “know” would be only what the demon allows us to know. Sanity Defining such a term in just a few words is difficult, but broadly speaking, sanity is the meta-belief that beliefs can track reality. We often say an insane person has “lost touch with reality” — so remaining in touch with reality, and perceiving it without serious distortion, carries deep epistemological importance. Sanity is something to value and protect, not to gamble with through reckless experimentation, as some spiritual seekers do with psychedelics. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Haha at least one person is excited It seems the total amount of the fucks given is one It's sad how this thread is the least popular on the forum, it seems we are all Spirituality junkies high on non dual mumbo jumbo. Do you see an value to the theory? Has it made you think about it? Changed your perspective on something? -
Anton Rogachevski posted a topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
What could be more meaningful? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Yes! I agree! -
Anton Rogachevski replied to UnbornTao's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
@UnbornTao The part about cooking sand and trying to make a delicious meal hits hard. Yep it seems the mind is not located but it's also everywhere. Correct me if I'm wrong as they are not so clear about that point. Why is he talking about himself in 3rd person and also calling himself "holy" or something?
