Anton Rogachevski

Member
  • Content count

    1,285
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Anton Rogachevski

  1. @Lila9 If something is "real" experientially, does that make it Real? Experience is pure hallucination.
  2. @Lila9 Both "separation" and "unity" are concepts. The problem with calling any part of God "corrupt" is creating a separation of nature which there is none. Parts of God are corrupt and evil, the unconscious parts of it.
  3. I'm trying to say that Leo is missing the big picture by pointing at instances of survival as corrupt or wrong or as contradicting Truth. God is a child that learns by mistakes, sometimes that mistake is war ,sometimes it's a Holocaust. It's not that simple.
  4. This makes me quite skeptical of all the "existential" or "truth" matters. What's more true than the need of a living creature to survive? Trying to look for absolute truths in such a vast and a divided reality looks silly to me. It's so natural for a unified consciousness to look for unity in reality.
  5. @Leo Gura What's the problem with survival? It's the most essential force of nature, driving all of the living creatures. Of course it's better to be conscious of it, but one can't just stop it willy nilly, that would contradict nature, and therefore God. God wants to survive through all the living creatures.
  6. @Cred Good luck my friend, I hope you succeed! Keep at it 💪
  7. @Cred Ok you should stick with this for while, this is great phenomenology and cognitive science. What leads you in this direction? What would you like to achieve?
  8. First write your thesis on what Neurodiversity is, it would be interesting to discuss. Metaphysics is a nice mental exercise for sure!
  9. I don't even know what "Absolute" is. This should be grounded in direct experience to contemplate it. You can't just invent an idea of an "Absolute" out of thin air.
  10. First define both and then explain why you are saying they are the same. Are there facts ontologically speaking? What does it mean for a fact to exist? Where does it exist?
  11. @Cred My whole problem with Modal logic is that it's hypothetical and ungrounded. "This could be and this could be" ad infinitum. Let's look at what is, what is right in front of you? Not what it could or couldn't be because of some ethereal concept like time or space or whatever.
  12. Try this. Paste your theory into an AI (I love gemini's thinking model, but Claude is also supreme for this) then paste my objections, and ask it questions. It's good at making 1+1 like that. You can pin the chat as Theory and keep coming back, asking more questions, ask it to ask you questions.
  13. How do you conclude that facts = existence? You start your theory by assuming there is only the absolute, and this is question begging. How did you reach that conclusion? For what reason did it suddenly decide to fragment? You assume the existence of change and time based on the first unquestioned axioms, and aren't "change" and "time" the same thing? Ok you do need space for anything to be. I didn't understand why you need "wholeness" at all I can't understand why "reality=idea=matter=spirit=consciousness" how did you conclude that? It would be much easier to say all of this in one sentence. You are consciousness itself or spirit, and you constructed all these ideas. But you could simply avoid constructing them all the same. Just be pure consciousness
  14. We usually think of sanity as binary, either on or off, at most maybe someone is more insane than the other, and never think about what is the positive aspect of gaining more sanity than normal, what we call in the spiritual sphere more enlightened or awoken. The ability to see reality as it is more accurately, to be even more sober than the norm. If this is true, then we can make a predictive model of enlightenment if we find ways to measure higher levels of sanity and so prove that sanity is central to the philosophical pursuit of the understanding of Metaphysics. We don't usually think of philosophy and psychology together but we should. We should first ask how sane and lucid the philosopher was when he declared his metaphysical statements, and even better to find a way to quantify and to measure his levels so we can know who to trust. Update Edit: I'm building a list of the required components of Hyper-Sanity, what else do you think comprises this meta structure? High Awareness Multi-Perspectival Fluidity Epistemic Humility Non-attachment to emotion Semantic Precision Highest Virtue and Universal Ethics
  15. @Cred Sure you can have a good final paradigm to rest upon, but surely not to hold on to. Send me the stuff, I'll be glad to check it out my friend.
  16. @VeganAwake The epistemically untrained mind of low sanity collapses into beliefs without noticing. You can't just chose to not believe anything from this place. You are thrown into many unquestioned and even unconscious beliefs. The work is working your way out of this mud with high sobriety to reach the true sanity I'm trying to delineate here.
  17. @Cred How do you define reason? How can you trust it? I'm trying to say that sanity is a meta structure that has many parts, and reason is one of them, but not the whole thing. Surely i would be problematic to say that someone is sane but unreasonable.
  18. Reason is only a small part of sanity I think.
  19. @VeganAwake Did i say i was? The one who stops asking questions is epistemically doomed to be stuck in closed-mindedness and dogma.
  20. @gettoefl Agree. For sure I wasn't saying that all paradigms are equally untrue, so yes they can be helpful. After all, without them we wouldn't have been able to get to where we are now in this discussion. So sanity is also the clear awareness of paradigms without attaching itself to any of them. It would be so hard to measure to this.
  21. @Ramasta9 The Hyper-Sane is aware of himself and all the "world" as pure hallucination. This is the phenomenological truth of seeing things from an enlightened perspective, but in my dual-epistemic view I still hold that there is something beyond the veil and that is the real Truth, and I am that which I will never have access to, but can only see from within as phenomenon. I can't know it, but I don't need to, I am already it. It's enough for me.
  22. @Cred A very interesting approach. Of course we can't use the old definitions the same way to work with something so extraordinary. We need to redefine.
  23. Ok I agree this is powerful. So by your definition sanity is seeing through false assumptions. It's also a good way of putting it. Just think for a second, there are no "real" or "unreal" paradigms, they are just that - a paradigm, and no paradigm can be the Truth. Enlightenment is post-paradigm, it's not within any framework.
  24. @gettoefl One cannot talk about clarity as separate from sanity. can one have clarity within insanity or sanity and a lack of clarity? sounds like clarity would be an important part of sanity. Your definition of sanity is too far from the usual way it's used, you are moving the goal post too far, and basically saying that it's a quantum leap into sanity. Basically you say it's a miracle, because one insane person somehow stumbles into sanity by mistake. There is a process and there is a degree of increasing sanity in the very process of getting there.