-
Content count
1,285 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Anton Rogachevski
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
A representation of all human knowledge: Everything second order to phenomenology. (the inner circles on top view and the top layers in the side view) -
What do you guys think about the diagram? I think @Leo Gura would say that's it's all God, self aware. Right? The Epistemic Process Take a look at this diagram that is depicting human understanding as an epistemic process that is grounded in Phenomenology: The fact that we can see the Boundary of Experience on the diagram might confuse us to think that this boundary is visible to the observer, but the situation is quite different. We can't possibly see the boundary between the known and the unknown, because to do that you will have to see them both, and therefore the unknown will become known. So to you, the epistemic agent, everything seems known! The bigger the circle the more foundational it is, and the inner circle is always second order to the outer one because it relies on it as foundation. Interestingly enough, from a phenomenological perspective experience is first order to it’s metaphysical foundation, while from the outside perspective it’s second order. This clearly demonstrated the Epistemic Dualism discussed in Chapter 2. The fact that our most abstract way of thinking, mathematics, can correspond to physical phenomena and predict it’s behaviour so well suggests to us that most likely the substance of experience may not be separate or that much different than the substance of the concrete. I think that psychological health is central to the process of forming a coherent and useful idea about reality. As you can see in the diagram: the psychological process is foundational for forming experience and to create accurate labels without much distortion. It could be in theory that all is known, and that the “unknown” outside of experience will end up being a wrong metaphysical hypothesis. We can’t know really, and if we did, it wouldn’t be unknown. Knowledge might end up being completely circular, pointing back at itself – It’s not a bug but a feature. As you can see the whole diagram, although reaching outside Philosophy to encompass all of knowledge, is at the same time a small little bubble (red dot) situated within philosophy – an idea, an image. This shows the holographic and self recurring nature of the inquiry. What can we learn? The first axiom is that there is experience. Can you doubt that you are experiencing this text right now? I don’t mean whether there is or there is not something “behind” your process of perception, but the very fact of having an experience right now in this moment. If you didn’t have it, we couldn’t talk about anything at all. I think experience is foundational in our epistemic process as an epistemic agent having a direct experience, trying to figure it all out. A hypothesis I can draw is that there may be a biological brain that has this experience. It would be odd if experience was just floating in the air experiencing itself. Theoretically however, what lies beyond the event horizon of experience is forever a mystery, and a hypothesis for the experiencer, because she can only have ideas about it, but she can never verify them empirically. That’s why I call all that lies beyond the limit of experience a “metaphysical hypothesis”, not to degrade it, but to stay humble about my ability to know it. This kind of proposition is not as far fetched because if we manipulate the brain with electrodes, or introduce psychedelic drugs, we can see a noticeable, and sometimes even a radical change in experience, so we can deduce that there must be a relation between the biological processes in the brain and the way experience appears. It’s tempting I know, to say that we know as absolute fact that the brain is generating or mediating experience, but to our direct experience these would be ideas and not actual reality. To understand what I mean you need to understand the inherently solipsistic structure of experience, and all the radical consequences it entails for what I call: “phenomenological truth” as opposed to Objective Truth.
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
What do you think? Does the inherent contingency of the inner circles upon the foundational ones, that builds up the more we go into abstraction increase the error probability and how far the map is from the actual thing? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
The structure of experience is inherently solipsistic, but does that imply a Solipsistic Metaphysics? I don't think so. From a phenomenological perspective no, from an objective view, of course yes. (The issue is that the "objective view" is second order to your phenomenology and that's exactly why you are confused.) In short I would say to solve the confusion, rest in the knowledge that you are the God of your own experience. You are your experience, you have never experienced any other thing than yourself. Leo and Me, are imaginary characters in your personal solipsistic dream, we are you. Do we exist "outside" of your dream as "real" people? Yes, but to you it matters not, because there's no such thing as "outside" in a dream, only an inside. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Ok so it's having a memory of an experience? There's another layer. On top of experience there's interpretation. Do you mean that? Please give an example of something you know. What does it mean for you to know it? I think that in spirituality as opposed to philosophy knowing is being itself. To realize you are it, and just be it. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
From a not-awakened state it doesn't help me that I'm it? As our friend said states are temporary and we can't expect a constant high state. Recently I am trying to increase my state in natural ways, but haven't seen much progress. How important are high states even if temporary? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
It's obviously not having ideas and believing them. It depends what kind of "truth" you are looking for. The ultimate ground of reality? The substance of everything? I'm focused on a much humbler version: "Phenomenological Truth" - that which is right now in your direct consciousness prior to interpretation. If you see the color Red than it's true that you are having an experience of the color red, a pure qualia. Sounds basic and boring but it has some very radical consequences if you think about it deeply. I've talked about some of them in Chapter 2 in my blog. What you said about the knowledge of pain is interesting. In your thought experiment that would literally mean that as Phenomenological Truth, the phenomenon of pain wouldn't exist for you. But it's also true right now, if you are not having any pain. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@integral Mu! -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@integral Are you yourself not confused right now from what you wrote? : ) -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
How do you know this? Can anything be known? So talking about knowing\not knowing is useless? Why do epistemology? I think Leo would claim that consciousness can know itself fully. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
<3 -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@Nemra It only seems crazy from our limited materialistic perspective. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
-
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
Spinoza would say that it's different modalities of the same substance. So no one substance creating another. Just like Leo he deduced trough logic there can only be one infinite fundamental substance - God. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@Leo Gura So you are 100% confident that awakening gives you the ability to understand the metaphysical ground of reality? How can you be so sure besides the fact that it feels more real than real? Where would epistemology be? Epistemology = Consciousness? -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@integral Nice. It's hard to picture consciousness as fundamental. I guess it doesn't need a ground, as it is it's own ground. I see you are placing the unconscious within the border of direct experience. Are you sure? You seem to have erased the "unknown", everything is known? Nothing is hidden? (I would say that it appears so from a phenomenological perspective) -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Anton Rogachevski's topic in Intellectual Stuff: Philosophy, Science, Technology
@integralYes the arrow of idea goes both ways into the metaphysical and the philosophical. But to have an experience I suppose requires to have a biological body sustaining it. So from the experiencers' point of view his experience is first order, but from the big picture if we look at it like that, it's second order. -
Anton Rogachevski replied to Natasha's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
-
@Leo Gura I'm afraid what you are offering in the blog, to "transcend humanity" and to become "post human" or God would be theoretically impossible as you are currently in a human vassel, yes you are God, but forever limited by your humanness by the inherent limits of this avatar. That's the story of Lucifer basically, but he wanted the other way around, he was Pure Godness, but wanted to be human, so became corrupted and limited. A plant can't decide to transcend itself and become a conscious animal. The very idea of transcendence is quite sketchy in my eyes, but sure you are welcome to try and show us. I think it might be psychologically dangerous, so I must warn you, but sure go ahead dude. You can purify this vessel to a point, and be sage like, but that's the max.
-
That is incorrect. "Humans" can't make it up, God can, and he did, it was necessary for him to learn all the good and bad lessons the hard way, they way evolution works. God isn't absolved from the evolutionary process, rather it is the evolutionary process. You are trying to judge the flower to grow faster, but nature doesn't work the way you want it to.
-
Of course it is, if the survival of the jewish people wasn't threatened they wouldn't need Zionism. They can't just forget their identity and pretend they are not jewish. There were many Jewish people who tried that, but hitler didn't mind, he looked in the records, and found the heritage. Blaming the Jewish people for antisemitism is the same as blaming rape victims for being attractive to the rapist. I don't see your point. Nationalism is a part of God's evolution on earth, he can't skip that part.
-
It's not moral. What does this question have to do with survival? Did these kids threaten you? Nature is brutal, many horrible things happen, but they are part of reality, this is the process of God evolving. Who said it was easy?
-
What is Truth for you? What are your metaphysics? You are being quite cryptic here. Why is identity contingent upon a forgiving? Who is forgiving whom?
-
Can contradictions exist in reality? Can reality contradict itself?
-
I'm resolving this conundrum by not being an Idealist, but by an epistemic duality and call the truths of perception Phenomenologically True. If you are hallucinating a unicorn right now, it's True that you have that experience, it's self evident and empirical data about the nature of experience. Nothing about it is "absolute" besides the fact of your absolute immersion in it. I explain it quite thoroughly in my theory of epistemology, you can check it out in my signature if you'd like.
