Topspin715
Member-
Content count
188 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Topspin715
-
taboo against incest is a cultural universal in that maybe every culture has independently decided that it is a very undesirable behavior. Not only does it increase risk of rare genetic illness, but it is potentially very destabilizing to the family structure in any society. It is theoretically possible for two siblings to become involved romantically or sexually and live healthy lives based on a sturdy relationship if they don't have children or maybe their children turn out fine, but at a societal level it is extremely risky to normalize that kind of behavior because the net effect on the entire group will likely be extremely bad.
-
this is an interesting dynamic because the transgender identity and how we decide to integrate it into american culture is deep at the heart of the american culture war that we're experiencing. to some extent, identities are social conventions, but individuals get to choose how they identify within reason and sometimes parts of society will accept that identity and others won't. we don't know how to think about transgenderism and its causing all sorts of problems. at the essence, gender dysphoria is not a social construct. some ppl physically feel very bad because of expectations that are imposed on them by society as to how they should act or behave or think because of their biological sex. If society were more accepting of diverse behaviors in men and women, then there would be less gender dysphoria. in some ways, exploring the way you relate to how society expects you to behave and whether you want to accept or reject that can be healthy as it gets you closer to your authentic self, but people can easily be misled or get off track on this wild explorations and its happening at a very large scale these days as our culture figures out what to do about all these things and how to define them. Would love to hear leo's take in a video because very very very very few people have anything intelligent to say about this concept and it's fairly important in today's world for people to able to make sense of it.
-
At a certain point, I felt like I got over the spiral dynamics model and was able to see between the lines and distinct stages so much that it was no longer so helpful to me. I only watched a few minute of this video, but any person that is religious from a traditional standpoint will be strongly blue of course. I will likely disagree with them about the nature of the universe and origin of humanity and Earth etc, but a lot of religious people, especially some religious leaders, possess very powerful spiritual wisdom which is of great value to their communities that really can't be categorized well with Spiral Dynamics. Many may still have huge personality flaws or gaps in scientific knowledge, but it takes a certain strength and level of insight and wisdom to lead their communities. Some of that wisdom transcends their local community or culture and would even be useful to all of humanity but we struggle to learn from people who we identify as being different from us.
-
Have you considered making a video on trangenderism? It's something I've been thinking about for the past year or so and it's really hard to put it into words. Society and history goes through cycles and we are at a point where gender differentials are at a cyclical low and will start to turn around again pretty soon. I'm not opposed to the idea of even having children transition, at least in theory, but my hunch is that the vast majority of children who are exploring the possibility of being trans these days really have no idea what that means or entails.
-
There is definitely a layer of the Matrix involving raw power dynamics that wants to keep some people weak in order for others to perpetuate their own survival needs. It's a really dark place to be but it definitely exists and it's not just in the mind. We will continue to see more of that over time in the US as our democracy unravels.
-
I think the way to get past a stage is to pursue enough money and success and status until you have your minimum needs met and you get to the point where you are sufficiently self aware to realize there are more important things in life once you have enough. Some people get stuck in that trap once they have enough because they don't realize they are using worldly trappings to fill a hole that it simply cannot fill. Often a trauma response or a means to find connection and respect from other people through success/money/fame. A lot of self-identifying spiritual people really skip the pursuit of worldly rewards which can be a form of escape or self-neglect.
-
Stage red in Spiral Dynamics is generally psychopathic. Some ppl get stuck there because they get traumatized or poorly socialized and others might have some kind of genetic abnormality that prevents them from developing normal social conditioning for pro-social behaviors.
-
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
thanks I really like this answer and explanation Any thoughts on how philosophy differs from spirituality? -
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Really interesting response from Chat gpt. I think esotericism refers to any kind of hidden or inner knowledge but perhaps the concepts of mysticism and occultism are much more closely related. But it seems that occultism is more often associated with supernatural or magical beliefs. What did you mean when you said that philosophy is the study of the seen where mysticism is the unseen. What does it mean to be seen versus unseen? Is unseen part of the inner or esoteric worlds? -
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Any thoughts on the differences between occultism, mysticism, and esotericism? -
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
How does spirituality fit into all of that? In what ways are philosophy and spirituality similar versus different? -
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
What would you say is the purpose of discovering truth? -
Topspin715 replied to UpperMaster's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I think there is some puzzling overlap between psychopathy and enlightenment. Because they are immune to social conditioning they have less things to unlearn that a more normal person would. But due to his impairment in empathy, it would probably be much harder for him unless he has experienced the same suffering that other people have. I think he is actually compassionate about a small number of things that he has personally suffered - mainly not being attracted to women and being poor. But he doesn't really understand much beyond that. He is crazy overcompensating from a traumatic childhood and rough upbringing that he has not yet come to terms with. It would probably take a crisis or serious adversity (like prison even) to motivate him to make changes. Right now, he seems to have little to no interest, but I think he might end up in jail. I would maybe argue that too much consciousness on certain dimensions and not others can lead to the risk of antisocial behavior being put into practice. Some of the Nazis were practitioners of yoga and mysticism and they clearly were deeply aware of how to manipulate people aggressively on a national level. Just massive limitations in other areas made them susceptible to the leadership of a megalomaniacal psychopath. -
Topspin715 replied to Rasheed's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Wilber is totally a genius but his content is so esoteric that it will be deeply appreciated by a narrow group of ppl which is why he has a cult following and misunderstood or ignored by masses. Leo is like that too in my opinion. There are very few truth seeking philosophers in this world but many of them are very private and very unlikely to be professional or academic philosophers. -
I am more familiar with Spiral Dynamics, but I have been trying to figure out the ego development model as it is a fairly close parallel. I think about 2.5 years ago I entered the ego construct aware stage and that has mostly run its course. My socialized identity and so much of my egoic and emotional conditioning has kind of fallen away, but I still don't feel that I relate to descriptions of the unitive stage. Does anybody have any suggestions on how to think about this or what to do? It feels like I've been stable for half a year now and I'm still evolving a bit but it has greatly slowed. Occasionally some ego trigger or emotion will come up, but I am at a point where I can more or less address most of them quickly and then they fall away.
-
Topspin715 replied to Topspin715's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
Solipsism is a perspective that many spiritual seekers seem to adopt, especially on this forum. It seems like a dangerous trap or black hole to me but very alluring because it is logically consistent but self-referential. I can assure you that I am experiencing a separate consciousness from you from my home. Everything in the universe is connected and interconnected on many levels. But I am an independently conscious being from you and anybody else on this forum. I guess that doesn't preclude determinism being real though and there being a lack of free will. I can't prove that you are a separate consciousness from me but if you say you are then I have no reason to believe you are merely a non-sentient holographic projection. -
Topspin715 replied to Leo Gura's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
We really need to have a national debate on the US about the purpose of 'free speech' and what legal exceptions we should impose on it. there already are a handful of restrictions although the US is less strict than other advanced countries). Beyond that, what are the obligations of private entitles to uphold these laws and maybe even privately enforce these violations. Few things are clear with the internet. As a common matter of human decency, I think internet speech should be moderated but that is a personal value of mine. I don't think there is any reason in a civil context to engage in racist or hateful speech. As civil society breaks down, so will civil discourse, and vice versa. Private business owners and operators do not have a legal responsibility in the US to protect civil discourse or speech but it would be nice if we had more people who recognized the grave importance of it. -
Chronic illnesses by nature don't have an easy or obvious solution. While its not impossible to find a solution to any chronic problem, this suggestion seems unhelpful in my opinion as it puts the focus on the frustrating and elusive aspect of chronic illness which will close you off rather than keep you open. Some chronic illnesses don't even have easy or obvious or adequate treatments. Your focus determines your reality.
-
When dealing with mystery illnesses, it's easy and very natural to fall into the trap that your fate is sealed. It is important to be as practical as you can and adapt to your unfortunate reality but always remain open to the possibility that you can find some way to improve your situation. It may not be worth it to try everything that promises or even just purports to be helpful but you can achieve a lot with an open mind and trial and error experimentation that people might never have though possible. My struggles have forced me to see the world in many more pixels and detail which is a silver lining even though I would never wish them on another person.
-
I've dealt with mystery illnesses for past decade and I would like to caution you against this kind of reductionist thinking. Even if it's true that it has a purely deterministic genetic cause (very possible), there always might be ways to heal, cure, compensate, hack your system to at least a better state. Prepare for the worst but accept that things always might get better or you can find some mixture of layered treatments that might help. I've unfortunately become intimately acquainted with the deep flaws and corruptions of modern biological thinking, western medicine and the experts that practice it. Merely believing it is 'possible' to improve, no matter how likely the odds, makes things much better to deal with because you aren't being poisoned with a fatalistic black pill. Holistic Bio-psycho-social model of medicine is the way to go and the future of western medicine I think but medicine is so rigid and siloed that it will take a long time to get there.
-
For whatever its worth, I have spend a long time learning about financial markets and practicing investing professionally and I really don't know how I would learn how to become a day trader. I think it probably is possible to figure it out but a lot of the people who report having success may very well have been gambling (most of it is gambling) and gotten lucky. If you learn how to do longer term investing, you learn more general business skills and it is a more sustainable way to make money. I generally recommend using very diversified index investing though if you aren't going to spend a lot of time focusing on it.
-
Just some things to give you perspective: the best investors of all time generated 20-30% per year over their careers, not 400% in a single day. When you are dealing with extremely small sums of money and short term time horizon, you can maybe make more but 400% in a day seems completely absurd. think about how it would work if you work a complete scam artist. Get people to do whatever you tell them and have them send you 10% of their earnings. You could be offering completely random trading decisions, and if they happen to make money (effectively playing roulette) they give you 10% of your earnings and you did nothing except find people to sign up for your scam. If they follow your suggestions and lose money, they don't pay you anything but you don't lose anything except for your time. they will prob be mad at you but they'll go away and not be able to do anything about it.
-
One thing I've noticed I guess, is that people can only recognize the capabilities that others possess if they possess them themselves. You may likely not even notice that they have certain wisdom or understanding that you lack, unless they directly transfer that wisdom and sense to you. Many times people are unwilling to even admit that another person transferred wisdom to them and just assume that they already understood what they were taught. the sophistication of systems thinking has not really been adequately described, but he has a very advanced understanding of how complex adaptive (evolutionary) systems work which he developed to build his business and investment strategy. I read most of his new book on the Changing World Order and thought it was very illuminating. I'm not familiar with the specific systems they've used to run their business or make investment decisions but I think he's written a bit about them. It's all very advanced for what most people are doing today and I worked in finance so I have familiarity.
-
Topspin715 replied to Leo Gura's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
It's all gna be OK guys, you don't need to worry anymore
