Topspin715
Member-
Content count
188 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Topspin715
-
Topspin715 replied to erikchomko's topic in Spirituality, Consciousness, Awakening, Mysticism, Meditation, God
I am not that familiar with Sadhguru's teachings but if we weren't a fraud, what would he be teaching and accomplishing and where does he live up to that and where does he fall short? He's said some pretty wacky things like how he has gotten angry at his students for using their powers to heal people and he seems to like media attention. Seeking attention isn't always a bad thing but the motivations and means by which attention is sought is often impure. Attention is a source of power. -
Part of being human is to have subjective perception and feelings about the external world. As long as you exist in a human body, it is impossible to completely eliminate that but you can rigorously work towards reducing bias, blindspots, and flaws in your thinking and communication. This is my personal opinion, but the strongest areas that I've seen within Leo's content are in the realms of meta philosophy, metaphysics, and some areas of epistemology. This is what I've found the most insightful and helpful, relative to my understanding prior to observing Leo's content and ideas. I'm personally strong in areas of social science, social philosophy, and working hard to understand politics so I see more bias and weakness there but that's relative to me. Those are areas where I'm constantly and vigorously challenging my beliefs, assumptions, mental models. The metaphilosophy content on here was truly ground breaking in my opinion. I'm interested in metaphysics and physics but have less personal space and use for it practically, and I'm deeply interested in epistemology but found things here that were helpful and insightful.
-
Better and worse can only be evaluated within the context of some "objective" reference point or measurement which is almost always arbitrary or subjective. You first have to determine an objective function for evaluating what a good or bad life priority is. Once you've done that, you can rigorously studying it using different scientific tools and methods. While it could be a very useful exercise if done thoughtfully, there will always be limitations.
-
Respectable response
-
Jay Z's latest album, 4:44, displays powerful wisdom and it was quite popular. He has evolved tremendously over the course of his life but given that he was raised in a very chaotic, survival based environment, you will see that in his earliest albums. The whole album is a masterpiece in my opinion, but this is the music video for the headline song.
-
I think this would be worthwhile and interesting. I've spent a lot of time on this thinking about this and working on it to sharpen my judgment for practical purposes. I see some blindspots here about what it even means to be biased and what causes bias. Any time you generalize about any subject or group, it inherently introduces bias unless you what you are saying is literally a property of every single instance of that generalization.
-
Topspin715 replied to Thought Art's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
It's going to get worse in coming years. People will increasingly ditch the US dollar as the global reserve currency, interest rates will continue to go up, and the government is likely to start printing money which will cause inflation which is like what happened around covid time. We desperately need entitlement reform but no politician is willing to do it because they are afraid that they can't get re-elected if they cut benefits or raise taxes. Will cause a debt hangover for probably twenty years in the US. -
Ethical marketing basically identifies potential users that might benefit from your product or service and truthfully educates them on the value so that they might buy it. There are ethical and unethical versions of these things but these days, our society is rampant with unethical business practices. This is my opinion but I think it can be unhealthy and unhelpful to generalize so much. Marketing can simply be offering a 50% promotion for first time users so that they are willing to try something out in order to convert them to a repeat customer. I don't see anything corrupt about that. I guess you could add a bias against marketing to the list of biases.
-
Topspin715 replied to Thought Art's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
The big problem with our debt largely has to do with government entitlements that grow every year to support an aging population with fewer and fewer people paying in to support those programs. Politicians also keep lower taxes for because it helps them get elected again and again. This problem has probably accelerated the most that it has under Trump but it really started with Reagan and has gotten worse under every administration except for Clinton. -
Topspin715 replied to integral's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
Capitalism isn't even a very meaningful term. It basically just refers to an economic system where the people own private property. Within a "capitalist" system, you can still redistribute significant wealth, have a very strong safety net and entitlement programs, and invest heavily in education and public infrastructure. The two biggest problems with capitalism is that it tends to lead to wealth concentration over time and then wealthy people and corporations start to buy off politicians to rig institutions and laws in their favor. When those problems get really bad, the people call for socialism although often they don't know what socialism means. -
Topspin715 replied to integral's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
Centrally planning everything in an economy is also very difficult because the market mechanism provides very useful information about what to produce and how much. It doesn't allocate resources fairly and it tends towards wealth concentration, especially when wealth can be used to overpower competitors, but the market tends to be much more resilient and efficient than a purely centrally planned economy. I'm not an expert on the subject, but part of the reason that the Soviet Union collapsed was that its economy became very bureaucratic and unresponsive to things like a collapse in the global oil price which had been bringing in a lot of revenue for the USSR. Central planning can be preferable in situations where you know exactly what you need to build and need to mobilize a lot of resources quickly like if you have an outdated economy and need to quickly modernize. The Soviet Union and China both used that power to modernize quickly. -
ADHD or any of these psychiatric diagnoses aren't very precise things with clear boundaries. They virtually all have many causes and many different ways and intensities in which they manifest. I'm not sure about this, but I think that ADHD is meant to be something genetic and not acquired by trauma. Although I'm sure that trauma cause make it difficult to focus in ways that resemble ADHD.
-
They have risks and side effects but if you are really struggling or suffering, I think you are doing yourself an injustice by totally ruling them out. Depression is a biopsychosocial phenomenon and if you have a genetic or biological vulnerability, then it can truly be a medicine. They don't always work for everybody and do your research on the risks and how they work and then decide if it might be helpful to you. At the same time, I believe they are both overprescribed and too stigmatized. Hope you feel better soon.
-
I wouldn't even say things are perfect. They just exist.
-
It was a serious comment. As you go through these comments, I suggest paying attention to how you respond to them. If you notice yourself deflecting or defending yourself, you might want to go deeper on what it means to have a bias.
-
Calling Trump a devil is bias. I didn't vote for him, I don't share many of his values, but there were important social, systemic, and personal reasons that he got elected twice. For example, when you have a legislative body that is unwilling and/or unable to solve national problems, power tends to shift towards a stronger executive regardless of who is in power. This can be dangerous for obvious reasons, but it also provides the opportunity for a capable and benevolent president to be able to make the institutional fixes that need to be made at some point in the future.
-
Any time you judge something as good/bad or right/wrong you are projecting an internal bias onto the world. This is especially evident in anything political. The only way to be objective about politics is to look at things with an analytical lens and seek to understand what exists today, why it is set up that way, and on what path did things evolve to get there. I don't see anything wrong with having political opinions, they determine things about your life, but they are largely out of your control unless you are able to directly influence them yourself. But if you want to be objective, it's important to recognize that they're just opinions.
-
What do you think about the filibuster? Anybody who knows anything about anything in political philosophy should have a thought about the filibuster.
-
Topspin715 replied to Schizophonia's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
Unless you have clearly defined rules by which you judge a party that are applied to all humans in the same situation, you are introducing significant bias in your judgment. The international laws of war strive to create and uphold that degree of objectivity but that legal system is still relatively young in its development, very poorly enforced, and very selectively applied. Under international humanitarian law (IHL), taking and holding hostages is prohibited and constitutes a war crime. If an adversary commits a war crime against you, what is the proper and/or appropriate response? These are not questions that I have the answer to, but really the right questions to be asking before you defend, excuse, or justify any behavior. -
Why shouldn't he read the comments? There are a lot of important counterarguments that can stress test his beliefs and arguments
-
Topspin715 replied to Average Actualizer's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
For a lot of different reasons, Jews are disproportionately the recipients of unfair hatred and criticism, well beyond what one population can or should be required to handle. A lot of times they single out isolated incidents and ascribe guilt to every single Jewish person. There are over 13 million of us. We shouldn't be responsible for deconstructing false or misleading claims for each and every one of us. -
Topspin715 replied to Average Actualizer's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
While Europa: The Last Battle is overwhelmingly a work of historical revisionism and conspiracy theories, there are some elements of truth mixed with distortions. Here are a few aspects where it touches on real historical events but misrepresents them or places them in misleading contexts: 1. Allied War Crimes It is true that the Allies committed some war crimes during and after World War II. Dresden Bombing (1945) – The firebombing of Dresden by British and American forces killed tens of thousands of civilians. Historians debate whether it was a necessary military operation or excessive. Soviet War Crimes – The Red Army engaged in mass rapes and killings during their advance into Germany, particularly in 1945. Operation Keelhaul – The forced repatriation of Soviet citizens and prisoners of war by the British and Americans led to many being executed or sent to gulags. However, Europa exaggerates these crimes while ignoring the overwhelming atrocities committed by Nazi Germany. 2. Post-War Influence of the U.S. and Soviet Union After WWII, the U.S. and the Soviet Union became global superpowers, shaping Europe through NATO and the Warsaw Pact. The U.S. did use economic and political influence to reshape Western Europe (e.g., the Marshall Plan). The Soviet Union imposed communist regimes in Eastern Europe. However, the documentary frames this as a deliberate plot to "destroy" Europe rather than as part of Cold War geopolitics. 3. Banking and Financial Interests Some international bankers and corporations did have economic interests in World War II. Companies like IBM, Ford, and Standard Oil had business dealings with Nazi Germany before the U.S. entered the war. However, Europa takes this fact and spins it into a broad conspiracy about Jewish control of global finance, which is a well-debunked anti-Semitic trope. 4. Cultural and Demographic Changes in Europe The documentary criticizes immigration policies and social changes in post-war Europe. It is true that mass immigration, particularly after the 1960s, changed European demographics and led to political debates on multiculturalism. However, Europa portrays this as a deliberate plan to "eradicate" European identity rather than as a mix of economic, political, and humanitarian factors. Conclusion While Europa includes real events, it manipulates them into a conspiratorial narrative that distorts historical context and intent. It selectively presents facts while ignoring contradictory evidence, ultimately serving as propaganda rather than a serious historical analysis. -
Topspin715 replied to Leo Gura's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
There 1.6m million immigrants in total since the 90s, beyond just the USSR, so no, not even close to 50%. You seem to be very ignorant about history and basic facts so not worth continuing this. -
Topspin715 replied to Leo Gura's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
About a million Jewish people migrated from the Soviet Union to Israel after the USSR collapsed so not even close to a half. This way of seeing the world is so simplistic. Do you think anybody who legally migrates to the US or Europe is a "colonizer"? Colonialism has existed since ancient times. After WW2, the world more or less agreed to respect territorial boundaries, but we have a legacy of colonialism across the entire planet. -
Topspin715 replied to Leo Gura's topic in Society, Politics, Government, Environment, Current Events
95% of Jews living in Israel today were born after 1948 or were less than 18 years old. Modern Jews are also related to the original inhabitants from the Levant, which makes this conflict even worse as they are fairly close genetic relatives.
