Euthanasia (merciful death) controversy

[YIDIRYIDIR]

This one is interesting, a girl from spain went through a lot, demanded to end her life as a merciful act and the government accepted after 2 years.

here's her story:

So Noelia Castillo Ramos was a 25-year-old girl from Spain. Her life got completely messed up after severe trauma and a suicide attempt that left her paralyzed and in constant pain.

She grew up in a broken family with addicted and psychologically unstable parents, so the state took her to a child protection center. In 2022, she was subjected to a gang assault by a group.

She jumped from the fifth floor in an attempt to end her life, but she survived and became paralyzed, suffering from chronic pain and severe psychological issues.

On top of that, she was dealing with heavy psychological struggles since she was a teenager. At some point, she decided she couldn't keep living like that and asked for euthanasia under the law.

It wasn't something quick though. She spent like 2 years going through doctors, evaluations, and courts, while her dad was trying to stop it the whole time. In the end, the courts said she was fully aware and made the decision on her own, so they allowed it.

Here's where the discussion gets heated:

Pros / why people support her choice:

• She suffered intensely and for years, physical and psychological pain.
• She was fully aware of her decision and repeatedly asked for it.
• Traditional treatments and therapies couldn't relieve her suffering enough.
• Autonomy matters: it's her life, her choice.

Cons / why some worry:

• Could be normalized, more people might see euthanasia as an "easy solution" to suffering.
• Vulnerable populations might feel pressure, consciously or unconsciously.
• Psychological suffering sometimes improves with therapy or support, so critics worry euthanasia could happen too early.
• Legal/moral lines are blurred when it's not a terminal illness.
• People claim she could've been saved and the system let her go/failed her
• her family deserves a saying (her dad and sister refused)
• Of course religious and cultural reasons.

My take? Honestly, for her specifically, she wanted it, she was suffering, she repeatedly asked for it for 2 years, so it's her right. The broader society concerns can be dealt with another way.

My question though is, if she was enlightened, would she do the same? if she was conscious of infinite love and God, would that make a difference?